NCA Legal Research and Writing in Canadian Context 3

Question 1

In Canadian legal research, what is the difference between 'primary sources' and 'secondary sources'?

Accepted Answer

Primary sources are the law itself (statutes, regulations, case law, treaties); secondary sources are commentary and analysis (textbooks, articles, encyclopedias) that help locate and understand primary sources

Answer

Primary sources are authoritative sources of law: legislation, regulations, case law, and international agreements. Secondary sources (textbooks, law review articles, Halsbury's Laws of Canada, CED) explain, organize, and analyze the primary sources. Research typically begins with secondary sources to understand the framework and identify key primary sources.

Question 2

When a Canadian statute has bilingual versions (English and French), which version prevails if there is a discrepancy?

Accepted Answer

Both versions are equally authoritative; courts interpret the statute using the version that best reflects the common meaning of both

Answer

Under the federal Official Languages Act and interpretive principles established in R v. Daoust [2004] and Medovarski v. Canada [2005], both the English and French versions of a bilingual federal statute are equally authoritative. Where they differ, courts look for the meaning common to both versions.

Question 3

What is the function of headnotes in Canadian law reports?

Accepted Answer

They are summaries prepared by editors to assist readers in identifying the key facts, issues, and holdings; they are not part of the judgment and are not authoritative

Answer

Headnotes are editorial summaries prepared by law report editors. They are not part of the court's reasons and have no legal authority. While useful for quickly identifying cases, lawyers must read the full text of the judgment for accurate understanding and citation.

Question 4

In Canadian public law research, the 'Canada Gazette' serves what purpose?

Accepted Answer

It is the official government publication for federal regulations, orders-in-council, and government notices; Part II contains statutory instruments (regulations)

Answer

The Canada Gazette is the official newspaper of the Government of Canada. Part I publishes proposed regulations and government notices for public comment. Part II publishes statutory instruments (regulations, orders in council) that have been officially enacted. Part III publishes newly enacted federal Acts.

Question 5

In preparing a legal memorandum on a constitutional issue for an NCA exam, which analytical step should come first?

Accepted Answer

Characterize the law using the pith and substance doctrine to identify the relevant head of power and whether the enacting body has jurisdiction

Answer

In constitutional analysis, the first step is always to determine whether the enacting body had jurisdiction under the division of powers (ss. 91/92). If the law is validly enacted (within jurisdiction), then the analysis moves to Charter compliance. Remedies are only reached after a finding of invalidity.

NCA Exam Practice Test

NCA Exam Practice Test

NCA Legal Research and Writing in Canadian Context 3