NCA Criminal Law 2

Question 1

What is the principle of 'proportionality' in Canadian criminal sentencing?

Accepted Answer

The sentence must be proportionate to the gravity of the offence and the degree of responsibility of the offender, as stated in section 718.1 of the Criminal Code

Answer

Section 718.1 establishes proportionality as the fundamental principle of sentencing: 'A sentence must be proportionate to the gravity of the offence and the degree of responsibility of the offender.' This ensures sentences are neither excessively harsh nor inappropriately lenient, considering both the objective seriousness of the crime and the individual circumstances of the offender.

Question 2

What are 'Gladue principles' and how do they affect sentencing in Canada?

Accepted Answer

They require courts to consider the unique systemic and background factors affecting Aboriginal offenders, with particular attention to restorative justice alternatives, as required by section 718.2(e) of the Criminal Code

Answer

Gladue principles (from R v Gladue, 1999) require courts to consider: (1) the unique systemic and background factors that may have brought the Aboriginal offender before the court (colonialism, residential schools, displacement, substance abuse in communities), and (2) the types of sentencing procedures and sanctions that may be appropriate because of the offender's Aboriginal heritage (restorative justice, community-based alternatives). This applies to all Aboriginal offenders, regardless of where they live.

Question 3

What is the 'right to counsel' under section 10(b) of the Charter and what are its informational and implementational components?

Accepted Answer

Upon arrest or detention, the person must be informed of their right to counsel without delay (informational), and the police must provide a reasonable opportunity to contact counsel and must refrain from eliciting evidence until the person has done so (implementational)

Answer

Section 10(b) has two components: (1) Informational — the detainee must be promptly informed of the right to retain and instruct counsel, including the availability of Legal Aid and duty counsel; (2) Implementational — police must provide a reasonable opportunity to contact counsel, refrain from questioning or eliciting evidence until the right is exercised, and cease questioning if the detainee exercises their right. Violations may lead to exclusion of evidence under s.24(2).

Question 4

What is 'joint liability' for parties to an offence under sections 21 and 22 of the Criminal Code?

Accepted Answer

A person is a party to an offence if they actually commit it, aid or abet its commission, or form a common intention to carry out an unlawful purpose with another person — parties are equally liable

Answer

Section 21 provides three modes of party liability: (1) actually committing the offence, (2) aiding (assisting) its commission, or (3) abetting (encouraging) its commission. Section 21(2) extends liability to common intention — where two or more persons form an intention to carry out an unlawful purpose and an offence is committed in its carrying out, each is a party if the offence was foreseeable. Section 22 covers counselling an offence.

Question 5

What is the 'right to be tried within a reasonable time' under section 11(b) of the Charter, as reframed by R v Jordan (2016)?

Accepted Answer

The SCC established presumptive ceilings of 18 months for provincial court cases and 30 months for superior court cases; delays exceeding these are presumptively unreasonable unless the Crown demonstrates exceptional circumstances

Answer

R v Jordan (2016) fundamentally changed the s.11(b) framework. The SCC established presumptive ceilings: 18 months for cases in provincial court and 30 months for cases in superior court (or cases in provincial court after a preliminary inquiry). If delay exceeds the ceiling, it is presumptively unreasonable unless the Crown proves exceptional circumstances. Below the ceiling, the defence must show the delay is markedly departed from reasonable.

NCA Exam Practice Test

NCA Exam Practice Test

NCA Criminal Law 2