NCA Administrative Law 4

Question 1

Which statutory provision gives the Federal Court authority to grant remedies on judicial review, including certiorari, mandamus, and prohibition?

Accepted Answer

Section 18 and 18.1 of the Federal Courts Act

Answer

Sections 18 and 18.1 of the Federal Courts Act grant the Federal Court exclusive jurisdiction to issue certiorari, mandamus, prohibition, quo warranto, and injunctions against federal boards, and set out the grounds for judicial review including procedural unfairness and jurisdictional error.

Question 2

A professional regulatory body refuses to license a foreign-trained lawyer without providing a hearing or reasons. Which administrative law principle is most directly engaged?

Accepted Answer

The duty of procedural fairness, which is particularly robust when an important professional interest is at stake

Answer

When a decision significantly affects an individual's ability to practise a profession, the duty of procedural fairness requires meaningful notice of the reasons for refusal and an opportunity to respond. A bare refusal without reasons or hearing would likely violate fairness.

Question 3

What is the effect of a privative clause in a statute that purports to shield an administrative decision from judicial review?

Accepted Answer

It signals legislative intent for deference but does not eliminate review for jurisdictional excess or constitutional violations

Answer

Privative clauses signal that the legislature wants courts to defer to the tribunal. They support reasonableness review but cannot oust judicial review entirely—courts retain jurisdiction to review for jurisdictional excess, breach of natural justice, and constitutional violations under s. 96 and the rule of law.

Question 4

The doctrine of 'issue estoppel' in administrative law prevents a party from re-litigating an issue already decided. Which SCC case addressed this in the administrative context and recognized the courts' residual discretion to decline to apply the doctrine?

Accepted Answer

Danyluk v. Ainsworth Technologies Inc. [2001]

Answer

Danyluk v. Ainsworth [2001] established that even where the preconditions of issue estoppel are met (same issue, final decision, same parties), courts retain residual discretion to decline to apply the doctrine where doing so would work an injustice.

Question 5

Which writ compels a public authority to perform a public duty it has refused or failed to perform?

Accepted Answer

Mandamus

Answer

Mandamus ('we command') compels a public authority to perform a ministerial or public duty where it has jurisdiction and a duty to act. It is available when the authority has refused to exercise a power it is legally obligated to exercise.

NCA Exam Practice Test

NCA Exam Practice Test

NCA Administrative Law 4