PLAB 2 Clinical Communication & Breaking Bad News 5 โ Questions and Answers
Question 1: A patient dies on the ward of a cause that is not known, and the death may need to be investigated. What should you explain to the family?
- That nothing can be done until the GP is informed
- That the death may be referred to the coroner (or procurator fiscal in Scotland), which might involve a post-mortem (Correct answer)
- That a post-mortem always needs the family's consent
- That a death certificate will be issued straight away
Correct answer: That the death may be referred to the coroner (or procurator fiscal in Scotland), which might involve a post-mortem
Unexplained deaths must be referred to the coroner, who can order a post-mortem without the family's consent.
Question 2: When explaining a new diagnosis of type 2 diabetes, which approach is most appropriate?
- Give a leaflet and tell them to read it at home
- Use medical terms such as 'insulin resistance' and 'HbA1c' without explaining them
- Use plain language, check what the patient already knows, and give written information (Correct answer)
- Focus only on the risks of complications so they take it seriously
Correct answer: Use plain language, check what the patient already knows, and give written information
Plain language, building on what the patient already knows, and written information all support understanding and shared decision-making.
Question 3: In SPIKES, what does the 'I' (Invitation) step involve?
- Introducing yourself and your role
- Inviting the family into the room
- Inviting the patient to a follow-up clinic
- Asking how much information the patient wants to know (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Asking how much information the patient wants to know
The Invitation step asks the patient how much detail they want, which respects their preferences.
Question 4: A patient is crying after hearing that her pregnancy has miscarried. What is the most helpful thing to do?
- Offer tissues, stay with her, acknowledge her loss and give her time (Correct answer)
- Tell her that miscarriage is very common and she can try again
- Explain the medical causes of miscarriage straight away
- Leave her alone with the nurse
Correct answer: Offer tissues, stay with her, acknowledge her loss and give her time
Staying present, acknowledging the loss and allowing time is empathic; comments like 'you can try again' minimise her grief.
Question 5: A patient with a terminal illness says, 'Please don't tell me anything more about my prognosis.' What should you do?
- Tell them anyway, as they have a right to know
- Respect their wish, check whether they would like someone else to be told, and revisit it later if appropriate (Correct answer)
- Tell the family everything without asking the patient
- Stop all further consultations
Correct answer: Respect their wish, check whether they would like someone else to be told, and revisit it later if appropriate
GMC guidance says doctors should respect a patient's wish not to know, while making sure they have the basic information needed for consent.
Question 6: A patient complains that the previous doctor was rude and did not listen. What is the best response?
- Agree that your colleague is often rude
- Defend your colleague's behaviour
- Apologise for their experience, listen to their concerns, and explain how they can give feedback or complain (Correct answer)
- Ignore the comment and carry on with the consultation
Correct answer: Apologise for their experience, listen to their concerns, and explain how they can give feedback or complain
Acknowledge and apologise for the patient's experience without criticising a colleague, and signpost them to PALS or the complaints process.
Question 7: At the end of a bad news consultation, what is the most important step in the 'Strategy and Summary' stage of SPIKES?
- Giving detailed survival statistics
- Ending the consultation quickly so the patient can rest
- Asking the patient to sign a consent form
- Summarising, agreeing a clear plan, checking understanding, and arranging follow-up and support (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Summarising, agreeing a clear plan, checking understanding, and arranging follow-up and support
The final stage makes sure the patient leaves with a clear summary, an agreed plan, follow-up and sources of support.