LEAP - Louisiana Educational Assessment Program Interpreting Scientific Data Questions and Answers 1 — Questions and Answers
Question 1: A group of students conducted an experiment to determine how the temperature of water affects the time it takes for a sugar cube to dissolve. They tested four different water temperatures and recorded the dissolving time for each. Their results are displayed in the table below. | Water Temperature (°C) | Time to Dissolve (seconds) | |-----------------------|----------------------------| | 20 | 150 | | 40 | 90 | | 60 | 45 | | 80 | 20 | Which statement is the most valid conclusion based on the data?
- The size of the sugar cube affects the dissolving time.
- As the water temperature increases, the time it takes for the sugar cube to dissolve decreases. (Correct answer)
- Sugar dissolves fastest at a temperature of 60°C.
- Stirring the water is necessary for the sugar to dissolve.
Correct answer: As the water temperature increases, the time it takes for the sugar cube to dissolve decreases.
The data in the table shows a clear pattern: as the temperature in the first column increases (20, 40, 60, 80°C), the time to dissolve in the second column consistently decreases (150, 90, 45, 20 seconds). This demonstrates an inverse relationship between water temperature and dissolving time.
Question 2: A scientist is studying the effect of different types of soil on the growth of bean plants. She plants identical bean seeds in pots containing either sandy soil, clay soil, or loam. Each pot is placed in the same location to receive the same amount of sunlight and is given the same amount of water each day. After four weeks, she measures the height of each plant. In this experiment, what is the dependent variable?
- The amount of water given to each plant.
- The type of soil used in each pot.
- The height of the bean plants. (Correct answer)
- The amount of sunlight each plant receives.
Correct answer: The height of the bean plants.
The dependent variable is the factor that is measured or observed to see how it is affected by changes in the independent variable. In this case, the scientist is measuring the plant height to see how it depends on the type of soil used.
Question 3: The graph below shows the population of deer and wolves in a particular ecosystem over a 50-year period. Which of the following is the most reasonable inference that can be made from this graph? (Image of a line graph with two lines. The 'Deer' line shows cyclical peaks and valleys. The 'Wolf' line also shows cyclical peaks and valleys, but its peaks consistently occur shortly after the deer population peaks, and its valleys occur after the deer population valleys.)
- The wolf population is a predator of the deer population, and their populations are linked. (Correct answer)
- An increase in the deer population causes a decrease in the wolf population.
- The deer and wolf populations compete for the same food source.
- The populations of deer and wolves are unrelated to each other.
Correct answer: The wolf population is a predator of the deer population, and their populations are linked.
The graph shows a classic predator-prey relationship. The wolf population increases shortly after the deer population (their food source) increases. Subsequently, the increased number of wolves leads to a decrease in the deer population, which in turn causes the wolf population to decline due to food scarcity. This cyclical pattern is characteristic of predator-prey dynamics.
Question 4: A student measures the temperature of a classroom every hour for one school day and creates a line graph of the data. The student concludes, 'The temperature in a classroom always increases between 8:00 AM and 3:00 PM.' Why is this conclusion potentially invalid?
- The student should have used a bar graph instead of a line graph.
- The student did not measure the temperature outside the classroom.
- The conclusion is too specific to the hours of a school day.
- The data was collected on only one day, which is not enough evidence to make a general statement. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The data was collected on only one day, which is not enough evidence to make a general statement.
A scientific conclusion must be supported by sufficient evidence. Data from a single day is not enough to make a broad claim about what 'always' happens. The observed trend could have been influenced by unique factors on that specific day (e.g., weather, heating system issues) and may not represent a typical pattern.
Question 5: A bar chart displays the average annual rainfall for four different cities. City A: 15 inches, City B: 45 inches, City C: 30 inches, City D: 15 inches. Which statement accurately compares the data presented in the chart?
- City B receives less rainfall than City C.
- City A and City D have the same average annual rainfall. (Correct answer)
- City C has the highest average annual rainfall.
- All four cities have a similar average annual rainfall.
Correct answer: City A and City D have the same average annual rainfall.
By reading the values from the bar chart, we can see that the bar for City A and the bar for City D both correspond to 15 inches of rainfall. Therefore, their average annual rainfall is the same. The other statements are contradicted by the data.
Question 6: Researchers found a strong positive correlation between the number of hours students spend studying for a test and their scores on that test. Based on this correlation, which is the most appropriate conclusion?
- Spending more time studying is likely to lead to a higher test score. (Correct answer)
- All students who study for many hours will get high scores.
- Studying causes students to perform well on all tests.
- Students who get high scores are naturally better at studying.
Correct answer: Spending more time studying is likely to lead to a higher test score.
A strong positive correlation indicates that as one variable increases, the other tends to increase as well. While correlation does not prove causation, it suggests a likely relationship. Therefore, it is reasonable to conclude that increased study time is associated with and likely contributes to higher scores. The other options are too absolute ('all students') or make an unsupported causal claim in the reverse direction.
LEAP - Louisiana Educational Assessment Program Interpreting Scientific Data Questions and Answers 1
A group of students conducted an experiment to determine how the temperature of water affects the time it takes for a sugar cube to dissolve.
They tested four different water temperatures and recorded the dissolving time for each.
Their results are displayed in the table below.
| Water Temperature (°C) | Time to Dissolve (seconds) |
|-----------------------|----------------------------|
| 20 | 150 |
| 40 | 90 |
| 60 | 45 |
| 80 | 20 |
Which statement is the most valid conclusion based on the data?