A treasury director is evaluating two mutually exclusive projects with different initial outlays and cash flow patterns. Project X has a Net Present Value (NPV) of $2.5 million and an Internal Rate of Return (IRR) of 18%. Project Y has an NPV of $2.2 million and an IRR of 22%. The company's WACC is 10%. Which project should be selected and why?
-
A
Project Y, because its IRR is higher, indicating a superior rate of return.
-
B
Both projects should be accepted because their IRRs exceed the WACC.
-
C
Project X, because its higher NPV indicates a greater contribution to shareholder wealth.
-
D
Neither project, as the conflicting signals between NPV and IRR suggest the data is unreliable.