Multistate Bar Examination (MBE) — Questions and Answers
Question 1: A plaintiff files suit in State X federal court. The defendant is incorporated in State Y but has its principal place of business in State X. The plaintiff is a citizen of State X. Is diversity jurisdiction available?
- Yes, because incorporation and principal place of business are considered separately
- No, because corporations cannot be sued in federal court under diversity
- No, because the defendant is deemed a citizen of both State Y and State X, destroying complete diversity (Correct answer)
- Yes, because the defendant is incorporated in State Y
Correct answer: No, because the defendant is deemed a citizen of both State Y and State X, destroying complete diversity
Under 28 U.S.C. § 1332(c)(1), a corporation is deemed a citizen of every state where it is incorporated and the state where it has its principal place of business; since the defendant is a citizen of State X, complete diversity with the plaintiff (also State X) is destroyed.
Question 2: A negative easement prevents a servient estate owner from doing something on their land. Which of the following is a recognized traditional negative easement?
- Blocking a neighbor's view of a scenic mountain
- Obstructing light and air reaching the dominant estate (Correct answer)
- Preventing the servient owner from playing loud music
- Parking vehicles on a shared driveway
Correct answer: Obstructing light and air reaching the dominant estate
Traditional negative easements include light, air, support, and streamflow — courts historically refused to expand this list to include view easements.
Question 3: A witness testifies she cannot recall the events in question. The party who called her seeks to refresh her recollection using a document. Under FRE 612, the opposing party:
- Must stipulate to the document's authenticity
- May inspect the document, cross-examine on it, and introduce relevant portions (Correct answer)
- May demand the witness read the entire document into evidence
- Has no rights regarding the document used
Correct answer: May inspect the document, cross-examine on it, and introduce relevant portions
FRE 612 grants the opposing party the right to inspect any writing used to refresh a witness's recollection and to introduce relevant portions.
Question 4: A high school student was running for president of the student council. He was a top scholar who had been selected to be the class valedictorian. Inexplicably, he gave a campaign speech at a school assembly that was filled with graphic stories and anecdotes about the imagined sexual adventures and prowess of certain teachers and students. Several teachers and students complained. The principal suspended him for five days and retracted the valedictorian honors. The student, with his parents, sued in federal court, seeking an injunction and damages based on denial of First Amendment free speech rights. The federal courts ruled for the student but the case came before the U.S. Supreme Court for final decision. Did the Supreme Court uphold the relief granted to the student?
- Yes, in today’s society sexual images and sexual humor is so intertwined into the fabric of society that it is something that has to be tolerated in the interest of free speech.
- Yes, despite some inconvenience to teachers and students, the immature presentation must be tolerated in deference to the need to provide platforms for free speech to students.
- No, the student had no rights to free speech, especially considering the violent disruptions in the schools in recent years.
- No, the school exercised its appropriate function of trying to restrict the use of vulgarity and offensive discourse in a high school setting where free speech may be limited. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: No, the school exercised its appropriate function of trying to restrict the use of vulgarity and offensive discourse in a high school setting where free speech may be limited.
The state has interests in teaching high school students how to conduct civil and effective public discourse and in avoiding disruption of educational school activities. In a high school setting, although political expression is generally not restricted, students do not have the same latitude given to adults. See Bethel School Dist. No. 403 v. Fraser, 478 US 675 (1986).
Question 5: A foreman in a slaughterhouse approached three female workers who were taking a proper 15-minute break and accused them of laziness, not doing their jobs, incompetency and taking an unauthorized break. He shouted profanities, various insults and accused them of “breaking the rules.” After a one-minute tirade, he left the area. One of the workers, a 69-year-old woman, became immediately ill, with complaints of chest pains, shortness of breath and anxiety. The employer transported her to a local hospital, where she remained for two days. Although all tests were negative, the doctor diagnosed severe panic attack. Despite no need for further treatment, and an apology from the foreman, she remained upset and stressed. She sued the foreman and the company for one count of intentional infliction of emotional distress, along with other claims. The defendants filed a motion to dismiss the intentional infliction count for failure to state a legal claim. Will the judge grant the motion and dismiss the intentional infliction count preliminarily?
- Yes, because a one-minute tirade of obscenities in a work environment is not so extreme and outrageous as to qualify for the intentional infliction of emotional distress tort. (Correct answer)
- No, the obscenities and the personal insults were so outrageous and extreme that no reasonable employee could endure the experience.
- No, the foreman knew or should have known that his tirade would cause severe emotional distress, so that he acted intentionally.
- Yes, because the tort requires a physical touching to accompany the insults and outrageous behavior and no physical contact occurred.
Correct answer: Yes, because a one-minute tirade of obscenities in a work environment is not so extreme and outrageous as to qualify for the intentional infliction of emotional distress tort.
See Howell v. New York Post Co., 81 NY 2d 115, 122 (NY Ct of Appeals 1993) (Liability is found only where the conduct has been so atrocious, outrageous and so extreme as to go beyond all possible bounds of decency, and must be “utterly intolerable in a civilized community”). See Murphy v. American Home Products, 58 N.Y.2d 293, 303, citing Restatement [Second] of Torts § 46, comment d (Liability does not extend to mere insults, indignities, threats, annoyances, petty oppressions, or other trivialities). See also, Hoffmann-La Roche Inc. v. Zeltwanger, 144 SW 3d 438, 445 (TX Sup.Ct. 2004) (behavior must be so severe and outrageous that no reasonable person could be expected to endure it). The defendant must have intended to inflict emotional distress, and the plaintiff’s reaction must be very severe. The current facts just don’t qualify for that kind of outrageousness. If this type of somewhat common temper tantrum were given actionable status in the workplace, the flood-gates would be opened to an overflow of cases, which is frowned upon by the courts.
Question 6: A father made out a deed to a parcel of farmland to his three daughters, as joint tenants. State law recognizes the right of survivorship among joint tenants. The youngest sister sold her interest to an unrelated purchaser for value. The eldest sister then died. After that sister’s death, the remaining sister sold her interest to one of her cousins. What is the resulting status of the ownership interests in the land?
- The purchaser for value owns a two-thirds interest as a tenant in common with the cousin, who holds a one-third interest.
- The purchaser for value owns a one-third interest, the heirs of the eldest sister own another one-third, and the cousin owns one-third, all holding their separate interests as tenants in common.
- The purchaser for value owns a one-third interest as a tenant in common with the cousin, who owns a two-thirds interest. (Correct answer)
- The purchaser for value owns a one-third interest as joint tenant with the cousin.
Correct answer: The purchaser for value owns a one-third interest as a tenant in common with the cousin, who owns a two-thirds interest.
When one joint tenant conveys their interest to a third party, it severs the joint tenancy as to that interest, converting it into a tenancy in common. Thus, the purchaser owns 1/3 as a tenant in common. The remaining two sisters still held their 2/3 interest as joint tenants with each other; when the eldest died, her 1/3 passed to the remaining sister by right of survivorship, making that sister own 2/3. When the remaining sister then sold her 2/3 interest to the cousin, the cousin became a tenant in common with the purchaser.
Question 7: A defendant is served with a complaint. Under the Federal Rules, within how many days must the defendant serve an answer if served within the United States?
- 30 days
- 14 days
- 28 days
- 21 days (Correct answer)
Correct answer: 21 days
Under FRCP 12(a)(1)(A)(i), a defendant must serve an answer within 21 days after being served with the summons and complaint.
Question 8: An owner leased land to a tenant who said that he was going to use the land for farming. The tract contained farmland and dozens of acres of pristine, scenic woodlands that were part of the view from the owner’s adjoining residence. The owner noticed that the tenant was cutting down trees and selling them to companies who manufactured wood and paper products. After a while, 20 acres or so had been cut down and the activity was continuing, leaving a ravaged sight on the land. Does the landlord have a right to stop the activity and recover the value of the lost trees?
- This is ameliorative waste, which actually improves the value by having a profitable business on site; the tenant will not be held liable because he has improved the property.
- Under the doctrine of transfer of leasehold estate, the tenant may change the original use intended and perform any legal use that he wishes.
- This is voluntary waste to the property, which is prohibited by most leases; the tenant may be ordered to pay for the value of the waste, stop further activities, and is subject to being evicted. (Correct answer)
- The landlord cannot interfere with lawful activities conducted by the tenant, and in this case the use of inactive trees that are mere woodlands cannot be prohibited.
Correct answer: This is voluntary waste to the property, which is prohibited by most leases; the tenant may be ordered to pay for the value of the waste, stop further activities, and is subject to being evicted.
Voluntary waste is the willful destruction and carrying away of something that is attached to the premises. It creates injury and some form of damage to the leased premises. Although he is conducting a business, this particular business is like strip mining, where once the activity is completed, there is no further profit to be gained but instead the property has lost in its intrinsic value and turned into an eyesore. In all likelihood, damages and an injunction would be granted in this case.
Question 9: An elderly man died with a will that had the following clause: “After payment of such debts and funeral expenses, I give and bequeath to my beloved wife the farm on which we now reside and all my personal property, so long as she remains my widow; the remainder on her remarriage or death to go to my son John..” Which one of the following estates in real property most closely reflects the wife’s interest upon her husband’s death?
- It is a life estate that ends on her remarriage or death, with a remainder over to the son. (Correct answer)
- It is a fee simple with a precedent condition.
- It is a devise of a fee simple absolute.
- It is a vested and contingent remainder;
Correct answer: It is a life estate that ends on her remarriage or death, with a remainder over to the son.
The clause "so long as she remains my widow" creates a determinable life estate for the wife. This means her interest in the property will automatically terminate upon the occurrence of either her death or her remarriage. The subsequent phrase "the remainder on her remarriage or death to go to my son John" clearly establishes a vested remainder interest in fee simple for John, which will become possessory upon the termination of the wife's life estate.
Question 10: Under the equitable mortgage doctrine, a deed absolute on its face will be treated as a mortgage when:
- The grantor retains possession
- The grantee fails to record the deed
- The deed lacks consideration
- The parties intended the deed as security for a debt (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The parties intended the deed as security for a debt
Courts apply the equitable mortgage doctrine when evidence shows the parties intended a conveyance to function as security for repayment of a debt.
Question 11: A defendant enters a building through an unlocked door, intending to commit theft inside. Under common law, is this burglary?
- No, because there was no breaking (Correct answer)
- Yes, because entering through any door satisfies the entry element
- No, because theft is not a felony at common law
- Yes, because intent to commit a felony inside is sufficient
Correct answer: No, because there was no breaking
Common law burglary requires a 'breaking,' which means creating or enlarging an opening; walking through an unlocked door does not satisfy this element.
Question 12: A defendant in a criminal trial does not testify. The prosecutor in closing argument comments, 'The defendant chose not to explain away the evidence.' This violates:
- The Fourth Amendment protection against unreasonable searches
- The Sixth Amendment Confrontation Clause
- The defendant's Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination (Correct answer)
- The defendant's Eighth Amendment rights
Correct answer: The defendant's Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination
The Fifth Amendment, along with FRE 513 and Griffin v. California, prohibits adverse comment on a criminal defendant's failure to testify.
Question 13: A married couple own a residential premises. They received a foreclosure action from the first mortgage lender in a state that has judicial foreclosure procedures. The state also statutorily extends the right of redemption both prior to the sale, and for a period of one year after the sale. The sale took place; the property was sold to the lender. The lender then filed a deficiency judgment action. The couple received a loan from family members about six months after the sale. It was sufficient to pay the balance on the mortgage plus interest and costs. The couple notified the lender and the court of their intent to exercise their right of redemption. What is the likely outcome?
- The court will order the couple evicted because they should have acted prior to the entry of the deficiency judgment.
- The court ruled that the lender did not have a right to file a deficiency judgment, and it ordered the foreclosure action null and void without the couple having to exercise the right of redemption
- A hearing must first be held to determine whether abatement has occurred.
- The couple will exercise their right of redemption to retain ownership of their property. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The couple will exercise their right of redemption to retain ownership of their property.
A statutory right of redemption allows a mortgagor to reclaim their property after a foreclosure sale by paying the sale price, plus interest and costs, within a specified statutory period. Since the state provides a one-year post-sale redemption period and the couple secured funds and notified their intent within six months, they are within the statutory timeframe and can successfully exercise their right to redeem the property.
Question 14: A man has a residence and is domiciled in State A. He sues a former friend who is a resident and domiciliary of State B in a federal district court in State A on the grounds of a civil assault that occurred in State A. The plaintiff is a U.S. citizen and the defendant is a citizen of France who is lawfully admitted for permanent residence in the United States. The man claims damages in excess of $100,000. Does he have federal diversity jurisdiction under Section 1332(a) in State A to bring the civil assault complaint, and why or why not?
- No, because the defendant is a citizen of another country and not subject to diversity jurisdiction.
- Yes, because the defendant is a citizen of France and a permanent resident who is domiciled in another state. (Correct answer)
- Yes, because the two live in different states and that is all that is required for diversity jurisdiction.
- No, because as a permanent resident the defendant is not subject to diversity jurisdiction.
Correct answer: Yes, because the defendant is a citizen of France and a permanent resident who is domiciled in another state.
Under 28 U.S.C. § 1332(a)(2), federal courts have diversity jurisdiction over civil actions between a citizen of a state and a citizen or subject of a foreign state. Furthermore, an alien admitted for permanent residence is deemed a citizen of the state in which they are domiciled. Since the defendant is a citizen of France and a permanent resident domiciled in State B, and the plaintiff is a U.S. citizen domiciled in State A, there is complete diversity between citizens of different states, satisfying the requirements for federal diversity jurisdiction.
Question 15: Defendants agreed to lease to plaintiffs a building that they were going to build. The lease was for a period of 10 years. The lease of the building was to commence upon the “completion of the building.” The defendants were bound in the agreement to start “forthwith” and proceed to build the building “expeditiously” after receiving all permits, and to complete the project in a reasonable time. Plaintiffs put $10,000 down on the rental agreement. Plaintiffs and defendants started arguing about other terms, such as who was to pay for an expensive sprinkler system. Eventually, plaintiffs sued for rescission and for return of the down payment. One of the main contentions of the plaintiffs was that the agreement violated the rule against perpetuities in that it was impossible to tell whether it could be performed within 21 years due to the ambiguity over when the building would be completed. What is the likely decision of the court?
- The rule must be applied very strictly in commercial transactions to make sure that the performance is not intentionally delayed beyond reason.
- The court would favor an interpretation that does not unduly interfere with commercial transactions, and here it appears that the building will easily be completed within 21 years. (Correct answer)
- The court would favor enforcement of the rule, and would interpret all of the contingencies involved to be so speculative that it could not be said that the building would be completed within 21 years.
- The rule against perpetuities does not apply to leases and therefore the agreement is enforceable.
Correct answer: The court would favor an interpretation that does not unduly interfere with commercial transactions, and here it appears that the building will easily be completed within 21 years.
Generally, modern cases hold that a document should be interpreted if feasible to avoid the conclusion that it violates the rule against perpetuities. The mandates for expeditious action, to start forthwith and complete within a reasonable time all militate toward finishing within 21 years. The court will not assume that the parties will breach their promises in order to be able to apply the rule against perpetuities to invalidate the transaction. See Wong v. Di Grazia, 60 Cal. 2d 525(Cal. Supreme Court 1963).
Question 16: An industrial manufacturing plant was producing large volumes of a new chemical combination to be marketed worldwide that was guaranteed to instantly and humanely kill death row inmates receiving their executions. The plant was blowing the exhaust fumes from the manufacturing process out into the atmosphere through massive industrial fans, apparently to help protect employees inside the complex. On days with a wind in the air, the invisible particles were traveling to adjacent neighborhoods and creating a permanent, invisible coating that was detectable by scientific testing. The highly dangerous chemical film had destroyed a number of residential homes – consulting experts advised the residents to move out of the homes and to raze the structures. These residents brought actions against the manufacturing plant for the damages they suffered, including pain, suffering and distress. What is the likely successful theory that they will assert against the manufacturer?
- Trespass to land, property and persons.
- The tort of physical intrusion and impairment.
- Strict liability for an abnormally dangerous condition or activity. (Correct answer)
- Environmental destruction under the Superfund Act.
Correct answer: Strict liability for an abnormally dangerous condition or activity.
Strict liability applies to abnormally dangerous activities, which create a foreseeable and highly significant risk of harm even with reasonable care, and are not matters of common usage. Manufacturing highly dangerous chemicals that can destroy homes through invisible emissions, regardless of precautions, fits this description. The plant's activity is inherently dangerous, and the harm is a direct result of that danger, making strict liability the most appropriate theory for recovery.
Question 17: A state passed a statute that prevents the sale of violent video games to minors. The act prohibits video games being sold or rented to minors where the player may have a choice of killing, maiming, dismembering or sexually assaulting an image of a human being in a manner that appeals to a deviant or morbid interest of minors and offends prevailing community standards of what is suitable for minors. The Petitioners, representing various interests of the video game industry, brought an action in federal court to have the statute declared unconstitutional. The video game industry has a voluntary rating system (like the one relating to movies) to assist parents. The state did not present evidence showing a connection between violent videos and violence in children. Based on U.S. Supreme Court precedence, what is the most likely decision of the federal court?
- The statute is constitutional because it meets a compelling government interest and it is drawn narrowly to fit very specific dangers.
- The statute is unconstitutional because it is does not meet a compelling state interest that would allow for restrictions on free speech. (Correct answer)
- The statute is constitutional because the restrictions are obviously going to reduce the crime rate among minors.
- The statute is unconstitutional because minors have unlimited rights under the First Amendment.
Correct answer: The statute is unconstitutional because it is does not meet a compelling state interest that would allow for restrictions on free speech.
In *Brown v. Entertainment Merchants Association* (2011), the Supreme Court held that video games are a form of speech protected by the First Amendment. To restrict such speech, the state must demonstrate a compelling government interest and that the law is narrowly tailored. Since the state failed to present evidence showing a causal link between violent video games and violence in children, it could not meet the compelling interest standard, rendering the statute unconstitutional.
Question 18: A defendant answers a complaint but fails to raise the defense of insufficient service of process. Under FRCP 12(h)(1), what is the consequence?
- The defense survives until trial
- The defendant may raise it in a later motion
- The defense is waived (Correct answer)
- The court must dismiss the case sua sponte
Correct answer: The defense is waived
Under FRCP 12(h)(1), the defenses of lack of personal jurisdiction, improper venue, insufficient process, and insufficient service of process are waived if not included in the first responsive pleading or a pre-answer motion.
Question 19: A man signed an agreement to purchase real estate from a woman for $10,000. He put $250 down at the time of signing the contract but was bound to put up another $750 within 10 days, so as to equal a total of 10% down, as per the written contract terms. The ten days passed without the balance being deposited. The purchaser’s broker told him that the title search revealed an ancient easement over the rear of the property allowing a farmer to take his sheep across the land. Nothing more was said about it. About 30 days after the date of the agreement, the seller gave written notice that she did not intend to perform the agreement and enclosed the check for $250 to the purchaser. The purchaser did not cash that check and put the remaining $750 in the escrow. He then sued for specific performance. Will the court enforce the agreement and compel the seller to sell under the contract?
- Yes, because the seller breached the contract without reason and the buyer has a right to compel conveyance of the specific property.
- No, because the purchaser breached the agreement by not putting up the balance of the down payment in time, and he had no right to delay just because of rumors about the title search. (Correct answer)
- Yes, because the buyer did not have to put the remaining down payment in the escrow account until the seller cleared title and the problem with the easement.
- No, because the court will not compel a seller that has a cloud on title to sell to the purchaser without first showing proof that the title is cleared.
Correct answer: No, because the purchaser breached the agreement by not putting up the balance of the down payment in time, and he had no right to delay just because of rumors about the title search.
A suit for specific performance cannot be enforced in favor of one who has not fully and fairly performed all conditions precedent on his part. Failure to pay the money within the specified time deprives the purchaser of his right of action to enforce performance. If he had a problem with the title search he had a duty to complain and demand a refund, but he did not do that.
Question 20: A cotenant in a tenancy in common exclusively possesses the entire property and excludes the other cotenant. The excluded cotenant may bring an action for:
- Ejectment only
- Partition only
- Ouster and recover a proportionate share of rental value (Correct answer)
- Quiet title
Correct answer: Ouster and recover a proportionate share of rental value
When one cotenant ousts another by exclusive possession, the ousted cotenant may recover their proportionate share of fair rental value.
Question 21: A court must determine whether a contract was formed. Witness testimony and written documents are introduced. Which standard applies to this preliminary question of fact?
- Preponderance of the evidence under FRE 104(a) (Correct answer)
- Proof beyond a reasonable doubt
- Clear and convincing evidence
- The court defers entirely to the jury
Correct answer: Preponderance of the evidence under FRE 104(a)
Under FRE 104(a), the court determines preliminary questions of fact regarding admissibility under a preponderance of the evidence standard.
Question 22: A broker and a seller of residential real estate entered into an “exclusive right to sell” contract (an exclusive listing agreement) in which the broker had the exclusive right to sell the property for the period of nine months and would receive 6% of the sales price if the property was put under agreement during that nine-month period. The agreement also stated that “if the property is withdrawn from sale, transferred, conveyed, leased without the consent of Broker, or made unmarketable by the owner's voluntary act during the term hereof or any extension thereof," the broker would receive 6% of the selling price of the property as set forth in the listing agreement.” The broker began performing all of its duties in aggressively trying to sell the property, but shortly after the agreement, the seller advised that it didn’t want to sell anymore, and it thwarted all efforts of the broker to take further action to sell the property. The broker demanded the 6% amount set forth in the withdrawal of sale provision, but the seller claimed a right to change his mind. Will the court likely enforce the broker’s claim for 6% of the listed price?
- Yes, because this is a typical enforceable contractual provision that the courts have upheld, and which reflected the intent of the parties in case of a premature rejection of the agreement by the seller. (Correct answer)
- No, the clause is unconstitutional because a person cannot be forced to pay for a service that it decides it doesn’t want.
- Yes, because the broker is entitled to an amount in restitution to repay it for the value of the time it spent trying to sell the home.
- No, the clause is unconstitutional because a person cannot be forced to pay for a service that it decides it doesn’t want.
Correct answer: Yes, because this is a typical enforceable contractual provision that the courts have upheld, and which reflected the intent of the parties in case of a premature rejection of the agreement by the seller.
'Exclusive right to sell' agreements often include clauses that entitle the broker to a commission if the seller withdraws the property from the market during the contract term. These clauses are generally enforceable as they compensate the broker for their efforts and the lost opportunity to earn a commission, reflecting the bargained-for exchange and the intent of the parties. The seller's unilateral decision to withdraw the property triggers this contractual obligation.
Question 23: A teenage girl was babysitting a two-year-old baby. She took the baby in a stroller to the public park, as she often did. On this day, she negligently "nodded off" for just a few seconds on a park bench with the stroller next to her. She felt some movement and snapped awake to see a man taking the baby from the stroller. The man was large and menacing-looking. The babysitter, who is thin and petite, froze and did not put up a struggle as the man stated, "I will kill you if you move." The babysitter did scream and call for help as the kidnapper fled with the child. Within a few yards he tripped and dropped the baby on its head. The baby died at the hospital of massive head injuries. Is it probable that the prosecutor will charge the babysitter with a crime, and if so, what will be the charge?
- Yes, she would be charged with negligent homicide because it was foreseeable that if she fell asleep for even just a few seconds, the baby would likely be kidnapped and killed.
- No, the babysitter did not commit a criminal act under the circumstances — her negligence was not gross enough to rise to the level of criminality and she had no criminal intent. (Correct answer)
- Yes, this is felony murder in that the babysitter's unacceptable behavior was committed during a the commission of the kidnapping felony.
- No, because she did not do anything wrong in dozing off and she had no duty to protect the baby at the expense of her own life.
Correct answer: No, the babysitter did not commit a criminal act under the circumstances — her negligence was not gross enough to rise to the level of criminality and she had no criminal intent.
While the babysitter was negligent in dozing off, criminal negligence requires a gross deviation from the standard of care, often involving a high degree of risk and a conscious disregard for that risk. Her brief dozing off, while negligent, likely does not meet the high threshold for criminal negligence or the specific intent required for more serious crimes. Furthermore, she was under duress when the kidnapper threatened her life, which could negate criminal liability for failing to resist.
Question 24: The police were at the scene of an accident, assisting injured victims and clearing traffic. One car stopped in traffic was creating a distraction by blasting rap music. A police officer told the driver to turn it down, which he did. While explaining this, the officer spotted a handgun next to the driver on the seat. State law allowed the carrying of a concealed or unconcealed weapon. The officer ordered him out of the car for safety concerns. The officer drew her gun and pointed it at him as he got out, threatening to shoot him if he was not compliant. Other officers approached with weapons drawn. The driver was put on the ground and handcuffed. Drugs were found inside the car and he was charged with drug possession. He filed a motion to suppress, claiming a Fourth Amendment violation. What is the most likely decision of the court?
- The drugs will be suppressed because the officer had no right to order the driver out of the car simply because a legal weapon was observed on the seat.
- The driver was acting erratically by blasting music in the middle of an auto accident investigation, and when a gun was spotted this justified a custodial interrogation and a search of the car.
- The officer in effect overreacted to the initial purpose of the stop, and initiated an arrest procedure without probable cause to do so, and thus the drugs will be suppressed. (Correct answer)
- The officer had a right to separate the driver from the gun, and the ensuing procedures and search were reasonably calculated to protect the officers and the other motorists.
Correct answer: The officer in effect overreacted to the initial purpose of the stop, and initiated an arrest procedure without probable cause to do so, and thus the drugs will be suppressed.
The officer’s failure to use less intrusive means to assure safety was unreasonable. The traffic hazard justified a minimal intrusion, and was alleviated when he turned the music down. She could reasonably order him out of the car in order to separate him from the gun, which was nonetheless a legal weapon under state law. But her conduct then escalated excessively out of proportion and initiated what was essentially an arrest procedure, which was not reasonably related in scope to the reason for the initial interference. See US v. King, 990 F. 2d 1552 (10th Circ. 1993); Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1, 88 S.Ct. 1868, 20 L.Ed.2d 889 (1967); Pennsylvania v. Mimms, 434 U.S. 106, 98 S.Ct. 330, 54 L.Ed.2d 331 (1977) (per curiam).
Question 25: A retail salesperson was driving her car at lunch when a man driving an SUV drove through a red light and struck her. The salesperson resided in State A and the accident occurred in State A. The driver of the SUV was employed by a company that was located in State B. The company allowed the employee to take its SUV, which was used most of the time for business purposes, to go home to State A every night and return to work in State B in the morning. The injured retail salesperson sued both the company and the driver in a State A court. The company filed a motion to dismiss claiming that the State A court did not have personal jurisdiction over the company, despite having over its employee. The trial court dismissed the case against the company for lack of personal jurisdiction. Will that decision likely survive on appeal and why or why not?
- Yes, because the company was not doing busines in State A and therefore it had no contact with the state.
- No, the mere act of the company's car being in State A was enough to establish personal jurisdiction over the company.
- Yes, because the company did not benefit from giving the employee a car to commute with, thus it had no minimum contacts with the forum state.
- No, the company benefited from having its employee commute from State A to State B and it is responsible for the acts of its agent. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: No, the company benefited from having its employee commute from State A to State B and it is responsible for the acts of its agent.
Personal jurisdiction over an out-of-state company requires sufficient minimum contacts with the forum state such that exercising jurisdiction comports with due process. Here, the company benefited from its employee commuting daily from State A in a company-owned SUV, which was primarily used for business. The accident occurred in State A while the employee was driving this company vehicle, establishing a direct connection between the company's purposeful availment of the forum state and the plaintiff's injury. Therefore, State A has specific personal jurisdiction over the company.
Question 26: A state recidivist statute made it a felony punishable by life imprisonment without parole to be convicted for the sixth time of any form of criminal theft involving goods or money in excess of $500. A man’s record showed five prior convictions for different forms of theft, each one for property or cash in excess of $500 but usually not in excess of $1,000. On the sixth conviction for a similar violation, he was sentenced to life without parole. He challenged the sentence based on the Eighth Amendment prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment. He appeals all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. Is the Supreme Court likely to invalidate the sentence on these facts?
- No, because it is improper for the courts to attempt to interject their value judgments into a state’s ostensibly reasonable legislative sentencing schemes.
- Yes, because life imprisonment can never be an appropriate punishment for criminality that does not take human life.
- Yes, because the gravity of the sentence is disproportionate to the seriousness of the crimes, none of which involved bodily injury. (Correct answer)
- No, because theft and theft by deception are heinous crimes causing extreme human suffering and negatively impacting the economy.
Correct answer: Yes, because the gravity of the sentence is disproportionate to the seriousness of the crimes, none of which involved bodily injury.
One of the principles of the Eighth Amendment is that the punishment must be proportionate to the crime for which the defendant has been convicted. It is likely that the court would here follow the reasoning that it provided in Solem v. Helm, 463 U.S. 277 (1983) where the Court found similar conduct to be “relatively minor” and not deserving of the “penultimate sentence.” The harsh treatment is more than others in the state and other states have received for more serious crimes and criminal records.
Question 27: A man wearing a jacket and jeans walked along a city street at night in a high crime area known for drug trafficking and gun violence. He saw two police officers walking toward him. The officers were checking on a 911 call from a resident who observed a man in jeans and a jacket apparently selling drugs to people on the street. When the police first saw him, he was walking alone, in the area that the woman identified. As they approached, he suddenly crossed the street by jaywalking. They followed, and approaching from behind, asked him to stop. He started walking faster, away from them. The officers saw what appeared to be a heavy object bulging in his pocket as he moved. The officers, with over 10 years of foot patrol experience, stepped up and stopped him. They patted him down and found a concealed, unlicensed handgun in the jacket pocket. They then made a full search and found 50 packets of heroin. He filed a motion to suppress the gun and drug evidence. Will the court likely suppress the evidence?
- Yes, because the police lacked reasonable suspicion to stop the man simply because he crossed the street and walked faster away from them.
- No, because the police had probable cause to make an arrest when the man began to walk away from them and walk even faster as they followed him.
- Yes, because they didn’t know if this was the same man, they observed nothing illegal except jaywalking, and he had a right to avoid them under the circumstances.
- No, because the accumulation of factors all added up to reasonable suspicion for a stop and articulable suspicion for a frisk. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: No, because the accumulation of factors all added up to reasonable suspicion for a stop and articulable suspicion for a frisk.
There must be reasonable suspicion of criminal activity to make a Terry stop. This is an objective standard, asking whether a reasonable police officer, faced with these circumstances, would believe that criminal activity was afoot. United States v. Patton, 705 F.3d 734, 738 (7th Cir.2013), (citing Terry, 392 U.S. at 27). The inquiry looks at all of the factors, not just one or two. See US v. Williams, 731 F. 3d 678, 695-96 (7th Cir. 2013). The officer needs even more for a frisk; this requires an articulable suspicion that the subject is "armed and dangerous." Arizona v. Johnson, 555 U.S. 323 (2009); United States v. Pedroza, 269 F.3d 821, 827 (2001), citing Terry, 392 U.S. at 27. The further inquiry is due to frisks being severe intrusions upon individual liberty. Terry, 392 U.S. at 27. Here, there is high crime, gun violence, drug activities, very experienced officers, poor lighting, a 911 call, trying to avoid the officers, and a bulging in the jacket, along with wearing a jacket and jeans and being in the same area where the activity was reported, all of which together justify both the stop and the frisk.
Question 28: During trial, a party attempts to impeach their own witness after the witness gives damaging testimony. Under FRE 607:
- A party may impeach their own witness only with written inconsistent statements
- A party may impeach their own witness only with prior convictions
- A party may never impeach their own witness
- A party may impeach any witness, including their own (Correct answer)
Correct answer: A party may impeach any witness, including their own
FRE 607 abolished the common law voucher rule and permits any party, including the calling party, to impeach any witness.
Question 29: In a products liability case, plaintiff offers expert testimony that the product was defectively designed. The expert bases his opinion solely on other experts' reports not in evidence. Under FRE 703, this is:
- Inadmissible because the expert must have personal knowledge
- Inadmissible because secondary sources cannot support expert opinion
- Admissible if experts in the field reasonably rely on such reports (Correct answer)
- Admissible only if the underlying reports are also entered into evidence
Correct answer: Admissible if experts in the field reasonably rely on such reports
FRE 703 allows experts to base opinions on facts or data that experts in the field reasonably rely upon, even if not independently admissible.
Question 30: A state law required that whenever a newspaper prints an editorial criticizing a candidate for office, his character or personal record on the issues, it must provide space for the opposing candidate to reply to the criticisms. A failure to do so is a second-degree misdemeanor. A candidate demanded space for responding to an editorial in a local newspaper that was critical to his character and his candidacy. The newspaper refused to comply. The candidate brought an action seeking declaratory and injunctive relief, and requesting actual and punitive damages. Based on U.S. Supreme Court precedent, what did the court likely decide?
- It was an improper restraint on freedom of speech, which guarantees the right to have a full discussion of the merits of the candidates and their views. (Correct answer)
- This was a proper attempt to regulate the fairness of speech and give equal time to both sides of an issue so that a slanted opinion would not be perceived as necessarily true.
- This is a constitutional statute because the government has a duty to assure that a wide variety of views reach the public.
- This was an unconstitutional statute because by allowing a response, the statute was favoring the criticized candidate and setting up a silent endorsement of that candidate.
Correct answer: It was an improper restraint on freedom of speech, which guarantees the right to have a full discussion of the merits of the candidates and their views.
The Supreme Court, in *Miami Herald Publishing Co. v. Tornillo*, held that a state statute requiring newspapers to provide space for political candidates to reply to criticisms unconstitutionally infringes on the freedom of the press. Such a law compels speech and interferes with the newspaper's editorial judgment and control over its content. The First Amendment protects the editorial autonomy of the press, preventing the government from dictating what must be published.
Question 31: A defendant is convicted of arson for burning down a vacant building he owns. Under the common law, is he guilty of arson?
- Yes, because arson covers all intentional fires
- No, because the building was vacant
- Yes, because he intentionally set fire to a building
- No, because common law arson requires the dwelling of another (Correct answer)
Correct answer: No, because common law arson requires the dwelling of another
Common law arson requires the malicious burning of the dwelling of another; a person cannot commit common law arson by burning his own property.
Question 32: A man was arrested and charged with first-degree murder. Police say that he killed his wife about two minutes after she returned home from a social evening. He had been drinking straight shots of alcohol for several hours before that. He claims that he was waiting to talk and not kill her. When she did come home, he was in an extremely intoxicated condition. He complained of her whereabouts and she responded by taunting him about his sexual deficiencies and uncontrolled drinking habits. He responded by picking up his gun from his desk drawer and shooting her. Will the prosecution likely succeed in its attempt to convict him of first-degree murder?
- Yes, because he waited for his wife knowing that he could exact revenge against her by killing her.
- No, because intoxication, even if voluntary, is an absolute defense to most kinds of violent crime due to the lack of mental capacity necessary for committing a crime.
- No, because there’s ample proof of intoxication substantial enough to prevent him from having the sufficient mental capacity to form the specific premeditative intent necessary for first-degree murder. (Correct answer)
- Yes, because voluntary intoxication is never an excuse that can be used as an affirmative defense to a criminal charge; at the most, it can be used as mitigating circumstances in the sentencing stage.
Correct answer: No, because there’s ample proof of intoxication substantial enough to prevent him from having the sufficient mental capacity to form the specific premeditative intent necessary for first-degree murder.
Because first-degree murder requires proof of a premeditative kind of specific intent, it may be one of the easier offenses in which to negate the intent element by proof of voluntary intoxication. The intoxication in this case appears to have been severe enough to rob the defendant of his ability to premeditate and deliberate. This does not work as a defense if he already had the specific intent to murder his wife but was drinking just to get up the nerve. But there are no facts in this case to indicate that possibility.
Question 33: A pedestrian found an elderly woman lying on the ground conscious but bruised from an attack and mugging that occurred a few minutes earlier. The woman related that the thugs who attacked her took her purse. However, she pulled out a money wallet and told him that they did not find the wallet, which had $2,000 cash in it. After calling 911 to get help for the woman, the pedestrian snatched the wallet from the woman’s hands and ran off. It happened so quickly that the woman had no time to react. The authorities caught him soon thereafter, and charged him with robbery and theft charges. What will be the most likely outcome of the robbery charge?
- He cannot be convicted of robbery because he did not take it from her person, but he simply snatched it out of her hands.
- The robbery charge will result in a conviction because he took the property of another with the intent to deprive her permanently of it.
- He will most likely be convicted of robbery because the woman was already in fear from the prior incident when he took her money.
- He cannot be convicted of robbery because he did not use violence, force or intimidation. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: He cannot be convicted of robbery because he did not use violence, force or intimidation.
Robbery requires the taking of property from another's person or presence by force, violence, or intimidation. The pedestrian's act of snatching the wallet was a sudden, non-violent act that did not involve the use of force or intimidation against the woman at that moment. This act would typically constitute larceny (theft), not robbery, as the element of force or fear was absent during the taking.
Question 34: A state law grants a tax exemption to 'charitable and benevolent organizations.' A church claims the exemption. A taxpayer sues, arguing this violates the Establishment Clause. Under Walz v. Tax Commission, the exemption is:
- Unconstitutional unless the church can show the exemption is the least restrictive means
- Constitutional because it extends to a broad class of nonprofit organizations (Correct answer)
- Unconstitutional because it financially benefits religious institutions
- Constitutional only if the church spends funds on secular charitable activities
Correct answer: Constitutional because it extends to a broad class of nonprofit organizations
In Walz v. Tax Commission, the Court upheld property tax exemptions for churches because they were part of a broad class of nonprofit charitable organizations, avoiding excessive government entanglement.
Question 35: A defendant receives stolen goods knowing they are stolen. He is charged with receiving stolen property. Later, the goods are proven to not have been stolen. Can the defendant be convicted?
- Yes, because he believed the goods were stolen
- No, because mistake of fact is a complete defense here
- Yes, because mens rea alone is sufficient for this crime
- No, because receiving stolen property requires the goods to actually be stolen (Correct answer)
Correct answer: No, because receiving stolen property requires the goods to actually be stolen
Receiving stolen property requires the goods to actually be stolen; if they were not, the actus reus is absent and conviction is not possible.
Question 36: A developer signed a contract to purchase 100 acres of land for construction of single-family dwellings. The land price was $100,000. The contract was contingent on approval of a subdivision plan being accepted by the township for 70 one-acre homes and 30 acres of open space. The subdivision plan was filed with the township but shortly thereafter, the township passed a zoning ordinance that increased the minimum size of building lots in rural areas to five acres per home, in order to preserve the rural nature of the countryside and prevent too much population growth. There was known to be little or no market for five-acre homes. The developer sued the township on the basis that the ordinance was not a reasonable use of the police powers and the property should revert to the original one-acre limitation. The county court denied the developer’s request for injunctive relief against the zoning board. Will the appellate court reverse the county court and issue an order declaring the new 5 acre rule to be an unreasonable and arbitrary use of the police power?
- No, because courts cannot interfere with the rights of local communities to set the minimum size of the lots that they prescribe.
- Yes, the reasonable limit for the size of lots is generally held to be 1 acre and anything above that is automatically prohibited in modern zoning laws.
- Yes, because the new rule imposes too much of an arbitrary, unreasonable, and exclusionary burden on the use of the land, and is therefore an abuse of the reasonable use of the police power. (Correct answer)
- No, it is proper for a municipality to regulate the flow of growth and maintain certain areas as strictly rural, and they can usually go up to ten acres without any concern.
Correct answer: Yes, because the new rule imposes too much of an arbitrary, unreasonable, and exclusionary burden on the use of the land, and is therefore an abuse of the reasonable use of the police power.
While municipalities have broad zoning authority under their police power, ordinances must be reasonable and not arbitrary or confiscatory. A drastic increase in minimum lot size from one to five acres, especially with little market for such large homes, can be deemed an unreasonable and exclusionary burden on property use. Such a change, if not supported by a clear and substantial public welfare justification, may exceed the legitimate bounds of the police power.
Question 37: A state’s voters approved an amendment to the state’s constitution that prevented any city, town, or county in the state from taking any legislative, executive, or judicial action to recognize gay and lesbian individuals as a protected class. The state’s highest court ruled that the measure could not pass strict scrutiny, and was a denial of equal protection for gays and lesbians. The proponents of the act appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court. What will the Court decide with respect to the validity of the law?
- The law is an appropriate measure because it merely denies preferential treatment to homosexuals and has no substantive effect on them.
- The law is unconstitutional because it lacks a rational relation to any legitimate government purpose and the denial of the right to seek protection is unprecedented in our jurisprudence. (Correct answer)
- The law was passed by a referendum majority vote of the people of the state and is thus constitutional and valid under state law.
- The law is unconstitutional because it was not appropriately ratified by the executive and judicial branches of the government.
Correct answer: The law is unconstitutional because it lacks a rational relation to any legitimate government purpose and the denial of the right to seek protection is unprecedented in our jurisprudence.
Although strict scrutiny is an appropriate test, the preliminary question to answer is whether the the amendment consists of any rational purpose that furthers a legitimate government interest. If the amendment or statute does not further a legitimate government interest because it has no rational basis, then you don't need to go to next step and analyze it from the perspective of "strict scrutiny." The first test to apply is the rational basis inquiry: the law is so outrageous that it does NOT have a legitimate government interest. It is based solely on malicious animosity toward a class of people. This law was born of the bare desire to harm an unpopular group of people. This cannot constitute a legitimate government purpose. See Romer v. Evans, 517 U.S. 620 (1996).
Question 38: An article appeared in a magazine dealing with public issues. The article discussed the author’s “personal theory” that a small group of industrial magnates, called the American Illuminati, controlled the government of the United States, regardless of the political party in power. The article mentioned names, and described how they generally aggrandized their economic power by keeping the poor down and concentrating all wealth at the top. The author believed that as long as these “fascist” individuals were ruling behind the scenes, that children here would continue to be deprived of food, a quality education and the right to true freedom. He called the group the “murderers” of the American spirit that once lived free. He concluded that if his “theory” was true, then the country must rise up and “bring down” this system of non-democratic governance. One of the individuals mentioned in the article, a well-known billionaire philanthropist who supported various political movements and candidates, brought a libel action against the author and the magazine. The defendants asked the court to dismiss the action because it failed to state a valid legal claim. Which of the following is the most likely ruling of the court under these circumstances?
- The plaintiff was a private figure never holding a public office and the limited privilege of the New York Times case would not be given to the defendants, so that the case will go to trial.
- The media cannot be censored – it enjoys an absolute privilege to publish controversial allegations of fact regardless of whether it commits injurious falsehood, so that the case would be dismissed.
- The defendants had a constitutional right to discuss and publish theories of politics and ideas that were not presented as truth but as theory of the current political system, and the case would be dismissed. (Correct answer)
- The case would proceed; the plaintiff is a public figure who must prove publication of defamatory falsehood with knowledge that it was false or with reckless disregard of whether it was false or not.
Correct answer: The defendants had a constitutional right to discuss and publish theories of politics and ideas that were not presented as truth but as theory of the current political system, and the case would be dismissed.
For a statement to be defamatory, it must be a false statement of fact, not merely an opinion or a theory. The article explicitly presented its claims as the author's 'personal theory' and 'if his "theory" was true.' Statements of opinion or theory, especially concerning political matters, are generally protected by the First Amendment and cannot form the basis of a libel claim, as they are not verifiable as true or false.
Question 39: When a truck rushing on the sand mowed down an elderly person sunbathing, the man was peacefully and relaxedly resting in a beach chair. Oh my God, see what that truck driver did, the man exclaimed aloud. The truck's driver was racing while traveling at a speed of roughly 100 mph. Please dial 911.When the case goes to trial, would the court allow both the guy and the lady to testify about the man's statements? " A woman, who was sitting on the beach close but looking the other direction, heard the man's outcry.
- No, neither can testify because the utterances do not fit any of the exceptions to the hearsay rule.
- No, neither of them can testify because the man was impaired due to being too relaxed from his meditation, and the woman cannot repeat the utterances of an impaired witness.
- Yes, because this is not hearsay and it is not being entered for the truth of the statement by either witness so that they can both testify.
- Yes, both the woman and the man can testify because it is an excited utterance exception to the hearsay rule that goes to the material issue of the case. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Yes, both the woman and the man can testify because it is an excited utterance exception to the hearsay rule that goes to the material issue of the case.
Explanation: <br> This is an example of an enthusiastic utterance, which is defined as a statement made hastily in response to an unexpected or upsetting incident or <br> circumstance. It is an exception to the hearsay rule that enables testimony from both parties. According to US v. Boyce, 742 F.3d at 748, "" <br> circumstances may produce an excitement condition which temporarily stills the capacity of reflection and produces utterances free of conscious <br> fabrication."" 2014; 3d 792, 796–97 (7th Cir.). To put it another way, the phrase couldn't have come from deliberate thought; it had to have been an <br> immediate response to the shocking event. 272 in McCormick on Evidence, 7th edition (2013).
Question 40: A woman contracted with a company to install central air in her home. The contract contained the details of performance and payment provisions. The agreement stated that it was to become binding upon approval of credit for financing the new system. The credit was approved 4 days later and notification was left on the woman’s voicemail. A crew went out the same day to get started but arrived only to find a competitor on the premises installing a new system. The company sued the woman for breach of contract damages. She claimed that the company delayed too long. An offer generally expires after a reasonable time. What is the best and most likely decision of the court regarding whether the woman and the company had a binding contract?
- This was a case of mutual mistake where each of the parties understood the circumstances in a different way, thus no contract was ever formed.
- The offer here expired because of the inordinate delay in getting credit approval and starting work so that a reasonable time expired and there was no contract.
- She fraudulently represented that she was waiting for the credit approval process, when in fact she was contracting with someone else – she’ll be ordered to pay damages based on fraud.
- There was no unreasonable delay – the parties knew that the credit process had to be carried out and therefore the offer was duly accepted within a reasonable time and as specified by the offer. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: There was no unreasonable delay – the parties knew that the credit process had to be carried out and therefore the offer was duly accepted within a reasonable time and as specified by the offer.
The contract explicitly stated that it would become binding upon credit approval, which serves as a condition precedent. The 4-day period for credit approval and notification was a reasonable time, especially given the nature of the condition. Since the offer was accepted as specified by its terms and within a reasonable timeframe, the woman's claim of unreasonable delay is unfounded, and a binding contract was formed.
Question 41: A man and woman lived together unmarried for 19 years. He assured her that they would live together as husband and wife but without the restriction of an official marriage license. She relied on those promises when giving up plans for a career in business. She assisted him in many substantial ways over the years as he progressed to becoming a successful neurosurgeon. During the years they displayed all of the trappings of being a married couple. When they split up, he refused to give her anything, saying that it was a meretricious relationship. She sued in state court claiming an interest in his income, profits and property. She claimed an express contract or an implied-in-fact agreement to share the economic wealth that was accumulated. The trial court dismissed, saying there could be no claim if there was no marriage. What is the most likely decision of the appellate court?
- This was a meretricious relationship in which the woman had been compensated for her services quite sufficiently over the years, but she had no residual legal claims that could be asserted.
- The couple had an implied-in-fact contract, in which the woman had relied in good faith to her detriment, and she was entitled to damages. (Correct answer)
- There was a right to collect damages based on the massive, lengthy fraudulent scheme that the man perpetrated to keep her within his consuming web but without any economic benefit.
- The rights and benefits claimed by the woman are based on a marital union under state law and there being no official marriage, her claims fail to have legal validity.
Correct answer: The couple had an implied-in-fact contract, in which the woman had relied in good faith to her detriment, and she was entitled to damages.
Many jurisdictions recognize implied-in-fact contracts between unmarried cohabitants who pool resources and efforts with an understanding of shared economic benefit, especially when one party detrimentally relies on the other's promises. Here, the woman's long-term contributions and sacrifice of her career, based on the man's assurances, support the existence of such an agreement to share accumulated wealth. The trial court's dismissal based solely on the lack of a formal marriage is often overturned in modern jurisprudence.
Question 42: A state started conducting random vehicle stops at highway roadblocks to look for drugs. A young man was In a civil case in federal court between two pharmaceutical companies involving a dispute over the rights to an anti-HIV drug, one of the litigants exercised some of its peremptory strikes to keep gay persons off of the jury. The other company challenged and appealed the procedure on the basis of a denial of equal protection to the prospective jurors. What was the most likely ruling of a three-judge panel of the United States Court of Appeals?
- Substantive due process prohibits discrimination by sexual orientation in the selection of a jury.
- Equal protection prohibits peremptory strikes on the basis of sexual orientation alone. (Correct answer)
- The court may exercise its wide discretion in deciding the propriety of peremptory jury strikes.
- The evidence indicates that gay jurors are likely to be biased regarding anti-HIV drug treatment.
Correct answer: Equal protection prohibits peremptory strikes on the basis of sexual orientation alone.
The Supreme Court has made some landmark decisions upholding equal protection and due process for persons regardless of sexual orientation. In U.S. v. Windsor, 570 U.S. ______ (2013), the Court held that provisions of the Defense of Marriage Act were unconstitutional under federal due process principles. In the instant case, it is a denial of equal protection to deny a person a seat on a jury panel due to nothing other than sexual orientation. See Smith-Kline Beecham v. Abbott (9th Cir., No. 11-17357) (2014).
Question 43: A professional hockey player was traded from one team to another, with his existing contract being assigned to the new team. The contract had an option to require the four-time all-star player to sign a new three-year contract at a newly negotiated amount. The new team exercised the option. After successful negotiations, they agreed on and signed a three-year contract. However, that team later discovered that the player also signed a one-year contract with another team. Despite demands, the player has failed to assure his new team that he is going to honor the three-year contract. For that reason, the team filed an action requesting injunctive relief. What will the court most likely decide?
- The one-year document was an anticipatory repudiation of the valid three-year contract, but injunctive relief was denied because the team can sue for money damages.
- There was no valid contract because it’s illegal for two teams to trade and negotiate the freedom of choice and freedom of movement of a player.
- There is an anticipatory repudiation of the valid three-year contract, and an injunction will issue because money damages are inadequate to replace the players highly unique and special services. (Correct answer)
- Although there was an anticipatory repudiation of a valid contract, money damages will suffice because the court can never attempt to enforce a contract for personal services.
Correct answer: There is an anticipatory repudiation of the valid three-year contract, and an injunction will issue because money damages are inadequate to replace the players highly unique and special services.
The player's action of signing a contract with another team constitutes an anticipatory repudiation of his valid three-year contract. Injunctive relief is appropriate because money damages are inadequate to compensate for the loss of a highly unique and special service, such as that of a professional athlete. Courts often grant injunctions to prevent such unique individuals from performing for a competitor when they have breached a valid contract.
Question 44: A seller of computers advertised for sale: “lot number 931, brand new computers, state-of-the-art, deeply discounted in price and with factory warranties.” Some of the buyers of these computers ran into problems in trying to register for the factory warranty. They were rejected without explanation, and several of them reported the problem to local authorities. The authorities eventually discovered that the whole lot of computers advertised by the seller was part of a truckload that was hijacked and emptied of its contents a few months earlier. Under questioning, the seller admitted to being part of a group that committed the hijacking. The police arrested him for theft, receiving stolen property, and criminal fraud. Can he likely be convicted of receiving stolen property?
- Yes, because the thief is always guilty of both theft and receiving stolen property.
- Yes, because he received the stolen goods with the intent of selling them to unsuspecting consumers.
- No, because one who has a retail business can never be guilty of receiving stolen property.
- No, one who steals the property from its owner cannot be convicted of receiving stolen goods when he tries to sell the stolen item. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: No, one who steals the property from its owner cannot be convicted of receiving stolen goods when he tries to sell the stolen item.
Under the common law and in many jurisdictions, a person who actually steals property cannot also be convicted of receiving stolen property for the same items. The crimes of larceny (theft) and receiving stolen property are distinct; receiving stolen property requires that the goods were stolen by *another* person. Since the seller admitted to being part of the hijacking, he is the thief and cannot be convicted of receiving the property he himself stole.
Question 45: Three seven-year-old boys crawled through a hole in a fence at the end of a school playground, and entered an active railroad switching yard. They climbed on top of a freight car and one of them was electrocuted by a high voltage wire. The fence they crawled through was owned and maintained by the local school district, which owned the playground. The rail yard was owned by the Penn Central Co. The deceased boy’s father brought a wrongful death action against both the city and the railroad company. There were several holes in the fence that were used by kids to come and go from the railroad yard. There were four prior incidents at the railroad yard where young children were electrocuted or seriously injured by high-tension wires. Both defendants filed motions to dismiss as a matter of law because the children were trespassers to whom they asserted that they owed no duty of care. The trial court agreed and dismissed the claim against both defendants. An appeal was filed. Will the appellate court affirm the dismissal?
- No, the court will reverse and enter judgment against the defendants for failing to use protective measures under the doctrine of absolute liability to protect the children.
- No, the court will reverse because it was foreseeable that children would come on the land and be exposed to a dangerous condition, triggering a duty to protect them. (Correct answer)
- Yes, the court will affirm as to the railroad which had no duty to trespassers on its land, but will reverse as to the school district, because the children were not trespassing on the playground.
- Yes, the court will affirm the dismissal against both defendants because neither of them owed any duty to children trespassing on the land.
Correct answer: No, the court will reverse because it was foreseeable that children would come on the land and be exposed to a dangerous condition, triggering a duty to protect them.
The attractive nuisance doctrine creates an exception to the general rule that landowners owe no duty to trespassers, particularly for child trespassers. It applies when a landowner knows or should know that children are likely to trespass on a property containing an artificial condition that poses an unreasonable risk of harm, and the children, due to their youth, cannot appreciate the danger. Given the multiple holes in the fence, prior incidents, and the inherent danger of high-tension wires, it was foreseeable that children would trespass and be harmed, triggering a duty for both defendants.
Question 46: After his home theater ignited a devastating fire that destroyed the equipment and a portion of his home, the owner filed a lawsuit against the maker of video and home theater products. He filed a federal lawsuit against the manufacturer. The plaintiff's expert's report and testimony were challenged at trial by the defendants in a motion made according to Federal Rule of Evidence. 702. The defendants assert bias, a lack of scientific backing, a lack of testing, differences in expert opinions, and the fact that the expert was prepared to deal with big commercial fires. Over 500 fires had been investigated by the expert, who also published a book that was used in classrooms across the country and instructed a course in forensic fire investigations at a university. Her report ruled out every other scenario. As required by Rule 702, the court conducted a gate-keeping review and determined that the expert was highly competent and that she had followed recognized scientific procedures to form her conclusion. The verdict was appealed by the defendants. Given these circumstances, is the appellate court likely to disagree with the judgment?
- No, the court has absolute discretion in deciding the competency of the expert for purposes of giving expert trial testimony and evidence.
- Yes, because the charge of bias against an expert witness requires a "trial within a trial" and that was not done.
- No, the court did the required gate-keeping inquiry and found that the witness was not only qualified and competent, but also used the accepted methodologies. (Correct answer)
- Yes, because whenever the expert does not back up her conclusion with experimental testing, an expert's opinion will be insufficiently reliable to be allowed.
Correct answer: No, the court did the required gate-keeping inquiry and found that the witness was not only qualified and competent, but also used the accepted methodologies.
Explanation: <br> Check out Westfield Ins. Co. v. J.C. In Penney Corp., 466 F.Supp.2d 1086, 1094 (W.D.Wis. 2006), the court rejected a challenge to the opinion testimony <br> of the fire investigator based on the investigator's failure to conduct tests. CNH Am., LLC v. Shuck, 498 F.3d 868, 875 n. Additionally, critiques of <br> methodology are typically best addressed during cross-examination at trial. 3 (8th Cir.2007) (clarifying that there is no rule requiring that expert <br> opinions in fire cases always must be backed by testing). (Dist. Court, D. N.H. 2013) (Civil No. 11-cv-430-JL, Opinion No. 2013 DNH 061) See MMG <br> Insurance Company v. Samsung Electronics America, Inc. 671 F. Meyers Builders, Inc. Supp. 2009 Dist. Ct. N.H. 2d 262).
Question 47: Plaintiff was injured in an accident on an interstate highway in his county of residence. The accident involved a truck and three cars in addition to plaintiff's car. Plaintiff brought suit in the federal district court in his district pursuant to diversity jurisdiction. He sued the truck driver and the truck owner, who were from another state. He also included a driver of one of the cars who resided in another state, and the driver of another car who resided in the same state as plaintiff. The amount in damages demanded by plaintiff was over $100,000. The truck company filed a motion to dismiss, claiming that plaintiff did not have diversity jurisdiction. Will the district court judge likely dismiss the complaint, and why or why not?
- No, diversity is perfectly proper as long as the amount in controversy is over $75,000 and the plaintiff and at least one defendant are from different states.
- No, because the plaintiff and most of the defendants are from different states, thus conferring proper diversity jurisdiction.
- Yes, because there is no federal subject matter jurisdiction, which must also be present in diversity cases.
- Yes, the plaintiff and one of the defendants are from the same state, which destroys federal diversity jurisdiction. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Yes, the plaintiff and one of the defendants are from the same state, which destroys federal diversity jurisdiction.
Federal diversity jurisdiction requires complete diversity, meaning no plaintiff can be a citizen of the same state as any defendant. In this case, the plaintiff and one of the car drivers are both residents of the same state. This lack of complete diversity, despite the amount in controversy being met and other parties being diverse, destroys federal subject matter jurisdiction, requiring dismissal.
Question 48: A witness on the stand testifies to facts she personally observed. On cross-examination, opposing counsel asks about a prior inconsistent statement the witness made to police. This is permissible because:
- The statement becomes a business record exception
- Witnesses waive all privileges once they testify
- Cross-examination may attack credibility by showing inconsistency (Correct answer)
- Prior statements are always admissible as substantive evidence
Correct answer: Cross-examination may attack credibility by showing inconsistency
A prior inconsistent statement is a classic tool for impeaching a witness's credibility on cross-examination under FRE 613.
Question 49: A painting was stolen collectively from an art gallery. One of them—the driver—was apprehended while committing another crime. "I didn't even get any money from the art museum," he admitted to the cops. Is the driver's statement admissible in court when the first and second guy stand trial for the theft of the art painting?
- Yes, as a statement against the interests of the other defendants.
- No, because it was made while in custody and therefore is unreliable.
- Yes, as an admission by a party opponent.
- No, because the statement was not made in the course of or in furtherance of the conspiracy and thus it is hearsay. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: No, because the statement was not made in the course of or in furtherance of the conspiracy and thus it is hearsay.
Explanation: <br> To establish a basis for admission of evidence under the co-conspirator exception to the hearsay rule, the government must demonstrate that (1) there <br> was a conspiracy, (2) the statement was made by a co-conspirator of a party, (3) it was made during the course of the conspiracy, and (4) it was made <br> in furtherance of the conspiracy. The statement cannot be admitted as evidence by itself. El-Mezain v. United States, 664 F.3d 467, 502 (5th Cir. 2011). <br> See U.S. v. Gigante, 166 F.3d 75 (2d Cir. 1999), which discusses the co-conspirator exception to the hearsay rule in more detail.
Question 50: In a civil case, evidence is offered that the parties entered into settlement negotiations. Under FRE 408, this evidence is:
- Admissible to prove the amount of damages
- Admissible because civil settlements are public records
- Inadmissible to prove or disprove the claim's validity (Correct answer)
- Admissible only if negotiations failed
Correct answer: Inadmissible to prove or disprove the claim's validity
FRE 408 prohibits admission of compromise negotiations to prove or disprove liability or damages to encourage settlement.
Question 51: A landlord leases an apartment to a tenant for one year. Mid-lease, the landlord sells the building. The new owner refuses to honor the lease. What is the tenant's best claim?
- The tenant may sue the original landlord for breach of contract only
- The lease terminates automatically upon sale
- The tenant must vacate but can recover a security deposit
- The lease binds the new owner because it runs with the land (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The lease binds the new owner because it runs with the land
A lease is a conveyance of a property interest that runs with the land and binds subsequent purchasers who take with notice.
Question 52: A candy manufacturer used pre-printed purchase order forms to purchase separate orders of baking sugar from a supplier. The supplier responded to each order by sending the shipment along with its own printed form confirming the shipment and the terms. According to the manufacturer, the last shipment contained spoiled sugar. The manufacturer filed a complaint in state court alleging breach of contract and damages. The supplier filed a motion to have the dispute transferred to arbitration. The manufacturer’s purchase order forms were silent as to the mode of settling disputes, but the supplier’s form contained a clause calling for “any controversy or claim” to be settled by arbitration. The manufacturer was silent as to the arbitration clause. What is the likely decision of the court?
- The clause did not become a part of the contract because the offer in this case expressly limited acceptance to the strict terms of the offer, and thus there is no transfer to arbitration.
- The case must be transferred to arbitration because a clause in the acceptance form always becomes a part of the contract if the offeror does not reject it.
- The case must be transferred to arbitration because the additional term did not materially alter the offer and therefore became incorporated into the contract.
- The clause did not automatically become a part of the contract because it materially altered the offer, thus there is no transfer to arbitration. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The clause did not automatically become a part of the contract because it materially altered the offer, thus there is no transfer to arbitration.
Under UCC § 2-207, an additional term in an acceptance between merchants becomes part of the contract unless it materially alters the offer. An arbitration clause is generally considered a material alteration because it significantly impacts the parties' rights and remedies by changing the forum for dispute resolution. Therefore, the arbitration clause did not automatically become part of the contract without the manufacturer's express assent, and the case will not be transferred to arbitration.
Question 53: A building owner hired a painter to paint 20 office units that were vacant and being refurbished. They agreed to terms in writing, and the painter started on the work. After completing only two units, he received a written message from the owner repudiating their agreement and stating that his services were no longer needed. The painter ignored the message because he believed that his contract guaranteed him the full 20 units of work. He finished all units and sent a bill to the owner, who responded with a check for the first two units only. The painter sued the building owner for the full balance due. The building owner countered that he only owed up to the point that he repudiated the contract. Which of the following most closely states the probable decision of the court?
- The painter had a right to complete performance because he had already started the work and had a right to perform his part of the valid and enforceable agreement.
- The “avoidable consequences” doctrine is applicable to support the right of the painter to finish the job and be paid.
- The painter could not receive the full contract price because he would be unjustly enriched under these circumstances.
- The painter had a duty to stop work and thus mitigate damages when he received a written repudiation of the contract. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The painter had a duty to stop work and thus mitigate damages when he received a written repudiation of the contract.
Upon receiving an unequivocal repudiation of a contract, the non-breaching party generally has a duty to stop performance and mitigate their damages. By continuing to paint the remaining 18 units after the owner's clear repudiation, the painter failed to mitigate his damages. Therefore, he can only recover for the work completed up to the point of repudiation, plus any damages incurred in preparing for the remaining work, not the full contract price for all 20 units.
Question 54: A jury verdict is entered in favor of the plaintiff. The defendant files a motion for a new trial under FRCP 59, arguing that the damages award is excessive. What standard does the court apply when reviewing the damages?
- The court must accept the jury's determination on damages without review
- The court applies the same standard as a motion for judgment as a matter of law
- The court grants a new trial only if no reasonable jury could have returned the verdict
- The court grants a new trial if the verdict is against the weight of the evidence, even if supported by substantial evidence (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The court grants a new trial if the verdict is against the weight of the evidence, even if supported by substantial evidence
On a motion for new trial, the court may weigh the evidence and credibility of witnesses, granting relief if the verdict is against the clear weight of the evidence, even where some evidence supports the verdict.
Question 55: A “disturbing the peace” ordinance passed by a city government prohibited the “sidewalk assembly of three or more persons who conduct themselves in a manner annoying to persons passing by . . . ." A group of three college students assembled on a busy and crowded sidewalk and gave speeches about the decline of democracy in America. They were arrested and prosecuted under the ordinance. Their appeals led to challenging the constitutionality of the provision in a federal district court. What is the likely decision of the federal court?
- The ordinance is constitutional because it seeks to control crowd disturbances in a congested public sidewalk.
- The ordinance is unconstitutional because it violates the “void-for-vagueness” doctrine. (Correct answer)
- The ordinance is unconstitutional because it denies the speakers of due process of law.
- The ordinance is constitutional because it adequately tells people not to do things that would be disturbing to the common peace on a crowded sidewalk.
Correct answer: The ordinance is unconstitutional because it violates the “void-for-vagueness” doctrine.
The ordinance makes it completely subjective as to what is prohibited. Laws must give the person of ordinary intelligence a reasonable chance to know what is prohibited, so that he may act accordingly. Second, to stop arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement, laws must provide explicit standards for enforcement. A vague law gives too much unbridled power to enforce the law indiscriminately, without defining parameters.
Question 56: A law student and two friends were at a mall peacefully handing out fliers protesting the country’s military involvement in a Middle Eastern country. The mall owner called the police, who warned them to stop or they would be arrested. They returned the next day and continued to leaflet. The police came again and issued another warning. The law student left to avoid arrest, but his friends stayed and were arrested for criminal trespass and loitering. The law student, in an attempt to get an advance ruling on the constitutionality of the criminal ordinances and propriety of police actions, filed an action in federal court asking for declaratory relief. Based on Supreme Court precedent, how should the federal district court rule?
- The declaratory relief would be premature because the law student’s fears of a future arrest are entirely speculative on his part.
- With no pending prosecution, a federal plaintiff may seek a declaratory judgment that a state statute would be unconstitutionally applied against him in a threatened future prosecution. (Correct answer)
- The declaratory relief would interfere with existing state prosecutions and would therefore be disallowed for reasons of equity and comity
- There is no pending prosecution, which means that there is no actual case or controversy to which the declaratory relief could apply.
Correct answer: With no pending prosecution, a federal plaintiff may seek a declaratory judgment that a state statute would be unconstitutionally applied against him in a threatened future prosecution.
Federal declaratory relief may be allowed when no state prosecution is pending and a federal plaintiff shows a genuine threat of enforcement of a disputed state criminal statute. See Steffel v. Thompson, 415 U.S. 452 (1974). This is an actual controversy under Art. III of the Constitution; this is not imaginary or speculative, and petitioner need not expose himself to actual arrest or prosecution to make his constitutional challenge.
Question 57: A state statute made it a crime to be addicted to the use of narcotic drugs. A man was arrested and charged with the crime. Two officers testified that they examined “track” marks on the defendant’s arms and wrists, and that the man admitted to using drugs. However, he testified and denied saying that to the officers; instead, he said that he was having an allergic reaction. The trial court instructed the jury that it could find the man guilty of the crime on proof that he was observed to be using drugs and appeared to be addicted to narcotics. The jury found him guilty based on the observed track marks and the man was sentenced to six months of incarceration in a state penitentiary. He appealed on the basis that this was cruel and unusual punishment prohibited by both the state and federal constitutions. Will the conviction likely be reversed?
- No, because the state has the power to forbid the use of narcotics within its borders and that’s in effect what this statute does.
- No, because the arrest is based on the regular use of illegal narcotics and is a proper concern of the criminal law.
- Yes, because the statute punishes the status of being an addict, which is an illness, and does not require proof of specific acts of drug usage – the punishment is cruel and unusual. (Correct answer)
- Yes, because the statute makes it criminal to use illegal drugs, which constitutes cruel and unusual punishment.
Correct answer: Yes, because the statute punishes the status of being an addict, which is an illness, and does not require proof of specific acts of drug usage – the punishment is cruel and unusual.
The Supreme Court, in *Robinson v. California*, held that a state cannot criminalize the *status* of being a drug addict, as addiction is considered an illness. Punishing someone for a condition or status, rather than for specific criminal acts (like possessing or using drugs), constitutes cruel and unusual punishment under the Eighth Amendment. This statute punishes the status of addiction, making it unconstitutional.
Question 58: A spouse is called to testify against her husband in a federal criminal case. Regarding the adverse spousal testimony privilege:
- Neither spouse holds the privilege in federal criminal cases
- The testifying spouse holds the privilege and may refuse to testify (Correct answer)
- Both spouses must jointly invoke the privilege
- The defendant spouse holds the privilege and may bar the testimony
Correct answer: The testifying spouse holds the privilege and may refuse to testify
Under Trammel v. United States, in federal courts the witness-spouse holds the adverse spousal testimony privilege and may choose to testify or refuse.
Question 59: In a medical malpractice case, the plaintiff's attorney sends a notice to the defending doctor to appear for her oral deposition. Because the doctor did not appear the first time it was scheduled, the plaintiff sends a subpoena ordering the doctor to attend and to bring her medical file with her. The respective lawyers discussed the matter but did not stipulate to the deposition, although the doctor's counsel have not objected to the scheduling notice. Does the doctor have to attend and bring her records?
- No, because the parties never stipulated to holding the deposition.
- Yes, under Rule 30(a)(1) it may be scheduled without leave of court, and under Rule 45, she may be compelled to appear by a subpoena served on her. (Correct answer)
- Yes, she must appear because she is a party to the case and she will automatically be held in contempt if she does not comply.
- No, because in this case the deponent was already sent a notice and did not appear the first time; therefore, leave of court is required.
Correct answer: Yes, under Rule 30(a)(1) it may be scheduled without leave of court, and under Rule 45, she may be compelled to appear by a subpoena served on her.
Rule 30(a)(1) says that a party may, by oral questions, depose any person, including a party, without leave of court except as provided in Rule 30(a)(2). The deponent’s attendance may be compelled by subpoena under Rule 45. Here, none of the exceptions in 30(a)(2) exist, and she must attend or the plaintiff can file a motion to compel her attendance.
Question 60: A man who works and resides in State A is injured seriously while using a defective lawn mower. The mower was made in State B where the manufacturer has a large manufacturing plant. The manufacturer is incorporated in State C where it has a registered agent and receives lawsuits and service of process. The manufacturer does business in State A but is headquartered, controlled and has its “nerve center” in State D. The man sues the manufacturer in a federal court in State A on a products liability tort claim. The complaint alleges serious and permanent injuries, a permanent disability, and damages in excess of $75,000. Leaving aside any potential questions of venue, is there subject matter jurisdictional authority for the case to be filed in State A and what is the reason for or against it?
- Yes, there is diversity jurisdiction because the man is domiciled in State A and the manufacturer is incorporated in State C and headquartered in State D, making them citizens of different states. (Correct answer)
- No, because the man lives in State A and the manufacturer does business there, which defeats diversity jurisdiction.
- No, the plaintiff must sue in state B where the manufacturer has a physical presence.
- Yes, there is federal subject matter jurisdiction in State A because the case is brought under the federal laws of products liability.
Correct answer: Yes, there is diversity jurisdiction because the man is domiciled in State A and the manufacturer is incorporated in State C and headquartered in State D, making them citizens of different states.
A federal court must have at least one of three types of subject matter jurisdiction: (1) under a federal statutory grant; (2) federal question jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1331; or (3) diversity jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1332. (1) and (2) do not apply here because this is a state law tort case. Under (3), diversity jurisdiction is where (1) the amount in controversy exceeds $75,000, exclusive of interests and costs, and (2) the parties are citizens of different states. A corporation is a citizen of the state of incorporation and also of the state where it has a principal place of business. 28 U.S.C. § 1332(c)(1). The “principal place of business” is where the corporation's high level officers direct, control, and coordinate its activities, which is often called its `nerve center.' Hertz Corp. v. Friend, 559 U.S. 77, 130 S.Ct. 1181, 1189-90, 175 L.Ed.2d 1029 (2010). Here, the man is domiciled in, and a citizen of, State A where he works and resides. The manufacturer is a citizen of State D, where it has its nerve center and of State C where it is incorporated. Thus, the man and the company are citizens of different states.
Question 61: Some disabled veterans sued a state government alleging that the state’s courthouses were inaccessible to disabled persons. They alleged that the state violated federal laws assuring access rights to people with disabilities. The state countered that the action violated the state’s sovereign immunity under the 11th Amendment. The plaintiffs argued that the enforcement clause of the Fourteenth Amendment allowed the federal government to apply anti-discrimination measures to protect the rights of disabled persons. What is the most likely decision of the federal court based on U.S. Supreme Court precedent?
- Those disabled persons in this case were being denied equal protection of the law, and as such, the federal statute was a proper application of the police powers of the state.
- The right of the disabled to access the courthouse was fundamental and was guaranteed by the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment; the remedy was not unduly burdensome or disproportionate to the harm. (Correct answer)
- Congress unconstitutionally abrogated state sovereign immunity by trying to apply a remedy that was not congruent and proportional to the discrimination being addressed, but instead was unduly burdensome on the states.
- Despite the discrimination these were not fundamental rights that were protected by the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
Correct answer: The right of the disabled to access the courthouse was fundamental and was guaranteed by the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment; the remedy was not unduly burdensome or disproportionate to the harm.
The Supreme Court, in *Tennessee v. Lane*, held that Congress can abrogate state sovereign immunity under Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment to enforce the right of access to the courts for disabled persons. This right is fundamental and protected by the Due Process Clause. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) was deemed a congruent and proportional remedy for the historical discrimination faced by disabled individuals in accessing public services, including courthouses, thus overcoming the state's Eleventh Amendment immunity.
Question 62: Which of the following is NOT an element required for the dying declaration exception under FRE 804(b)(2)?
- The declarant must be unavailable as a witness
- The statement concerns the cause or circumstances of the impending death
- The declarant must have believed death was imminent when speaking
- The declarant must have actually died before trial (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The declarant must have actually died before trial
FRE 804(b)(2) does not require actual death; the declarant need only have believed death was imminent, but must be unavailable (which can include incompetency or other reasons).
Question 63: A bank sues a homeowner in a civil foreclosure action. The homeowner does not respond and a judgment is entered in favor of the bank. Several months later, the bank files to execute on the judgment and set a date for a sheriff's sale. Due to backlogs, the sale will take place in six months, which will be well over one year from the date of entering the judgment. The homeowner hires an attorney on the same day that the request for sheriff's sale is filed by the bank. The attorney immediately files a motion for relief from the Order under Rule 60(b). The homeowner alleges as grounds for relief that the bank committed fraud and used "robo-signing" methods whereby the person allegedly signing the foreclosure papers did not actually sign them, making the judgment void. The defendant objects on the basis that the motion was not filed within a reasonable time. Will the court likely rule that the motion was filed too late?
- No, because the allegation of fraud can be considered at any time by the court.
- Yes, because the motion for relief from the order was filed over a year after judgment was entered.
- Yes, because the homeowner never responded to the original complaint in foreclosure.
- No, because the computation of time shows that the motion for relief was filed under one year from the date of entering the judgment. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: No, because the computation of time shows that the motion for relief was filed under one year from the date of entering the judgment.
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(c)(1) requires a motion for relief from judgment based on fraud to be made within a reasonable time, and no more than one year after the entry of the judgment. The homeowner's motion was filed on the same day the request for sheriff's sale was filed, which was several months after judgment but still within the one-year limit. Therefore, the motion was timely.
Question 64: A federal court enters a default judgment against a defendant who was never properly served. The defendant learns of the judgment one year later. Under FRCP 60(b)(4), the defendant may seek relief from the judgment because:
- The judgment is void due to lack of personal jurisdiction (Correct answer)
- The judgment was entered through fraud on the court
- Enforcing the judgment would be unjust
- Newly discovered evidence supports setting aside the judgment
Correct answer: The judgment is void due to lack of personal jurisdiction
A judgment is void under Rule 60(b)(4) when the court lacked personal jurisdiction over the defendant, and there is no time limit for seeking relief from a void judgment.
Question 65: In a medical malpractice case, the plaintiff's attorney sends a notice to the defending doctor to appear for her oral deposition. Because the doctor did not appear the first time it was scheduled, the plaintiff sends a subpoena ordering the doctor to attend and to bring her medical file with her. The respective lawyers discussed the matter but did not stipulate to the deposition, although the doctor's counsel have not objected to the scheduling notice. Does the doctor have to attend and bring her records?
- No, because the parties never stipulated to holding the deposition.
- Yes, she must appear because she is a party to the case and she will automatically be held in contempt if she does not comply.
- Yes, under Rule 30(a)(1) it may be scheduled without leave of court, and under Rule 45, she may be compelled to appear by a subpoena served on her. (Correct answer)
- No, because in this case the deponent was already sent a notice and did not appear the first time; therefore, leave of court is required.
Correct answer: Yes, under Rule 30(a)(1) it may be scheduled without leave of court, and under Rule 45, she may be compelled to appear by a subpoena served on her.
Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 30(a)(1), a party may depose any person without leave of court. While a notice is sufficient for a party's attendance, a subpoena (Rule 45) is necessary to compel the production of documents from any deponent, including a party. Since the doctor is a party and was served with a subpoena, she is legally obligated to attend and bring the requested records.
Question 66: A dealer ordered “one truckload of western regional first-grade widgets, usual terms and conditions” on a standard order form that he sent to his usual wholesale supplier. The dealer and the supplier had a practice that all shipments would contain standard-sized widgets unless otherwise stated. The truckload arrived and was unloaded but later discovered to contain “extra-large” size widgets, which the dealer could not use. The dealer refused to pay and the manufacturer sued for the ticket price of $223,000. The dealer soon learned that industry standards re-classified the extra-large widgets as “discontinued” and essentially obsolete. At trial, the dealer offered to testify to his standard practices in ordering so as to clarify what he intended to order. The manufacturer objected based on the parol evidence rule. What is the best and most likely decision of the court regarding the objection?
- The dealer’s testimony will be allowed because course-of-dealing testimony that attempts to explain and interpret what is meant by the writing is allowed. (Correct answer)
- The dealer’s testimony will be disallowed because it is in direct violation of the parol evidence rule’s prohibition of testimony regarding subjects already integrated into the written contract.
- The testimony will be allowed because it is relevant and relevancy always trumps the parol evidence rule.
- The testimony will not be allowed because it will serve to confuse the issues and simply cloud up the clear meaning already explained in the order form and shipping documents.
Correct answer: The dealer’s testimony will be allowed because course-of-dealing testimony that attempts to explain and interpret what is meant by the writing is allowed.
The parol evidence rule generally prevents the introduction of prior or contemporaneous oral agreements that contradict a fully integrated written contract. However, it does not bar evidence of course of dealing, usage of trade, or course of performance to *explain or supplement* the terms of a contract, especially under the UCC for contracts involving goods. The dealer's testimony about standard practices (course of dealing) is admissible to clarify the meaning of terms like 'western regional first-grade widgets' and 'usual terms and conditions.'
Question 67: An owner leased land to a tenant who said that he was going to use the land for farming. The tract contained farmland and dozens of acres of pristine, scenic woodlands that were part of the view from the owner’s adjoining residence. The owner noticed that the tenant was cutting down trees and selling them to companies who manufactured wood and paper products. After a while, 20 acres or so had been cut down and the activity was continuing, leaving a ravaged sight on the land. Does the landlord have a right to stop the activity and recover the value of the lost trees?
- Under the doctrine of transfer of leasehold estate, the tenant may change the original use intended and perform any legal use that he wishes.
- This is voluntary waste to the property, which is prohibited by most leases; the tenant may be ordered to pay for the value of the waste, stop further activities, and is subject to being evicted. (Correct answer)
- The landlord cannot interfere with lawful activities conducted by the tenant, and in this case the use of inactive trees that are mere woodlands cannot be prohibited.
- This is ameliorative waste, which actually improves the value by having a profitable business on site; the tenant will not be held liable because he has improved the property.
Correct answer: This is voluntary waste to the property, which is prohibited by most leases; the tenant may be ordered to pay for the value of the waste, stop further activities, and is subject to being evicted.
A tenant has a duty not to commit waste, which means they cannot engage in acts that substantially diminish the value of the leased property. Cutting down dozens of acres of pristine woodlands for sale constitutes voluntary or affirmative waste, as it actively harms the property's value and character. The landlord can seek an injunction to stop the activity, recover damages for the lost trees, and potentially evict the tenant for breach of this duty.
Question 68: A woman was walking to a bus stop after leaving her workplace. A teen in a parked car waved a gun at her and asked in an obscene tone of voice if she would like a ride. She kept walking and he did not pursue, but she heard him yelling in her direction that maybe he should get out and teach her a lesson. The woman went straight to a police officer and reported the incident, stating that she was afraid. The police went to the car and found the teen, and the gun. The gun was unloaded. Will the police be able to successfully prosecute the man for simple assault?
- Yes, this was assault because waving a weapon, whether loaded or not, is always sufficient to constitute assault under any circumstances.
- No, a criminal assault is not supported where the gun is unloaded and the person therefore had no intent to use it.
- Yes, this was assault because the woman was placed in fear of receiving immediate bodily harm; even if the gun was unloaded she did not know it and was frightened. (Correct answer)
- No, this was a joking gesture that was not intended to put the woman in fear of immediate bodily harm; there is no assault when the perpetrator’s intent is not to inflict harm.
Correct answer: Yes, this was assault because the woman was placed in fear of receiving immediate bodily harm; even if the gun was unloaded she did not know it and was frightened.
Criminal assault typically requires an intentional act that places another in reasonable apprehension of immediate bodily harm. The key is the victim's reasonable apprehension, not the perpetrator's actual ability or intent to inflict harm. Waving a gun, even an unloaded one, and making threatening remarks would reasonably put the woman in fear, satisfying the elements of assault.
Question 69: A distributor agrees to sell 100 tubes of growth hormone to a medical treatment center in exchange for $30,000. The contract has many clauses, including one that prohibits generally the assignment of the contract or any of its terms. The distributor assigns its right to receive the funds anyway. Will a court enforce the bar against assignment under these circumstances?
- No, a bar of assignment does not apply to the right to receive the funds unless specifically stated. (Correct answer)
- Yes, a contractual provision prohibiting assignments is enforceable in all respects.
- No, a bar of assignment is an unconstitutional deprivation of due process.
- Yes, a bar against the right to receive proceeds is a favored restriction unless otherwise stated.
Correct answer: No, a bar of assignment does not apply to the right to receive the funds unless specifically stated.
Contractual provisions prohibiting assignment are generally construed narrowly. A clause that generally prohibits 'assignment of the contract or any of its terms' is typically interpreted as prohibiting the delegation of duties, but not the assignment of the right to receive payments (money). To prohibit the assignment of the right to receive funds, the clause must specifically and clearly state that such assignments are barred.
Question 70: A student sued his university for failing to deliver the quality of education promised in its catalogue. There is a count also for fraudulent misrepresentation of the quality, content, and accuracy of the courses offered, along with fraud regarding the qualifications of the teachers. The university filed an answer denying responsibility and listing various affirmative defenses. Two months later, the university filed a third-party complaint against a private benefactor who had pledged $20 million for the current and last two operating years, but who had not lived up to her pledge. The university, as the third-party plaintiff, claimed that the benefactor is or may be liable to it for all or part of the claim. The benefactor filed a motion to dismiss the third-party complaint. What will the court likely do and why?
- Dismiss the third-party complaint due to it being late and filed without leave of court. (Correct answer)
- Allow the third-party complaint and order the benefactor to file an answer.
- Allow the third-party complaint based on the rule of indispensable joinder of a necessary third-party benefactor.
- Dismiss the third-party complaint as a frivolous pleading.
Correct answer: Dismiss the third-party complaint due to it being late and filed without leave of court.
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 14(a)(1) allows a defendant to serve a third-party complaint within 14 days after serving its original answer without needing court permission. If more than 14 days have passed, the defendant must obtain leave of court to file the third-party complaint. Here, the university filed its third-party complaint two months after its answer, exceeding the 14-day window and failing to seek leave of court, making the filing untimely.
Question 71: A bill collector came to the door of an elderly widow. The collector showed her a credit card bill for $20,000 owed by her recently deceased husband. He told the widow that she could be arrested and prosecuted if the bill, which was now her responsibility, was not paid. He left her a promissory note for $20,000 with interest and urged that she sign and send it back to him. After a few days, the widow signed the note, hoping in her mind to restore and maintain her husband’s good name. Six months later, the collection company sued on the note because the widow had made no payments. The widow’s attorney filed a motion to have the note declared void due to duress. What is the most likely decision of the court based on the principles of duress?
- This was not duress because the threat was not imminent and did not deprive her of time to think, and to take the papers to a lawyer for help and advice, and thus the contract is enforceable. (Correct answer)
- The note put the widow in a state of utter fear, and she knew that she had no time to consult an attorney or to try and get a second opinion, hence the contract was voidable by her.
- The note was signed under fear by the widow that she would be imminently sued and maybe end up in jail, and thus it is voidable by her.
- A threat of going to jail will never suffice to establish duress because it is not capable of being carried out and is not a true statement of the law, hence the contract is enforceable.
Correct answer: This was not duress because the threat was not imminent and did not deprive her of time to think, and to take the papers to a lawyer for help and advice, and thus the contract is enforceable.
For duress to void a contract, the threat must be improper and deprive the victim of their free will, leaving no reasonable alternative but to assent. While a threat of criminal prosecution can be improper, the widow had 'a few days' to consider the promissory note and consult an attorney. This time period indicates she was not deprived of a reasonable opportunity to seek advice, thus negating the element of duress that requires an imminent threat leaving no reasonable alternative.
Question 72: Two women, a cashier and an accountant, worked closely together in the accounting department of a large retailer. Both were defrauding the company by separate schemes. The cashier was issuing checks to certain persons and then splitting the proceeds with them. The accountant was making certain expense vouchers that she would issue to persons not entitled to reimbursement, and then she would share the proceeds with them. Both women assisted each other in the making and processing their respective checks and vouchers each month, but each believed that the other’s documents were legal. When things started to unwind, the police discovered both plots and arrested both women for criminal fraud and theft. They also arrested the women for a felony conspiracy to act together in defrauding their company. They both defended against the conspiracy charge. What is the likely outcome of their defense of the conspiracy charge?
- The conspiracy charge will be dismissed because they can’t be punished for the completed crime and the conspiracy at the same time.
- The conspiracy is valid because both individuals defrauded their employer out of funds and they helped each other further their respective crimes.
- The conspiracy charge is valid because they don’t have to know what the other is doing to have a conspiracy.
- The conspiracy will be dismissed because they had no agreement to further a crime together; rather each thought that the other’s activities were legal. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The conspiracy will be dismissed because they had no agreement to further a crime together; rather each thought that the other’s activities were legal.
There was no agreement between them regarding the commission of a fraud. There must be an agreement to a common scheme or plan, which there was not here, therefore there is no conspiracy. See, for example, United States v. Rosenblatt, 554 F. 2d 36 (2d Cir. 1977)
Question 73: A buyer and seller agreed on terms to transfer a property to buyer. They wrote up a contract themselves that said: Seller is selling the Old Wilson property to the Buyer, for a value they have agreed on, and the sale should be finished and done in thirty days by cash payment by buyer, or in installments if buyer cannot get a mortgage. The seller changed his mind and filed suit, asking for rescission of the document, on the basis that it was not a contract due to ambiguity and leaving out basic required information. Will the court likely order rescission?
- The document would require a more clear description of the property to be sold, a more clear statement of the purchase price, amount and disposition of earnest money, date of closing and that time is of the essence. Most of these are missing and it leaves too much to guess-work, which is not an enforceable agreement. Rescission will be ordered.
- Yes, because the parties can always keep certain parts of the contract out of the writing, as long as they agree on those extra provisions.
- Yes, the document is not a contract for the sale of real estate because it does not contain all of the information required. (Correct answer)
- No, because the terms stated are definite and precise enough to allow for a final settlement.
Correct answer: Yes, the document is not a contract for the sale of real estate because it does not contain all of the information required.
For a contract for the sale of real estate to be enforceable, it must contain essential terms with sufficient definiteness, including a clear description of the property, a specific purchase price, and definite payment terms. The document here is ambiguous regarding the 'value they have agreed on' and lacks details on earnest money, closing date, and precise installment terms. These missing or vague provisions leave too much to speculation, rendering the agreement unenforceable as a matter of law.
Question 74: A homeowner hires an independent contractor to repair her roof. The contractor negligently drops a tool that injures a passerby on the public sidewalk. Which of the following is most accurate regarding the homeowner's liability?
- The homeowner is strictly liable for all contractor acts on her property.
- The homeowner may be liable if the work was inherently dangerous. (Correct answer)
- The homeowner is vicariously liable because she hired the contractor.
- The homeowner is not liable because independent contractors are not agents.
Correct answer: The homeowner may be liable if the work was inherently dangerous.
An employer is generally not liable for an independent contractor's negligence, but an exception exists for inherently dangerous activities.
Question 75: A trial court admits evidence over a proper objection. For an appellate court to reverse on evidentiary grounds, the appellant must show:
- Any error in admitting the evidence
- The objection was made before the evidence was introduced
- The error was harmless but the court should exercise discretion
- The error affected a substantial right — i.e., was not harmless error (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The error affected a substantial right — i.e., was not harmless error
Under FRE 103(a), an error in admitting or excluding evidence requires reversal only if it affects a substantial right of the party — the harmless error standard.
Question 76: A private organization applied annually for a parade permit to march in the Italian section of the city to celebrate Italian-American Immigration Day. A group of gay, lesbian and bisexual Italian-Americans applied for a permit to join in the parade. The state, pursuant to its public accommodations law, ordered the organization to allow the group in the parade. The organization filed suit, arguing that its right to free speech and expression would be interfered with by having a group with a message different from its own. Because the group was formed to celebrate the members’ sexual orientation, the organization objected to having that message included. What is the most likely decision of the court based on U.S. Supreme Court precedent?
- A parade is a form of free speech and the state’s use of its power violates the First Amendment’s rule that the speaker has the right to choose the content of his own message. (Correct answer)
- Because the group identified itself as Italian-Americans of certain sexual persuasions, the same ethnic identity gave them a right to participate equally in the parade.
- A parade is not a form of free speech and, as such, it can be regulated by government intrusion.
- Because the parade took place under government permission, discrimination against a group due to sexual orientation was impermissible.
Correct answer: A parade is a form of free speech and the state’s use of its power violates the First Amendment’s rule that the speaker has the right to choose the content of his own message.
A parade is a form of free speech. This use of the State's power violates the fundamental rule of protection under the First Amendment, that a speaker has the autonomy to choose the content of his own message. The government does not have the power to compel the speaker to alter the message by including one more acceptable to others. See Hurley v. Irish-American Gay, Lesbian and Bisexual Group of Boston, Inc. - 515 U.S. 557 (1995).
Question 77: Two employees of a large multi-state corporation sued the company for violations of the wage and hour laws of state A, where the two worked and resided. They sued in a state court in state A, and requested class certification on behalf of their co-workers who also worked and resided in State A. The company filed to remove the case to the federal district court in state B based on federal diversity jurisdiction. The plaintiffs objected to removal because they asserted that the company's principal place of business was in State A, which destroyed diversity jurisdiction under the circumstances. The company argued that its principal place of business was in State B, thus creating diversity jurisdiction in the federal court. Which of the following would be the main basis for the court’s determination of where the company had it principal place of business?
- In the state where the highest volume of activity is conducted in terms of volume of sales.
- In the state where the officers direct, control, and maintain its activities. (Correct answer)
- In the state where its incorporation papers were filed and where its registered agent officially accepts all papers and service of process.
- In the state with the highest population and the greatest potential for the most customers.
Correct answer: In the state where the officers direct, control, and maintain its activities.
The federal diversity jurisdiction statute provides that "a corporation shall be deemed to be a citizen of any State by which it has been incorporated and of the State where it has its principal place of business." 28 U.S.C. § 1332(c)(1) See The Hertz Corporation v. Friend, 130 S.Ct. 1181 (2010). The Supreme Court ruled in Hertz that the "principal place of business" for purposes of determining whether there was diversity citizenship was the place where the corporation's officers direct, control, and coordinate the corporation's activities. It is called the corporation's "nerve center." Hertz, 130 S.Ct. 1192. In practice, it should normally be the place where the corporation maintains its headquarters—provided that the headquarters is the actual center of direction, control, and coordination, i.e., the "nerve center," and not simply an office where the corporation holds its board meetings.
Question 78: An employee of a retail chain filed a class action against the company alleging wage and hour violations. The complaint alleged that the plaintiff and other salespersons had to make summary reports after they clocked out each day. They had to type up the reports and submit them to their supervisor each day. The suit claimed an average of 15 hours per week of overtime that went uncompensated. The plaintiff sought to represent about 1,000 sales employees who were required to fill out the forms and who did not get paid for the overtime. The employer filed a motion to dismiss the class action, stating that each case was different to some degree, the amount of wages claimed by each employee would differ, and that the plaintiff could not represent the class properly as required by law. Will the court dismiss the case because there are deviations in the facts of some of the cases?
- No, because the employer's claim is general and can be taken up later; it appears that the cases are all very similar and they all deal with the same challenged policy of the employer. (Correct answer)
- Yes, because it would be unmanageable for the plaintiff to represent the interests of 1,000 employees in addition to his own interests.
- Yes, a class action requires precise uniformity of facts for each member of the class.
- No, because the class members can have widely divergent facts and legal issues in their cases, but if they work for the same employer these issues may all be decided at the same time.
Correct answer: No, because the employer's claim is general and can be taken up later; it appears that the cases are all very similar and they all deal with the same challenged policy of the employer.
Fed.R.Civ.P. 23(a)(2) requires commonality, i.e., that there are questions of law or fact common to the class. Rule 23(a)(2) does not require identical claims or facts among class members. Chiang v. Veneman, 385 F.3d 256, 265 (3d Cir.2004). For purposes of Rule 23(a)(2), even a single common question will do. Wal-Mart Stores v. Dukes, ___ U.S. ___, 131 S.Ct. 2541, 2556 180 L.Ed.2d 374 (2011). However, having “widely divergent facts and legal issues” would not serve the efficient administration of justice. Commonality requires the plaintiff to demonstrate that the class members have suffered essentially the same injury. Their claims must depend upon a common contention which must be capable of classwide resolution—which means that determination of its legal validity will resolve an issue that is central to the decision for all claims in one stroke. Dukes, 131 S.Ct. at 2551. Here, the individual employees may have different losses and some divergent facts, but they are all victims of the same employer policy of making them work overtime, fill in forms, and not get paid.
Question 79: A woman asked a male friend to hold her valuable antique jewelry in safe storage for her while she traveled in a foreign country. He owned a jewelry store and graciously offered to store the collection for free. He also volunteered to get the jewelry insured at his own expense. She relied on the promises, and turned over the collection to him without the payment of monetary consideration. He forgot to get the jewelry insured, and the collection was stolen in an armed robbery of the jewelry store. When she returned, he refused to compensate her for the stolen collection. Which one of the following legal principles would be her strongest and most accurate claim for remuneration under these facts?
- The principle of promissory estoppel. (Correct answer)
- The principle of unilateral contract.
- The principle of natural consideration.
- The principle of equitable trust.
Correct answer: The principle of promissory estoppel.
The principle of promissory estoppel applies when a clear and unambiguous promise is made, the promisee reasonably and foreseeably relies on that promise, and the promisee suffers detriment as a result of that reliance. Here, the friend promised to insure the jewelry, the woman relied on this promise by not seeking other insurance, and she suffered a loss when the uninsured collection was stolen, making promissory estoppel her strongest claim.
Question 80: A federal statute governing food stamp fraud makes it a crime to knowingly acquire or possess food coupons in a manner not authorized by the statute or the regulations. A grocery store owner purchased discounted food stamps from an undercover agent, and was arrested for violating the statute. At trial, the store owner claimed that the government must prove that he had the specific intent to commit a crime. The government contended it only had to show that he knowingly acquired food stamps, and that this was not a specific intent crime. The trial judge adopted the government's interpretation, and the store owner was convicted. His appeal made it all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. Will the Court likely reverse or affirm the conviction and why?
- Conviction reversed, because a store owner is exempt from the statute, which applies only to consumers who use food stamps illegally.
- Conviction reversed, because the better interpretation is that mens rea is included, and the owner must know his conduct is in violation of the criminal laws. (Correct answer)
- Conviction affirmed, because the meaning of knowingly does not connote that there must be specific knowledge by the actor that what he is doing is illegal.
- Conviction affirmed, because the modern trend of the law is to recognize criminal liability without mens rea or specific criminal intent.
Correct answer: Conviction reversed, because the better interpretation is that mens rea is included, and the owner must know his conduct is in violation of the criminal laws.
In federal criminal statutes, particularly those involving complex regulatory schemes, the term 'knowingly' often requires not just knowledge of the facts constituting the offense, but also knowledge that the conduct is unlawful. This is especially true when the statute criminalizes conduct that might otherwise appear innocent. Therefore, the government likely needed to prove the store owner knew his acquisition of discounted food stamps was unauthorized and illegal, not just that he acquired them.
Question 81: Under the Fourth Amendment, a person retains a reasonable expectation of privacy in which of the following?
- Bank records voluntarily shared with a financial institution
- Garbage placed at the curb for collection
- The contents of a sealed letter sent through the U.S. Mail (Correct answer)
- Conversations spoken aloud in a public park
Correct answer: The contents of a sealed letter sent through the U.S. Mail
Sealed letters in the mail are constitutionally protected because the sender retains a reasonable expectation of privacy in their contents, unlike garbage set out for collection or information shared with third parties.
Question 82: A defendant threatens to expose embarrassing (but legal) information about a victim unless paid $5,000, and the victim pays. The defendant is charged with extortion. Is the threat to reveal legal information sufficient for extortion?
- No, because the information is not criminal
- Yes, only if the victim suffered actual harm
- Yes, because extortion covers threats to expose any information to obtain property (Correct answer)
- No, because the information was true
Correct answer: Yes, because extortion covers threats to expose any information to obtain property
Extortion (blackmail) covers threats to expose any information — criminal or embarrassing but legal — made to obtain money or property from the victim.
Question 83: A defendant, intending to kill his enemy, poisons the enemy's coffee. The enemy drinks it but does not die due to medical intervention. The defendant is charged with attempted murder. Under the MPC, which test applies?
- Dangerous proximity test
- Last act test
- Substantial step test (Correct answer)
- Proximity test
Correct answer: Substantial step test
The MPC uses the substantial step test, which asks whether the defendant took a substantial step strongly corroborative of criminal purpose.
Question 84: An offeror offers to sell a parcel of land to an offeree for $10,000, stating that the offer shall remain open for 30 days. The offeree replies that she will keep the offeror’s offer under advisement but says, “We can wrap this up immediately if you’ll take $9,000.” The offeror does not reply, but within the 30-day period the offeree accepts the original offer. The offeror, however, replies that he now wants $12,500. Was a contract formed when the offeree accepted the $10,000 offer?
- Yes, because the original offer must always legally remain in effect for the remainder of the specified 30 days, even after a counter-offer has been communicated.
- No, because when a counter-offer was made the offeror was then free to change the offer to $12,500 and the original offer became rescinded.
- Yes, because the offeree was able to keep the original offer with the 30-day window open by stating that he was keeping it under advisement. (Correct answer)
- No, because once the offeree made a counter-offer she could not go back and later accept the original offer.
Correct answer: Yes, because the offeree was able to keep the original offer with the 30-day window open by stating that he was keeping it under advisement.
A counter-offer typically terminates the original offer, but an inquiry or negotiation does not. The offeree's statement, 'We can wrap this up immediately if you’ll take $9,000,' coupled with her intention to keep the original offer 'under advisement,' indicates an exploration of terms rather than a definitive rejection. Since the original offer explicitly stated it would remain open for 30 days, it created an option period, and the offeree's subsequent acceptance within that period was valid.
Question 85: A group of college students published a monthly magazine with the purpose of challenging the laws of government and the values of society, and to thus stimulate creative thinking and expression. It criticized all religions, had drawings of public officials in sexual and corrupt activities, and mocked virtually all societal values. There was a flurry of frantic complaints to state legislators, who passed a law permanently enjoining the college from publishing the magazine without first getting the prior approval of designated state authorities for each new edition. The college brought an action to declare the law unconstitutional. Will the court strike down the statute?
- No, because a “gag order” of this kind is sometimes required to stop the defamation of public officials and religious leaders.
- Yes, because it’s an illegal prior restraint on free speech. (Correct answer)
- Yes, because it violates the establishment clause.
- No, because the publication fell below the standards required for free speech.
Correct answer: Yes, because it’s an illegal prior restraint on free speech.
The law requiring prior approval from state authorities before publishing the magazine constitutes a prior restraint on speech. Prior restraints are administrative or judicial orders that forbid certain communications before they occur, and they are heavily disfavored under the First Amendment. Such restraints bear a strong presumption of unconstitutionality because they prevent speech from ever reaching the public, even if it might ultimately be found protected.
Question 86: A merchant sends a signed written offer to sell 500 widgets at $10 each, stating the offer is 'firm for 30 days.' Under the UCC, this offer:
- Is irrevocable for 30 days even without consideration (Correct answer)
- May be revoked at any time before acceptance
- Expires after 3 months regardless of its stated term
- Is irrevocable only if the offeree gave consideration
Correct answer: Is irrevocable for 30 days even without consideration
Under UCC § 2-205, a merchant's signed, written firm offer is irrevocable for the stated period (up to 3 months) without any consideration from the offeree.
Question 87: A lessor leased real estate with a gas station business on it to a lessee for two-year terms that were renewable every two years until the tenth year. The property was described as being “located at 1900 Superpower Highway, fronting on the highway 100 feet and extending in depth of equal width 150 feet, as described in Deed Vol. 22, Page 10, with the privilege of using additional adjoining grounds for the general use of the business and the parking of customer's cars.” The lessor granted an option to purchase the “demised premises” at the “current market value at the end of the final term.” The lessee exercised the option (for property at Deed Vol. 22, Page 10) as provided, but the lessor refused to perform. Lessee brought an action for specific performance, to which the lessor responded that the price was indefinite and subject to debate, and that it was unclear if the option included the “additional adjoining grounds,” making specific performance unavailable. Will the court grant the complaint for specific performance and order that the plaintiff’s exercise of the option be enforced?
- No, because it is impossible to determine if the option includes the adjoining lands; furthermore, current market value is an ambiguous term subject to debate by experts.
- No, because it could not be determined whether “current market value” meant the value at the entering of the lease or the value at the end of the lease.
- Yes, because specific performance applies to a right to enforce the option, and the precise terms of the option can be ironed out by the court through the taking of testimony and hearing evidence.
- Yes, because the land is specifically described at the deed reference, and the “market value” at a specified time is held by courts to be a sufficiently precise description of price. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Yes, because the land is specifically described at the deed reference, and the “market value” at a specified time is held by courts to be a sufficiently precise description of price.
It’s true that specific performance will not be granted where the terms are not definite enough to perform. Here, the “demised premises” does not include the additional adjoining grounds because, for one thing, the property is specifically determined by the dimensions included at the referenced deed book and page number. The term “market value” at a certain time has been held sufficiently definite to determine a price for the property. Where a contract specifies that the price is to be measured by the "fair market value" or "reasonable value" of the property involved, courts have generally held that the price is sufficiently certain to enforce the agreement. Moreover, the law recognizes in the area of enforceability of contracts the maxim, "id certum est quod certum reddi potest" (that is certain which can be made certain). See Portnoy v. Brown, 430 Pa. 401 (Pa. Supreme Court 1968).
Question 88: A young man was arrested for statutory rape involving a fifteen-year-old girl. The girl had identified him as the person with whom she was having sexual relations. He asserted in his defense that the girl was sexually active and that she had intercourse with other men but not with him. He tried to offer into evidence testimony regarding the prior sexual activities of the girl and to identify other men with whom she had sexual encounters. Part of the defendant’s evidence would describe the girl’s need and desire to cover-up her other relationships, which gave her a motive to wrongly accuse the young man. Is the evidence admissible on the defendant’s behalf?
- It is inadmissible due to the likelihood that the defendant will merely try to dig up “dirt” regarding the victim’s reputation that has no relevancy to his specific charges.
- It is admissible because an individual’s prior sexual activities are always admissible to show bad character of the victim.
- It is admissible to show that one or more others may have raped her instead of the defendant, and that she had a motive to want to blame the young man and to cover-up the other relationships. (Correct answer)
- It is inadmissible under the rape shield provision of the federal rules because it is trying to cast aspersions that are irrelevant to the charges against the defendant.
Correct answer: It is admissible to show that one or more others may have raped her instead of the defendant, and that she had a motive to want to blame the young man and to cover-up the other relationships.
While rape shield laws (like Federal Rule of Evidence 412) generally prohibit evidence of a victim's past sexual behavior, there are specific exceptions. Evidence of a victim's past sexual behavior is admissible if offered to prove that someone other than the defendant was the source of physical evidence, or if its exclusion would violate the defendant's constitutional rights, such as the right to present a defense by showing an alternative perpetrator or a motive for the victim to fabricate the accusation.
Question 89: A defendant was charged and convicted of felony murder as a participant in a robbery in which the store clerk was murdered by his accomplice. The authorities then indicted and convicted him of robbery with a firearm. The two prosecutions were not the same offense because felony murder could be proved by proof of any felony, not just robbery, and robbery with a firearm did not require proof of a death. However, the prosecution acknowledged that it was necessary for all the ingredients of the underlying felony of robbery with a firearm to be proved in the felony-murder trial. Will the defendant prevail on appeal in getting the robbery with a firearm conviction dismissed with prejudice on the basis of a double jeopardy violation?
- Yes, because the second prosecution of using a firearm in a robbery was based on the same firearm already proved in the earlier case, and when the same firearm is raised twice, double jeopardy applies.
- No, because the second prosecution was for a status crime of using a firearm in a robbery and as such it was totally different from the first prosecution.
- No, because the two offenses were different and required different elements of proof, the second prosecution was valid.
- Yes, because it was necessary for all the ingredients of robbery with a firearm to be proved in the felony-murder trial, the second prosecution was barred by the double jeopardy constitutional prohibition. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Yes, because it was necessary for all the ingredients of robbery with a firearm to be proved in the felony-murder trial, the second prosecution was barred by the double jeopardy constitutional prohibition.
The U.S. Supreme Court has held that the Double Jeopardy Clause bars any subsequent prosecution in which the government, to establish an essential element of an offense charged in that prosecution, will prove conduct that constitutes an offense for which the defendant has already been prosecuted. See Grady v. Corbin, 495 US 508 (1990); Harris v. Oklahoma, 433 U. S. 682 (1977).
Question 90: A married couple own a residential premises. They received a foreclosure action from the first mortgage lender in a state that has judicial foreclosure procedures. The state also statutorily extends the right of redemption both prior to the sale, and for a period of one year after the sale. The sale took place; the property was sold to the lender. The lender then filed a deficiency judgment action. The couple received a loan from family members about six months after the sale. It was sufficient to pay the balance on the mortgage plus interest and costs. The couple notified the lender and the court of their intent to exercise their right of redemption. What is the likely outcome?
- The court will order the couple evicted because they should have acted prior to the entry of the deficiency judgment.
- The couple will exercise their right of redemption to retain ownership of their property. (Correct answer)
- The court ruled that the lender did not have a right to file a deficiency judgment, and it ordered the foreclosure action null and void without the couple having to exercise the right of redemption.
- A hearing must first be held to determine whether abatement has occurred.
Correct answer: The couple will exercise their right of redemption to retain ownership of their property.
At the end of the redemption period, if the former homeowner cannot exercise the right of redemption, the new owners have the right to evict them. Here, the couple will be able to exercise the right of redemption, assuming they have sufficient funds to do so, and title will revert back to them by order of court.
Question 91: A businessman files a complaint for defamation against a former customer in a federal district court. The businessman sends an adult friend to serve the complaint and summons to the home of the former customer. The friend leaves the papers with a cleaning person who is the only person home, and who has control of the premises for just the several hours while she is there doing her job. The defendant files a motion to dismiss for insufficiency of service of process under Rule 12(b)(5). Assume that state law regarding service of a complaint is the same as Rule 4 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. What is the court's likely decision and reason?
- The court will grant the motion and reject service because the papers must be served only on the defendant herself.
- The court will deny the motion and allow service because the circumstances point to reliable service of process.
- The court will deny the motion and allow service due to the fact that the person had control of the house for that temporary time.
- The court will grant the motion and reject service because the person served did not reside there. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The court will grant the motion and reject service because the person served did not reside there.
Rule 4( e) provides that the complaint and summons must be delivered to the person individually, or by leaving a copy at the defendant's dwelling or abode with someone of suitable age and discretion who resides there. Clearly, the cleaning person does not reside there and service under these facts is defective.
Question 92: The defendant was convicted under a criminal statute of raping a child under the age of 12. The court sentenced him to death pursuant to the permissible provisions of the criminal statute. The defendant appealed the death sentence, claiming that it violates the Eighth Amendment by imposing a sentence that is cruel and unusual based on the crime committed. Based on U.S. Supreme Court Eighth Amendment jurisprudence, what will be the most likely outcome?
- The death penalty can never be imposed on someone who did not take human life despite the despicable nature of the crime.
- The death penalty can be imposed whether or not human life was taken as long as the statute includes it as a specified punishment.
- This was as heinous a crime as can be imagined and the penalty of death is therefore justified despite the fact that the victim survived the brutal sexual attack.
- With respect to crimes against individuals, the death penalty should not be extended to instances where human life was not taken. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: With respect to crimes against individuals, the death penalty should not be extended to instances where human life was not taken.
This is a crime against the individual, and not the state. In this kind of crime, the U.S. Supreme Court has held that it is unconstitutional to put a man to death when there was no taking of life.
Question 93: A woman asked a male friend to hold her valuable antique jewelry in safe storage for her while she traveled in a foreign country. He owned a jewelry store and graciously offered to store the collection for free. He also volunteered to get the jewelry insured at his own expense. She relied on the promises, and turned over the collection to him without the payment of monetary consideration. He forgot to get the jewelry insured, and the collection was stolen in an armed robbery of the jewelry store. When she returned, he refused to compensate her for the stolen collection. Which one of the following legal principles would be her strongest and most accurate claim for remuneration under these facts?
- The principle of natural consideration.
- The principle of promissory estoppel. (Correct answer)
- The principle of equitable trust.
- The principle of unilateral contract.
Correct answer: The principle of promissory estoppel.
While the friend's promise to insure the jewelry was a gratuitous promise lacking consideration, the woman reasonably and foreseeably relied on that promise to her detriment by entrusting him with her valuable collection and not seeking her own insurance. Promissory estoppel allows for the enforcement of such promises to prevent injustice when there has been clear detrimental reliance. The friend's failure to insure, leading to the loss, makes promissory estoppel the strongest claim for remuneration.
Question 94: When she was seven months pregnant, a female executive assistant employee was let go from her job. She filed a Title VII civil rights lawsuit against the company in federal court alleging gender discrimination. The proposed witness had been a vice-president of the company and a close adviser to the president; at trial, she was not permitted to testify that she heard the human relations manager say in an informal meeting that the plaintiff and her predecessor were both fired due to what the manager described as "pregnancy complications." The jury rendered a verdict in favor of the defendant employer without the benefit of such crucial testimony. The plaintiff maintained that the testimony should have been accepted and that it did not qualify as hearsay under federal regulations in the appeal. The court is likely to rule in favor of the appeal and mandate a fresh trial.
- No, because it was based on things that the co-worker heard from others, making double-hearsay that is never admissible.
- Yes, because it was admissible under the "spontaneous utterance" exception to the hearsay rules.
- Yes, because that kind of testimony is reliable and not excludable as hearsay. (Correct answer)
- No, because the statement is clearly hearsay with no exception to the hearsay rule being applicable.
Correct answer: Yes, because that kind of testimony is reliable and not excludable as hearsay.
Explanation: <br> A statement submitted against a party and made by the party's agent or servant about an issue within the scope of the agency or employment is not <br> considered hearsay, according to Rule 801(d)(2)(D). during the duration of the relationship. The case is Zaken v. Boerer, 964 F. (2d Cir. 1992) 2d 1319, <br> 1322–23. These elements give the statement a high level of dependability and tend to favor its admission as a non-hearsay statement. In essence, this <br> statement was made against the employer's interest by the employer's agent or servant while performing their duties.
Question 95: In a personal injury case for damages suffered by plaintiff, a nurse at the treating hospital testified that the plaintiff failed or refused to take his prescribed medications on seven different occasions during his hospital stay. On cross-examination, it became clear that the nurse’s testimony was not based on personal knowledge as she was not at work during several of the instances she mentioned. In these several instances, the sole basis for her testimony was what she read in the medical charts, which were not in evidence at the trial. The defense objected to the evidence and asked that it be stricken. The trial judge overruled the objection. The plaintiff appealed the issue. What was the likely holding of the court of appeals regarding the nurse’s testimony?
- The nurse, as a treating medical provider, was allowed to make inferences from the medical records and therefore the evidence was admissible.
- The testimony was based on the nurse’s knowledge regarding the reliability of the medical records and, as such, she was qualified to testify on information from them.
- The testimony was based on unauthenticated medical records not entered into evidence; the testimony was inadmissible hearsay, and not based on the witness’ personal knowledge. (Correct answer)
- The testimony was not allowed because it was irrelevant and immaterial.
Correct answer: The testimony was based on unauthenticated medical records not entered into evidence; the testimony was inadmissible hearsay, and not based on the witness’ personal knowledge.
A witness must have personal knowledge of a matter to testify about it, as required by Federal Rule of Evidence 602. The nurse's testimony regarding instances she did not personally observe, relying solely on medical charts not admitted into evidence, lacks this foundational personal knowledge. Furthermore, her recounting of the charts' contents, offered to prove the patient's non-compliance, constitutes inadmissible hearsay because the records themselves were not properly introduced under an exception.
Question 96: A witness in a murder case doesn't always offer the same account truthfully; instead, he has given many accounts of his observations to various people and investigators throughout the course of time. The witness was called to the stand by the prosecution during the trial to describe what he saw. By referencing earlier contradictory statements and charging him with fabricating his testimony, the defendant's attorney attacked the credibility of the witness's testimony. The prosecution then made an effort to restore his credibility by bringing up earlier, reliable remarks. Since prior consistent comments are alleged to be repetitive, cumulative, and to unfairly enhance the witness's credibility, they are typically not admissible. Will the court probably permit the prosecution to rehabilitate the witness based on earlier reliable testimony in light of these circumstances?
- No, because the witness cannot be rehabilitated once a successful impeachment has occurred.
- Yes, because it is being used to rehabilitate a witness whose credibility was attacked. (Correct answer)
- No, because it would tend to confuse the jury with too much conflicting evidence.
- Yes, because all repetitive prior statements are important to show the consistency of the witness’ testimony.
Correct answer: Yes, because it is being used to rehabilitate a witness whose credibility was attacked.
Explanation: <br> Repeated prior consistent remarks improperly support the witness' evidence. There is one exception, nevertheless, in which the previous reliable <br> statement is required to restore the witness' credibility after being called into question on cross-examination. Rule 801(d)(1)(B) of the Federal Rules of <br> Evidence was amended in 2014 to add two grounds for allowing the prior consistent statement: ""(i) to rebut an express or implied charge that the <br> declarant recently fabricated it or acted from a recent improper influence or motive in so testifying; or (ii) to rehabilitate the declarant's credibility as a <br> witness when attacked on another ground. The rule provides enough justification for the rehabilitation inquiries to be permitted. Observe Mason v. US, <br> 53 A, for instance. (DC Ct of App 2012) 3d 1084, 1090.
Question 97: In a case for sexual harassment, the jury entered a monetary verdict in favor of the plaintiff. She alleged that her supervisor persistently demanded sexual favors in return for promotions, that he had sent her lascivious text messages and semi-nude photos of himself on several occasions. Her complaints were ignored by the employer. The jury believed the plaintiff and returned a verdict for her. The defendants, i.e., the supervisor and the employer company, filed a motion under Rule 59(a) asking for a new trial. Without alleging specifics, the defendants asked the court to recognize that the verdict was against the manifest weight of the evidence. Under these facts, which of the following is the most likely decision and reasoning of the court?
- The motion will be granted because it specifically demonstrates that the jury's verdict was against the manifest weight of the evidence.
- The motion will be rejected because there was sufficient evidence to support the verdict and the movants alleged only conclusions. (Correct answer)
- The motion will be granted because the plaintiff's testimony was insufficient evidence in itself to support the verdict.
- The motion will be denied because the defendants cannot get a new trial unless they prove that the plaintiff was lying about what happened.
Correct answer: The motion will be rejected because there was sufficient evidence to support the verdict and the movants alleged only conclusions.
A court may only order a new trial if the jury's "`verdict is against the manifest weight of the evidence, ... or if for other reasons the trial was not fair to the moving party.'" Marcus & Millichap Inv. Servs. v. Sekulovski, 639 F.3d 301, 313 (7th Cir.2011). The moving party cannot just allege a manifest weight of the evidence argument without giving the court specific reasons. Willis v. Lepine, 687 F. 3d 826, 836 (7th Cir. 2012). Here, defendants make only a bald allegation and give nothing to back it up. A motion for new trial should not be granted "simply because the court would have arrived at a different verdict." Pavao v. Pagay, 307 F.3d 915, 918 (9th Cir. 2002); U.S. v. 40 Acres, 175 F.3d 1133, 1139 (9th Cir. 1999). A motion based on insufficiency of the evidence can only be granted if the verdict is against the great weight of the evidence or if the jury has reached a seriously erroneous result. Digidyne Corp. v. Data Gen. Corp., 734 F.2d 1336, 1347 (9th Cir. 1984).
Question 98: A 35-year-old married man who worked for many years as a roofing and siding installer for a contractor was rear-ended by an 18-wheeler while stopped at a stop light. He sustained multiple fractures and lesions along his spinal cord and was declared by his doctors and the trucking company’s doctors to be totally and permanently disabled. In his suit against the trucking company, the damages include a demand for compensation for the permanent loss of earnings of the plaintiff for the remainder of his work life. How does the plaintiff best prove what amount he is entitled to receive for future lost wages, i.e., permanent and total loss of earning capacity?
- By presenting a tax specialist and certified financial planner to compute the average annual wage less all annual taxes and average expenses of living, and multiplying that net figure by the estimated remaining years of work life, reduced to present value.
- There are official tables published by the government that provide the amount of lost earnings that a person suffers, for purposes of a tort recovery, for a specified period of years.
- By presenting an economist or actuarial witness who in general computes lost wages and benefits for the estimated remainder of his work life, adding for inflation, and then applying a discount rate to reduce that amount to present value. (Correct answer)
- He must have his employer verify how much he was making and then present a disability expert to multiply that by the number of years until retirement and add a growth rate for future inflation.
Correct answer: By presenting an economist or actuarial witness who in general computes lost wages and benefits for the estimated remainder of his work life, adding for inflation, and then applying a discount rate to reduce that amount to present value.
To prove permanent loss of earning capacity, a plaintiff typically relies on expert testimony from an economist or actuarial witness. This expert computes the estimated lost wages and benefits for the remainder of the plaintiff's work life, factoring in potential inflation or growth, and then applies a discount rate to reduce that total to its present value. This method provides a legally recognized and comprehensive calculation for future economic damages.
Question 99: An owner of a small online startup company sued a competitor for copyright infringement and interference with contract. At trial, the owner's attorney questioned a juror who stated that she had worked for the competitor for 10 years in the past and still did regular part-time work for the company when it was extra busy. However, under questioning she stated that she could hear the case fairly and without prejudice. Can the attorney prevail in a motion to strike the juror for cause?
- No, because the assertion that she could fairly decide the case erases the tendency to presume bias on her part.
- Yes, because the juror had a business relationship with the defendant that has not yet even ended, there is too much chance for bias. (Correct answer)
- No, because having worked for one of the litigants is not a grounds to make any assumptions whatsoever about the potential juror's ability to be fair.
- Yes, because by having knowledge of the business practices of the defendant it makes her absolutely unqualified to serve as a juror on any cases involving the same type of business.
Correct answer: Yes, because the juror had a business relationship with the defendant that has not yet even ended, there is too much chance for bias.
A juror can be struck for cause if there is actual or implied bias. A current or very recent employment relationship with a party creates a strong presumption of implied bias, even if the juror claims impartiality. The ongoing part-time work for the defendant competitor presents a significant risk that the juror's judgment could be influenced, justifying removal for cause.
Question 100: A developer purchased two lots of ocean front property. He intended to build two single-family high-end homes like adjacent homes built in the surrounding areas. Two years later, the state passed a beachfront protection statute that prohibited the developer from building on his lots. The developer filed a claim in state court demanding compensation for a taking of his property under the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments because the state denied all economic uses of the property. The trial court agreed that the property was now economically useless, and awarded compensation to the developer. However, on appeal the supreme court of the state reversed. The United States Supreme Court granted certiorari. Did the U.S. Supreme Court grant the developer’s plea for compensation based on an unconstitutional taking of his property by the state?
- No, the valid exercise of the police powers by the state cannot result in a claim for compensation by a property owner.
- Yes, compensation is payable for a taking of property where a statute or regulation takes away all economic use of the land. (Correct answer)
- No, the statute did not forbid all uses of the property; there were still social and recreational uses that remained.
- Yes, any interference with a landowner’s interest in building commercial property is prohibited by the due process clause and requires compensation.
Correct answer: Yes, compensation is payable for a taking of property where a statute or regulation takes away all economic use of the land.
The Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment, made applicable to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment, provides that private property shall not “be taken for public use, without just compensation.” Lingle v. Chevron USA Inc., 544 U.S. 528, 536-37. When the owner of real property has been called upon to sacrifice all economically beneficial uses in the name of the common good, that is, to leave his property economically idle, he has suffered a taking for which reasonable compensation must be paid. See Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Council, 505 U.S. 1003, 1019, 1027 (1992).
Question 101: A man entered into a lease for an apartment with a landlord. The lease stated that the term was month-to-month. After one month, the man went to the city health and licensing department and complained about various sanitary code violations that the landlord failed to correct. The agency made an inspection and found 40 sanitary code violations. It cited the landlord, and ordered him to clear up all of the violations. After the inspection, the landlord brought an eviction action against the man and obtained a judgment against him for eviction. Will the eviction order hold up under the stated facts?
- Yes, because the law of landlord-tenant generally favors the landlord and doesn’t require that the landlord make repairs or keep a property up to code.
- No, because eviction is not recognized with respect to a month-to-month lease; instead, the tenant must vacate immediately on receiving written notice.
- No, because the landlord’s action is a retaliatory eviction, which cannot be used against a tenant who reports code violations and is a defense that the tenant may raise. (Correct answer)
- Yes, because the tenant’s act of disloyalty is a breach of the lease that may be enforced by an eviction action.
Correct answer: No, because the landlord’s action is a retaliatory eviction, which cannot be used against a tenant who reports code violations and is a defense that the tenant may raise.
Most jurisdictions recognize the defense of retaliatory eviction, which prohibits landlords from evicting tenants for exercising their legal rights, such as reporting housing code violations. The landlord's eviction action immediately following the tenant's complaint and the subsequent citation for 40 violations strongly indicates a retaliatory motive. Therefore, the eviction order will likely not hold up as it is an unlawful retaliatory act.
Question 102: A customer was shopping at a large retail mall. She slipped and broke her hip on a patch of clear oily residue. It had accumulated over a two-day period in front of a massage kiosk, and spread several feet onto the main walking area for customers. There was a small sign as a part of the massage kiosk display on the front counter that said, “Beware of slippery floors.” The customer had been looking ahead and walking when her feet slid wildly off of the floor and sent her body somersaulting into the air and down onto the concrete foundation. After learning that she would be disabled permanently, she sued the mall and the massage company. Will she likely prevail in her negligence claim against the mall?
- Yes, because the mall is strictly liable to licensees who are allowed on the land for all injuries that they may sustain.
- No, because the mall owes no duty to business invitees to inspect the premises and to fix or warn of potential dangers that it discovers.
- Yes, because the mall owes a duty to its business invitees to inspect and discover dangerous artificial conditions on the premises; the mall must make these safe or post a conspicuous warning of the danger. (Correct answer)
- No, because the mall cannot be responsible for a danger that emanated from a kiosk in that it doesn’t even have the authority to inspect the potential dangers in and around the kiosk area.
Correct answer: Yes, because the mall owes a duty to its business invitees to inspect and discover dangerous artificial conditions on the premises; the mall must make these safe or post a conspicuous warning of the danger.
The highest duty is owed to the business invitee. In this case a customer shopping for goods was a business invitee, as opposed to a trespasser or mere licensee. The duty owed to a business invitee includes inspecting for dangers, and making them safe, or posting a noticeable warning of the danger. Here, the oil had spread out into the main walkway and, although the kiosk had a duty to clean it up, the mall also was responsible, particularly for its main walkways.
Question 103: A Wildlife Preservation League sued the U.S. Coast Guard to obtain a preliminary injunction to stop certain “war games” being conducted by the Coast Guard. The sonar blasts were allegedly disruptive to natural wildlife and fish populations. The plaintiff could not prove actual injury to wildlife, but did present expert testimony that this was a distinct possibility for the future. There was uncontested testimony by the Coast Guard indicating an increase in crime if the games were closed. The lower courts approved a preliminary injunction stopping the games until further order. This was based on the growing possibility that the wildlife would be disrupted and/or displaced. The Coast Guard appealed and the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to hear the appeal. Is it likely that the Supreme Court will uphold the injunction, and why or why not?
- Yes, because it virtually always defers to the lower court’s discretion on whether an injunction should issue.
- No, because in this case the interests of national defense outweighed the interests of the wildlife organization. (Correct answer)
- Yes, because there was a possibility of irreparable harm to the wildlife in the area of the games.
- No, because there was no real indication of danger to the wildlife population.
Correct answer: No, because in this case the interests of national defense outweighed the interests of the wildlife organization.
See Winter v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., 129 S. Ct. 365, 377-78 (2008). In the makeup of the court in 2008, national defense interests outweighed wildlife concerns. Also, the Court held that the possibility of irreparable harm was too easy of a standard and that it had to be “likely” that harm to wildlife would be irreparable.
Question 104: A defendant honestly and reasonably believed he was about to be attacked and killed a person who turned out to be an innocent bystander. Under the MPC, is imperfect self-defense available?
- Yes, the defendant may be convicted of a lesser offense due to the honest but unreasonable belief
- Yes, the honest belief is a complete defense under the MPC (Correct answer)
- No, because self-defense requires the threat to be real
- No, because the victim was innocent
Correct answer: Yes, the honest belief is a complete defense under the MPC
Under the MPC, an honest but mistaken belief in the need for self-defense is a complete defense if the belief was reasonable; if unreasonable, it may reduce but not eliminate liability.
Question 105: Congress passes a law making it a federal crime to possess a firearm within 1,000 feet of a school. Under what constitutional basis was this law ultimately struck down?
- It violated the Second Amendment right to bear arms
- Congress exceeded its Commerce Clause authority because gun possession near schools is not economic activity (Correct answer)
- It violated the Tenth Amendment by commandeering state police
- It violated the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment
Correct answer: Congress exceeded its Commerce Clause authority because gun possession near schools is not economic activity
In United States v. Lopez, the Court held the Gun-Free School Zones Act exceeded Congress's Commerce Clause power because firearm possession near schools was not economic activity substantially affecting interstate commerce.
Question 106: A group of neighbors sued an industrial plant under the provisions of the federal Clean Water Act for discharging mercury and other poisons into a river near their properties. The group asked for an injunction and civil penalties to stop the discharges. The discharges were tested and exceeded the maximum amounts of several pollutants allowable under federal regulations. After the suit was filed, the industrial plant ceased the polluting activities and was able to get its discharges into compliance, and obtained a renewal of its permit. The company then asserted that the lawsuit was moot. What was the likely decision of the federal court?
- The case was not moot because there was always the possibility that the defendant could return to its old ways without a judicial determination. (Correct answer)
- The case was not moot because the propriety of granting them a new permit had to be reviewed by the court.
- The case was moot because there was no longer a “case or controversy” before the court.
- The case was moot because there was no activity that could be enjoined anymore.
Correct answer: The case was not moot because there was always the possibility that the defendant could return to its old ways without a judicial determination.
A case might become moot if subsequent events made it absolutely clear that the allegedly wrongful behavior could not reasonably be expected to recur. In this case that possibility of a resumption of illegal activities still existed. Friends of Earth, Inc. v. Laidlaw Environmental Services (TOC), Inc., 528 U.S. 167 (1999).
Question 107: Immediately after a shooting incident, the police chased one of the shooters into an apartment where he was apprehended and arrested. While in the apartment, a detective noticed some antique furniture that seemed of collectors’ quality and was out of place in the squalidly furnished quarters. He moved and turned over the pieces to look for markings and insignia. He called headquarters, and was told that items with those markings and descriptions were stolen from a museum six months earlier. He seized the items and arrested another occupant, who claimed he owned the items, on charges of burglary. That suspect filed a motion to suppress based on there being a warrantless search without probable cause. The police relied on the plain view doctrine. Will the court likely suppress the evidence?
- No, the evidence was subject to further search and seizure because it was in plain view and the officer had a reasonable suspicion that it was contraband.
- No, the evidence was properly seized because the officer had a right to investigate it further once he had properly entered the apartment under exigent circumstances.
- Yes, the evidence must be suppressed because the plain view doctrine does not apply where the officer had no probable cause to believe that the observed item was contraband. (Correct answer)
- Yes, the evidence will be suppressed because the police can never search a personal residence or seize any unrelated items after entering for exigent circumstances dealing with something else.
Correct answer: Yes, the evidence must be suppressed because the plain view doctrine does not apply where the officer had no probable cause to believe that the observed item was contraband.
An officer must have probable cause to believe that items in plain view are contraband before he may search or seize them. The police may not move objects to get a better view. In Arizona v. Hicks, 480 U.S. 321 (1987), the officer was found to have acted unlawfully. While investigating a shooting, the officer moved, without probable cause, stereo equipment to record the serial numbers. The evidence was later suppressed because the officer had no probable cause to believe that the equipment, appearing in plain view, was contraband.
Question 108: Under the best evidence rule (FRE 1002), which of the following is correct?
- An original writing must be produced to prove its contents unless an exception applies (Correct answer)
- Oral testimony about the contents of a document is always inadmissible
- The rule applies only to documentary evidence in criminal cases
- A photocopy is never acceptable in place of an original
Correct answer: An original writing must be produced to prove its contents unless an exception applies
FRE 1002 requires production of the original writing to prove its contents, but FRE 1003–1004 provide exceptions for duplicates and when originals are unavailable.
Question 109: A retail store runs an advertisement in the local newspaper stating: “Only 3 cashmere sweaters remaining; highest quality; real Polo; one grey, one maroon and one beige; on closeout, starting 9 a.m. Saturday, $5.00 each, first-come, first-served.” A store customer was the first to arrive on Saturday morning. He located the three advertised sweaters, picked them up, handed $15.00 to the clerk, and demanded all three sweaters at $5 each. The clerk stated that the store’s price on each sweater was actually $50 each. The customer demanded the advertised price. Who has the superior legal position?
- The customer, because the terms of the advertisement were definite enough to constitute an offer and the offer was duly accepted. (Correct answer)
- The customer, because this was a contract of adhesion favoring one party only, and as such, the store could not enforce it.
- The store, in that a contract was made at $50 each, which was the store’s actual intended price for the sweaters.
- The retail store, because the terms of the advertisement were merely an invitation to make an offer, and the offer made was duly rejected by the store.
Correct answer: The customer, because the terms of the advertisement were definite enough to constitute an offer and the offer was duly accepted.
While advertisements are usually invitations to make an offer, this advertisement was sufficiently definite and specific to constitute a binding offer. It specified the exact items, quantity ('Only 3'), price ('$5.00 each'), and method of acceptance ('first-come, first-served'). By being the first to arrive and tendering the exact price for the specified items, the customer duly accepted the offer, forming a valid contract.
Question 110: A campaign worker for a City Council candidate distributed a flier saying that the candidate was offering transportation to the polls on election day. The flier stated that recipients should come to a nearby storefront on election day, where there would be free food and drink, and other “prizes” for those who voted. Two police undercover agents went to the party, where they agreed to be taken to vote in return for $50 each. The campaign worker drove the men to their alleged poll location, where the agents arrested him on charges of conspiracy to violate the election bribery laws. The defense filed a motion to dismiss on the basis that it was legally impossible to commit the crime because the agents were not registered to vote in that district and they never intended to allow a crime to be permitted. Is the trial court likely to grant the motion to dismiss?
- No, because the basis of the conspiracy charge is the agreement to commit the act, along with an affirmative step in that direction. (Correct answer)
- No, because when the worker drove the agents to the voting place, he committed the complete crime of bribery and the conspiracy was an element contained within it.
- Yes, because legal impossibility is a defense to the crime of conspiracy.
- Yes, because he could not be guilty of conspiring with two law enforcement agents who never intended to commit the crime.
Correct answer: No, because the basis of the conspiracy charge is the agreement to commit the act, along with an affirmative step in that direction.
Conspiracy focuses on the agreement to commit an unlawful act and an overt act in furtherance of that agreement. The fact that the undercover agents never intended to commit the crime (making it factually impossible for them to vote) does not negate the campaign worker's intent or the existence of the agreement from his perspective. Legal impossibility, which would apply if the agreed-upon act was not a crime even if completed, is not present here, as election bribery is a crime.
Question 111: A woman was injured when her motorcycle crashed after it failed to handle a sharp turn in the roadway. She had been traveling on a state highway in another state. She suffered grievous injuries. There were no warning signs about the dangerous curve, and visibility was difficult due to overgrown tree branches. She sued the state and its director of highways, claiming negligent maintenance and failure to warn of a dangerous roadway. She claimed that the defendants’ negligence caused her grievous injuries. A jury awarded her a modest sum after a trial. The plaintiff then sued the same defendants in federal court due to diversity jurisdiction and claimed the same injuries from the accident, but alleged that they had gotten much worse since then. The defendants requested dismissal of the second case. Will the federal court judge likely grant the request of the defendants and why?
- No, because the aggravation of injuries makes the second case sufficiently different from the first.
- No, because the second case is in a totally different court with different legal principles applicable to the issues.
- Yes, because the second case is not allowed due to collateral estoppel.
- Yes, because the second case is precluded by res judicata. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Yes, because the second case is precluded by res judicata.
Res judicata, or claim preclusion, prevents the relitigation of claims that have already been litigated and decided, or that could have been litigated, between the same parties or those in privity with them. Here, the plaintiff is suing the same defendants for the same injuries arising from the same accident, merely alleging that the injuries worsened. Since the first case resulted in a final judgment, the plaintiff is barred from bringing a second suit on the same claim, as all damages arising from that single cause of action should have been litigated in the original action.
Question 112: A woman was injured when her motorcycle crashed after it failed to handle a sharp turn in the roadway. She had been traveling on a state highway in another state. She suffered grievous injuries. There were no warning signs about the dangerous curve, and visibility was difficult due to overgrown tree branches. She sued the state and its director of highways, claiming negligent maintenance and failure to warn of a dangerous roadway. She claimed that the defendants’ negligence caused her grievous injuries. A jury awarded her a modest sum after a trial. The plaintiff then sued the same defendants in federal court due to diversity jurisdiction and claimed the same injuries from the accident, but alleged that they had gotten much worse since then. The defendants requested dismissal of the second case. Will the federal court judge likely grant the request of the defendants and why?
- No, because the aggravation of injuries makes the second case sufficiently different from the first.
- Yes, because the second case is precluded by res judicata. (Correct answer)
- No, because the second case is in a totally different court with different legal principles applicable to the issues.
- Yes, because the second case is not allowed due to collateral estoppel.
Correct answer: Yes, because the second case is precluded by res judicata.
Claim preclusion, or res judicata, bars the litigation of claims that either have been litigated or should have been raised in an earlier suit. Petro-Hunt, L.L.C. v. United States, 365 F.3d 385, 395 (5th Cir.2004) (quoting In re Southmark Corp., 163 F.3d 925, 934 (5th Cir.1999)). The test for res judicata has four elements: (1) the parties are identical or in privity; (2) the judgment in the prior action was rendered by a court of competent jurisdiction; (3) the prior action was concluded by a final judgment on the merits; and (4) the same claim or cause of action was involved in both actions. Id.
Question 113: A man entered into a lease for an apartment with a landlord. The lease stated that the term was month-to-month. After one month, the man went to the city health and licensing department and complained about various sanitary code violations that the landlord failed to correct. The agency made an inspection and found 40 sanitary code violations. It cited the landlord, and ordered him to clear up all of the violations. After the inspection, the landlord brought an eviction action against the man and obtained a judgment against him for eviction. Will the eviction order hold up under the stated facts?
- Yes, because the law of landlord-tenant generally favors the landlord and doesn’t require that the landlord make repairs or keep a property up to code.
- Yes, because the tenant’s act of disloyalty is a breach of the lease that may be enforced by an eviction action.
- No, because eviction is not recognized with respect to a month-to-month lease; instead, the tenant must vacate immediately on receiving written notice.
- No, because the landlord’s action is a retaliatory eviction, which cannot be used against a tenant who reports code violations and is a defense that the tenant may raise. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: No, because the landlord’s action is a retaliatory eviction, which cannot be used against a tenant who reports code violations and is a defense that the tenant may raise.
Most jurisdictions prohibit retaliatory eviction, meaning a landlord cannot evict a tenant in response to the tenant's good-faith complaints about housing code violations. This protection is designed to encourage tenants to report unsafe or unhealthy living conditions without fear of losing their home. The tenant's report to the health department, followed by the eviction action, strongly suggests a retaliatory motive, which serves as a valid defense against the eviction.
Question 114: A defendant is charged with rape under a statute requiring 'forcible compulsion.' The victim physically resisted but the defendant overpowered her. Which element of rape does this scenario clearly satisfy?
- Forcible compulsion only
- Neither, because resistance alone is insufficient
- Lack of consent only
- Both lack of consent and forcible compulsion (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Both lack of consent and forcible compulsion
Physical resistance by the victim establishes both lack of consent and, when the defendant overpowers her, forcible compulsion.
Question 115: A regional planning commission ordered a temporary cessation of all construction in a large planned residential development in order to formulate a comprehensive land-use plan, and to study the environmental impact on a large natural lake adjoining the property. After some 24 months the moratorium still existed, and real estate developers sued, alleging that the moratorium constituted a taking of their property without due compensation in violation of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments. A lower federal court held a hearing, heard evidence, and ruled that the delay under these facts was not unreasonable and no taking occurred. How would the federal court of appeals most likely decide the issue?
- A temporary moratorium denies the developers of all economic use of their land during the cessation, and compensation was payable.
- The moratorium was an attempt by the government to appropriate private land for public use during an inordinate period of time, thus requiring compensation.
- The temporary cessation was not the same as a total restriction on further development and didn’t ultimately deprive the owners of all economic uses of their property. (Correct answer)
- No compensation is ever due when all that is involved is a regulatory intrusion on the use of one’s property.
Correct answer: The temporary cessation was not the same as a total restriction on further development and didn’t ultimately deprive the owners of all economic uses of their property.
A temporary moratorium on development, especially one implemented to study environmental impact and formulate a comprehensive plan, is generally not considered a categorical (per se) regulatory taking requiring compensation. The Supreme Court in *Tahoe-Sierra Preservation Council v. Tahoe Regional Planning Agency* held that a temporary moratorium does not deprive an owner of all economically beneficial use of their land, as the property retains its value and potential for development once the moratorium is lifted. Therefore, it is analyzed under the *Penn Central* ad hoc balancing test, and such reasonable, temporary moratoria typically do not constitute a taking.
Question 116: A tenant moved into a single-family residence. She and the landlord signed a lease-purchase agreement, which applied $200 of each month’s rent to the purchase price of $50,000. The tenant agreed to get a mortgage within 33 months and to pay the full balance due, less the payments credited, on the final settlement date, which was set for 90 days after the 33rd month. A default by the tenant caused a forfeiture of all credits and voided the agreement. The tenant made 31 consecutive payments, but stopped on month 32, when part of the roof caved in causing an uninhabitable situation in the dead of winter. She put the rental payments in an escrow account. The landlord sued for eviction and termination of the lease-purchase agreement. The tenant answered that the landlord had breached the warranty of habitability. She also counterclaimed to compel specific performance of the agreement because she was ready to tender the balance due and take full title to the property. Under the circumstances, what is the most likely ruling of the court?
- The landlord must refund the $200 per month payments made toward the purchase; however, the agreement became void due to both parties nonperformance, and the closing would not be compelled.
- The tenant breached the agreement by stopping the rent payments, which she had no right to do just because there was a repair that needed to be made, and closing would not be compelled.
- The landlord breached the warranty of habitability, which had the effect of voiding the lease-agreement and making the tenant’s right unenforceable, so that closing could not be compelled.
- The landlord breached the warranty of habitability, which released the tenant at least temporarily from further rent payments, but the purchase agreement was still valid and it would be enforced. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The landlord breached the warranty of habitability, which released the tenant at least temporarily from further rent payments, but the purchase agreement was still valid and it would be enforced.
The warranty of habitability is implied in residential leases, requiring landlords to maintain premises fit for human habitation. The caved-in roof in winter clearly breaches this warranty, excusing the tenant from rent payments during that period. However, the lease-purchase agreement has two distinct components: the lease and the option to purchase. While the landlord's breach affects the lease, it does not automatically void the purchase agreement, especially since the tenant is ready to tender the balance, thus the purchase agreement would be enforced.
Question 117: A professional hockey player was traded from one team to another, with his existing contract being assigned to the new team. The contract had an option to require the four-time all-star player to sign a new three-year contract at a newly negotiated amount. The new team exercised the option. After successful negotiations, they agreed on and signed a three-year contract. However, that team later discovered that the player also signed a one-year contract with another team. Despite demands, the player has failed to assure his new team that he is going to honor the three-year contract. For that reason, the team filed an action requesting injunctive relief. What will the court most likely decide?
- There is an anticipatory repudiation of the valid three-year contract, and an injunction will issue because money damages are inadequate to replace the players highly unique and special services. (Correct answer)
- There was no valid contract because it’s illegal for two teams to trade and negotiate the freedom of choice and freedom of movement of a player.
- The one-year document was an anticipatory repudiation of the valid three-year contract, but injunctive relief was denied because the team can sue for money damages.
- Although there was an anticipatory repudiation of a valid contract, money damages will suffice because the court can never attempt to enforce a contract for personal services.
Correct answer: There is an anticipatory repudiation of the valid three-year contract, and an injunction will issue because money damages are inadequate to replace the players highly unique and special services.
The player signing with another team after agreeing to a new contract with the current team constitutes an anticipatory repudiation, an unequivocal indication that he will not perform his contractual obligations. While courts generally do not grant specific performance for personal service contracts (forcing someone to work), they *can* issue an injunction to prevent a party from performing *similar services for a competitor* if the services are unique or extraordinary and money damages would be inadequate. Professional athletes are typically considered to provide unique services, making injunctive relief appropriate to prevent them from playing for another team (option B). Money damages are often inadequate in such cases (options A and C are wrong). Player trades and contracts are standard and legal in professional sports (option D is wrong).
Question 118: An investor sued his stock broker company and alleged a civil conspiracy among several employees and an outside party to take advantage of existing customers, including the investor. He alleged that the co-conspirators conducted an insider trading deal for themselves without providing the same information to the investor and the other customers, thus denigrating the customers’ account to the conspirators' own benefit. However, after discovery and presenting his side of the evidence at the jury trial, it was apparent that the investor had been unable to prove a conspiracy or evidence of fraud. The investor testified to his suspicions, which were mainly conclusions without proof. At the close of the investor-plaintiff’s side of the case, what is the likely best strategy that the investment banking defendants can follow?
- File a motion for judgment as a matter of law under Rule 50(a). (Correct answer)
- Present no evidence on their side and ask for the the judge to submit the case to the jury.
- Request relief under Rule 60.
- File a motion to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6).
Correct answer: File a motion for judgment as a matter of law under Rule 50(a).
Federa Rule 50(a) states that if a party has been fully heard on an issue during a jury trial and the court finds that a reasonable jury would not have a legally sufficient evidentiary basis to find for the party on that issue, the court may enter a judgment as a matter of law. Under Rule 50(a)(2), a motion for judgment as a matter of law may be made at any time before the case is submitted to the jury. The motion must specify the judgment sought and the law and facts that entitle the movant to the judgment. Here, the mere suspicions of a plaintiff can not stand as sufficient evidentiary support for the proof needed to prove a conspiracy and fraud. There is no alternative but to enter a final judgment as a matter of law and dismiss the jury.
Question 119: A contract for the sale of land contains a clause: 'Time is of the essence.' Buyer tenders payment one day late. Seller refuses to convey. The likely result is:
- Seller must perform because one day is immaterial
- Seller may rescind because buyer materially breached (Correct answer)
- Seller must give written notice before refusing to perform
- Buyer is entitled to reasonable delay without consequence
Correct answer: Seller may rescind because buyer materially breached
A 'time is of the essence' clause makes timely performance a material condition, so even a one-day delay constitutes a material breach entitling the seller to rescind.
Question 120: An owner signed papers and a deed to sell a piece of property to buyer one, who held his deed and did not record it. The next month the original owner sold the same property to a second buyer. Buyer two had information that buyer one had bought the property, but he knew that buyer one had not yet recorded a deed. Buyer two recorded five days later. The next day after the deed was executed and delivered to the second buyer, the original owner conveyed a deed to the same property to a third buyer, who was a good faith purchaser for value and who recorded his deed the very same day. Which buyer has superior title under a race-notice recording statute?
- The first buyer has superior title because he innocently purchased the property for value, and was not aware of any other transactions.
- Buyer two has superior title because he was defrauded by the seller and the courts will enforce his purchase to avoid injustice.
- Buyer three has better title because he had no notice of any prior transactions and recorded first. (Correct answer)
- Buyer one has superior title because he is the only one who acted in good faith without knowledge of prior transactions.
Correct answer: Buyer three has better title because he had no notice of any prior transactions and recorded first.
Under a race-notice recording statute, a subsequent purchaser for value takes priority over a prior unrecorded interest only if they (1) take without notice of the prior interest AND (2) record their deed first. Buyer 1 did not record. Buyer 2 had notice of Buyer 1, so B2 cannot prevail against B1. Buyer 3 is a good faith purchaser for value without notice and recorded first among those without notice, thus Buyer 3 prevails.
Question 121: A 16-year-old minor went to a used car dealer with his aunt and grandmother. The minor purchased a used car in “as is” condition. The purchaser was listed as the minor; his relatives were not on the agreements. The boy discovered later that the drive shaft was bent and he returned the car with a demand for a refund of the $2,000 purchase price. The dealer refused to give a refund, citing the assistance and verbal assurances by the aunt and grandmother. They also gave him funds to make the purchase. Is the contract still voidable by the minor so that he can get a refund of the purchase price?
- He’s entitled to a refund because the dealer committed fraud by not telling him about the defective drive shaft.
- The aunt and grandmother actually own the vehicle because they were the real parties in interest, and the dealer must return the money to them based on restitution.
- The participation in this case by the adults did not change the rule that a contract entered into by a minor is voidable by that minor – he’s entitled to a refund. (Correct answer)
- There is no refund and the contract was not voidable because the presence of the aunt and grandmother constituted an implied warranty of title.
Correct answer: The participation in this case by the adults did not change the rule that a contract entered into by a minor is voidable by that minor – he’s entitled to a refund.
Contracts entered into by minors (typically individuals under 18) are generally voidable at the minor's option. The presence or assistance of adults who are not parties to the contract does not alter the minor's right to disaffirm. Since the contract was solely between the minor and the dealer, the minor retains the power to void the contract and is entitled to a refund of the purchase price.
Question 122: A manufacturer of widgets sent a letter to an international widget retailer offering to sell ten truckloads of construction-quality widgets for $1,000 per truck. The retailer emailed a note back saying “Please send 10 truckloads as promised.” No shipment was sent, but four months later when the market demand for widgets skyrocketed, the retailer sued the manufacturer for breach claiming that the retailer suffered damages by not having received the shipment of ten trucks as agreed. Does the retailer have a legal right to collect damages under these facts?
- No, the parties do not set a date for delivery, which always invalidates a contract between merchants for the delivery of goods.
- No, the retailer never called back and asked for the widgets, which means that the contract was not finally confirmed and legalized.
- Yes, the retailer is entitled to collect damages because the manufacturer violated the doctrine of avoidable consequences.
- Yes, there is a specific and detailed enough offer, followed by an unequivocal acceptance, indicating an intent to form a contract. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Yes, there is a specific and detailed enough offer, followed by an unequivocal acceptance, indicating an intent to form a contract.
Under the UCC, a contract for the sale of goods can be formed if the parties intended to make a contract and there is a reasonably certain basis for giving a remedy, even if some terms are left open. Here, the manufacturer's letter was a clear and definite offer for 'ten truckloads of construction-quality widgets for $1,000 per truck.' The retailer's email 'Please send 10 truckloads as promised' was an unequivocal acceptance of these terms, indicating mutual assent and forming a binding contract.
Question 123: A state law required voters to present a photo identification card at the time of voting. If they did not, they could cast a provisional vote and present an ID within 10 days or sign an affirmation that they were unable to afford one. Actually, ID cards were free at state agencies. Disgruntled voters sued to have the provision declared unconstitutional. What was the most likely decision of the courts?
- The law was unconstitutional because it imposed an undue burden on the old, disabled and poor.
- This law was constitutional because it was not a burden for people to live up to it, and they could always file a provisional vote if need be. (Correct answer)
- The law was constitutional because the U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that all such laws are legitimate exercises of the police power of the state.
- Voter ID laws are unconstitutional and not allowed to restrict free voting rights.
Correct answer: This law was constitutional because it was not a burden for people to live up to it, and they could always file a provisional vote if need be.
Because the cards are free, the trouble of going to the Bureau of Motor Vehicles, gathering required documents, and posing for a photograph is not a substantial burden on most voters' right to vote, and is not a significant increase over the usual burdens of voting. See Crawford v. Marion County Election Board, 553 U.S. 181 (2008
Question 124: An online company has sued a competitor for trademark infringement in federal court. The company has made some broad discovery requests, which are being refused by the competitor. The Court issues a date for a scheduling conference. After the scheduling conference, which of the following appears to be the most appropriate subjects for a scheduling order, considering the mandates of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure?
- The Order will limit the time to join other parties, the time to amend the pleadings, the time to complete discovery, and the time to file motions. It will also set the limits of discovery, and set dates for pre-trial conferences and trial. (Correct answer)
- The Order will set sanctions for any party not appearing at pre-trial conferences, determine the form and content of the pretrial order, dispose of pending motions, and set special procedures for managing potentially difficult or protracted actions that may involve complex problems.
- The Order will deal primarily with the nature of the evidence and discovery obtained to date, with the goal of setting the summary judgment dates for future resolution.
- The Order will set the schedule for the providing the disclosure items that must be provided in the Rules, which includes detailed information by each party regarding its evidence.
Correct answer: The Order will limit the time to join other parties, the time to amend the pleadings, the time to complete discovery, and the time to file motions. It will also set the limits of discovery, and set dates for pre-trial conferences and trial.
See FRCP 16(b). After consulting with the parties’ attorneys and any unrepresented parties at a scheduling conference, the Court must issue and Order within the time specified in the Rule. The Order must limit the time to join other parties, amend the pleadings, complete discovery, and file motions. There are several other permissible functions listed in Rule 16(b).
Question 125: A city park accepted a limited number of privately funded and donated monuments. One of them was a monument displaying the Ten Commandments, which the Kiwanis International donated in a campaign against juvenile delinquency 50 years ago. A non-denominational church organization recently demanded that the city provide space in the park for the church to erect a monument giving the seven precepts of the church. The city rejected the request, and the church sued the city requesting injunctive action to compel the city to provide space for its religious display. The church argued that the city was in violation of the religious establishment clause of the First Amendment by allowing the Ten Commandments. The church said that the monument was an establishment of religion and that all religions should be allowed to display equally or none should be allowed. Based on modern precedent, what will the court decide?
- The city must allow a fair selection of monuments from all religions or be guilty of establishing a religion by appearing to favor one religious heritage only.
- The First Amendment requires that every expression and form of speech be allowed by a government agency and thus the new monument must be allowed.
- The city can accept a monument that also has historical, non-sectarian interest without violating the establishment clause and without having to accept other monuments. (Correct answer)
- The placing of a monument that has any religious significance at all is always a violation of the establishment clause, and the Ten Commandments must be removed.
Correct answer: The city can accept a monument that also has historical, non-sectarian interest without violating the establishment clause and without having to accept other monuments.
Simply having religious content or promoting a message consistent with a religious doctrine does not run afoul of the Establishment Clause. Van Orden v. Perry, 545 U. S. 677, 690 (2005) There is a sufficiently secular message of the Ten Commandments. They have undeniable historical meaning in the American heritage. A non-religious organization donated it for non-religious purposes, and it went unchallenged for 50 years. A reasonable observer, mindful of the history, purpose, and context, would not conclude that this passive monument conveyed the message that the State was seeking to endorse religion, even though it also had to be recognized that the Ten Commandments had religious significance. Id. at 545 U. S. 682-683. See also Rosenberger v. Rector and Visitors of Univ. of Va., 515 U. S. 819, 845-846 (1995) (warning against the "risk [of] fostering a pervasive bias or hostility to religion, which could undermine the very neutrality the Establishment Clause requires").
Question 126: A seller contracts to deliver 100 chairs by May 1. On April 15, the seller tells the buyer, 'I won't be delivering those chairs.' The buyer's best immediate legal remedy is:
- Wait until May 1 and then sue for breach
- Accept the repudiation and negotiate a new contract
- Immediately treat the contract as breached and seek damages (Correct answer)
- Only seek specific performance since the goods are unique
Correct answer: Immediately treat the contract as breached and seek damages
An anticipatory repudiation allows the non-breaching party to immediately treat the contract as breached and sue for damages without waiting for the performance date.
Question 127: A murder victim's statement to a 911 operator saying 'My husband is trying to kill me!' is sought to be admitted after the victim dies. Under Crawford v. Washington, this statement is:
- Admissible as a dying declaration regardless of its testimonial nature
- Non-testimonial and admissible because it was made under emergency circumstances (Correct answer)
- Testimonial and barred by the Confrontation Clause if the defendant cannot cross-examine
- Inadmissible hearsay with no applicable exception
Correct answer: Non-testimonial and admissible because it was made under emergency circumstances
Under Davis v. Washington, statements made to enable police to respond to an ongoing emergency are non-testimonial and not barred by the Confrontation Clause.
Question 128: A tenant moved into a single-family residence. She and the landlord signed a lease-purchase agreement, which applied $200 of each month’s rent to the purchase price of $50,000. The tenant agreed to get a mortgage within 33 months and to pay the full balance due, less the payments credited, on the final settlement date, which was set for 90 days after the 33rd month. A default by the tenant caused a forfeiture of all credits and voided the agreement. The tenant made 31 consecutive payments, but stopped on month 32, when part of the roof caved in causing an uninhabitable situation in the dead of winter. She put the rental payments in an escrow account. The landlord sued for eviction and termination of the lease-purchase agreement. The tenant answered that the landlord had breached the warranty of habitability. She also counterclaimed to compel specific performance of the agreement because she was ready to tender the balance due and take full title to the property. Under the circumstances, what is the most likely ruling of the court?
- The tenant breached the agreement by stopping the rent payments, which she had no right to do just because there was a repair that needed to be made, and closing would not be compelled.
- The landlord must refund the $200 per month payments made toward the purchase; however, the agreement became void due to both parties nonperformance, and the closing would not be compelled.
- The landlord breached the warranty of habitability, which had the effect of voiding the lease-agreement and making the tenant’s right unenforceable, so that closing could not be compelled.
- The landlord breached the warranty of habitability, which released the tenant at least temporarily from further rent payments, but the purchase agreement was still valid and it would be enforced. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The landlord breached the warranty of habitability, which released the tenant at least temporarily from further rent payments, but the purchase agreement was still valid and it would be enforced.
Landlords have an implied warranty of habitability, requiring them to provide premises fit for human habitation. A caved-in roof in winter clearly breaches this warranty, justifying the tenant's temporary withholding of rent (especially if placed in escrow). However, a breach of the *lease* portion of a lease-purchase agreement does not automatically void the *purchase option*, particularly when the tenant is ready and willing to perform the purchase. The lease and purchase components are often severable. Thus, the landlord breached the warranty of habitability, but the purchase agreement remains valid and enforceable if the tenant is ready to close (option A). The tenant was justified in withholding rent (option C is wrong), and the agreement is not voided by the landlord's breach (option B and D are wrong).
Question 129: A state passes a law imposing a $0.05 tax on every copy of a newspaper sold, but exempting magazines and online publications. A newspaper publisher challenges this. The most likely result is:
- Unconstitutional because singling out newspapers for taxation raises First Amendment concerns (Correct answer)
- Constitutional because the tax rate is de minimis and has no chilling effect
- Unconstitutional only if the publisher can show the tax was intended to suppress criticism of the government
- Constitutional because the tax is generally applicable to all print media
Correct answer: Unconstitutional because singling out newspapers for taxation raises First Amendment concerns
Under Minneapolis Star & Tribune Co. v. Minnesota Commissioner of Revenue, differential taxes targeting the press raise serious First Amendment concerns even without proof of censorial intent.
Question 130: A state law required that whenever a newspaper prints an editorial criticizing a candidate for office, his character or personal record on the issues, it must provide space for the opposing candidate to reply to the criticisms. A failure to do so is a second-degree misdemeanor. A candidate demanded space for responding to an editorial in a local newspaper that was critical to his character and his candidacy. The newspaper refused to comply. The candidate brought an action seeking declaratory and injunctive relief, and requesting actual and punitive damages. Based on U.S. Supreme Court precedent, what did the court likely decide?
- This was a proper attempt to regulate the fairness of speech and give equal time to both sides of an issue so that a slanted opinion would not be perceived as necessarily true.
- This was an unconstitutional statute because by allowing a response, the statute was favoring the criticized candidate and setting up a silent endorsement of that candidate.
- This is a constitutional statute because the government has a duty to assure that a wide variety of views reach the public.
- It was an improper restraint on freedom of speech, which guarantees the right to have a full discussion of the merits of the candidates and their views. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: It was an improper restraint on freedom of speech, which guarantees the right to have a full discussion of the merits of the candidates and their views.
The statute threatens the free expression of opinions by the newspaper. Newspapers might take the safe route and not comment to avoid controversy and the expense of printing a reply. The First Amendment protects the free discussion of governmental affairs, including of the candidates. Such regulation of the process is inconsistent with the guarantees of a free press. See Miami Herald Pub. Co. v. Tornillo, 418 U.S. 241 (1974).
Question 131: Plaintiff filed a personal injury action against a trucking company whose truck rear-ended the A prisoner filed a pro se civil rights complaint against the prison, alleging that the authorities had treated him with deliberate indifference. He asserted that he had been beaten and tortured by other prisoners with the knowledge of prison officials, who did nothing to prevent or stop the attacks. The prisoner, however, did not identify any specific prison officials who were involved, nor did he give any details on when and where the beatings took place. The prisoner did not describe his injuries in detail in the complaint, due to the fact that he was waiting for his medical records, which were being held up by the prison. The defendants made a Rule 12 motion to dismiss, which the court granted. The court did not give leave to amend because it felt that plaintiff probably could not obtain all of the facts that he needed to make a well-pleaded complaint. The plaintiff filed an appeal, alleging that he should have been granted leave to amend the complaint. What is the court’s likely decision and why?
- The appeal will be denied because the court has the discretion to say whether it believes that the plaintiff could obtain more facts to allege.
- The appeal will be granted because the prison was obstructing justice by holding the medical records.
- The appeal will be denied because the plaintiff had the opportunity to obtain the facts before he filed an indadequate complaint.
- The appeal will be granted because the court must allow parties the liberal right to amend their pleadings where there is a possibility that this will be fruitful. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The appeal will be granted because the court must allow parties the liberal right to amend their pleadings where there is a possibility that this will be fruitful.
Under Rule 15(a), federal courts "should freely give leave [to amend] when justice so requires."[1] In the Court's view, this meant that the standard for granting leave to amend was quite liberal: only in very limited circumstances would a denial of leave to amend be justified. Specifically, the Court found that undue delay, bad faith or dilatory motive on the part of the movant, repeated failure to cure deficiencies by previous amendment, prejudice to the opposing party, and futility of amendment would support a denial. Absent such special circumstances, it would be an abuse of discretion for a court to deny leave to amend. The Court granted Foman's motion to amend her complaint and remanded the case to the First Circuit for proceedings consistent with its opinion. Foman v. Davis, 371 U.S. 178 (1962).
Question 132: A contractor substantially performs a home renovation but omits a small requested feature. Under the doctrine of substantial performance, the owner:
- May rescind the contract and recover all payments made
- Owes the full contract price without any offset
- Owes nothing because the contractor breached the contract
- Owes the contract price minus the cost to remedy the deficiency (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Owes the contract price minus the cost to remedy the deficiency
Under substantial performance, the owner must pay the contract price less the cost to complete or correct the omitted work — the contractor does not forfeit payment entirely.
Question 133: A state-funded military institute accepts only male students. The college-level school has a renowned history of producing military and government leaders. It is known for having a uniquely rigorous form of military training that builds strong character forged in the tribulations of adversity and military discipline. A woman with excellent scholastic and athletic achievements applied for admission and was turned down. She brought an injunctive action in federal court claiming a denial of equal protection guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment. The state offered to develop a parallel military school for women that would not be as physically demanding or as confrontational. Facilities and faculty would not be equal to the men’s institute because of initial budgetary restraints. In light of U.S. Supreme Court precedent, what should the federal district court rule?
- There is no equal protection problem because the unique attributes of a men-only vigorous military training program is constitutionally justified in not allowing women.
- This may be a violation of the civil rights laws against gender discrimination but it has nothing to do with a denial of equal protection.
- There is no equal protection problem when the state offers a parallel program of education to women.
- There is a denial of equal protection because the “parallel” program does not provide the same rigorous military training or the full spectrum of benefits. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: There is a denial of equal protection because the “parallel” program does not provide the same rigorous military training or the full spectrum of benefits.
The injunction must be granted – the school must accept the applicant. The idea of an alternative military school is similar to the discredited “separate but equal” argument. It is demonstrably unequal in that women do not have the same hard-core training, an equally accomplished faculty, or the prestige of graduating from the men’s institute. Parties who seek to defend gender-based government action must demonstrate an "exceedingly persuasive justification" for that action, which was not done here. There is no doubt that some women will be able to succeed and prosper in the demanding men’s institute. See United States v. Virginia, 518 US 515 (1996).
Question 134: A man works as an engineer in a small building. He uses a candle to meditate when he is stressed on the job, which then calms him down. He has been mulling an idea in his mind to take a lot of money from his employer using his computer skills, and he has worked out a general plan in his mind. Once he obtains the money, he thinks it might be good to let a candle drop and have the whole building burn down. While he is out at lunch, the janitorial staff came through his office. While cleaning the area, one person lit a candle on the man's desk. When they left, he forgot to blow it out. They slammed the door on the way out, causing the lit candle to fall. It started a fire that burned the building down. What crime, if any, is the man most likely to be convicted of?
- No crime, because he only had ideas in his mind and leaving the candle on his desk where he used it for meditation cannot be a substantial act toward committing a crime. (Correct answer)
- Attempted arson and attempted murder. Attempted arson because he took a substantial step to committing arson. Attempted murder because his recklessness put the lives of the janitors in potential peril.
- Arson, because he took a substantial act by having the candle on his desk, and the crime was finished by the foreseeable act of a janitor lighting it and causing a fire.
- Attempted arson, because he took steps to have a candle there to finish the criminal act, but someone else ended up causing an accidental fire that he did not cause.
Correct answer: No crime, because he only had ideas in his mind and leaving the candle on his desk where he used it for meditation cannot be a substantial act toward committing a crime.
For criminal attempt, a defendant must not only have the intent to commit the crime but also take a 'substantial step' toward its commission, which goes beyond mere preparation. Here, the man's thoughts and the presence of a candle he used for meditation do not constitute a substantial step towards arson. The fire was caused by an accidental act of a third party, not by any action taken by the man to further his criminal plan.
Question 135: A defendant charged with sexual assault seeks to introduce evidence of the victim's prior sexual conduct. Under FRE 412 (Rape Shield), this evidence is:
- Admissible if older than one year
- Admissible only if the defendant testifies first
- Generally inadmissible, with narrow exceptions (Correct answer)
- Generally admissible to show the victim's credibility
Correct answer: Generally inadmissible, with narrow exceptions
FRE 412 (the rape shield law) generally bars evidence of a victim's other sexual behavior or predisposition, with narrow exceptions.
Question 136: A law graduate applied for admission and licensing to a state bar committee. On the questionnaire she was required to complete a question that asked whether the applicant “had belonged to the Communist Party or any organization that advocated overthrow of the United States Government by force?.” It also asked for a list of all organizations joined in the past 10 years. The graduate refused to answer those two questions, citing First Amendment rights. She was denied her law license and sued the state committee. The case is accepted for review by the United States Supreme Court. What will be the most likely decision of the court?
- The state has an absolute right to know the applicant’s background – she can be denied admission for failing to answer.
- The committee’s requirements are unconstitutional as an interference with First Amendment rights. (Correct answer)
- The state must know, in this age of terrorism, whether she has ever been involved in terrorist organizations – her license can be withheld.
- The committee’s requirements are unconstitutional as violation of procedural due process, and the license must be issued.
Correct answer: The committee’s requirements are unconstitutional as an interference with First Amendment rights.
It was a denial of her First Amendment rights to refuse her admission because she declined to answer questions about her beliefs and associations. This practice can have a chilling effect and cause law students to join only organizations that would be “safe.” Law students are thus encouraged to shun unpopular or controversial organizations. A person cannot be penalized for the organizations that she has joined. In Re Stolar, 401 U.S. 23 (1971); Baird v. State Bar of Arizona, 401 U.S. 1 (1971).
Question 137: A man wants to sell his bungalow for $10,000. His neighbor wants to buy it so he can make his yard bigger and use the structure as a storage space, so he agrees to buy the bungalow in a written agreement. The sale is to be complete on October 14. On October 10, the neighbor realizes he cannot pay $10,000, and offers to pay $8,000 instead. The man agrees, and the exchange takes place on October 14. The man then sues for the remaining $2000. Would he likely prevail in getting the additional $2,000 that is part of the signed contract?
- No the original contract was a unilateral contract that could not be modified and had to be performed at the original price
- Yes, there was a lack of additional consideration under the pre-existing duty rule so that the modification was invalid and the original price was still valid. (Correct answer)
- No, there was full performance of the contract.
- No, the modification of the sales price was accepted and therefore both parties are bound to the $8000 price.
Correct answer: Yes, there was a lack of additional consideration under the pre-existing duty rule so that the modification was invalid and the original price was still valid.
Under the common law pre-existing duty rule, a promise to perform a duty already owed under an existing contract is not sufficient consideration for a new promise. Here, the neighbor was already contractually obligated to pay $10,000. His offer to pay $8,000, without providing any new consideration, means the man's agreement to accept less was not supported by consideration and thus the modification is invalid. The original contract price of $10,000 remains enforceable.
Question 138: A young woman incurred credit card and medical debts that were overwhelming. She filed bankruptcy and discharged the debts. After receiving her final discharge, she contacted her dentist who had been listed in the bankruptcy for a debt of $10,000. That debt was now discharged and not owed. She said to the dentist, “I know I owe you $10,000 and I’m going to pay it off in the future. Can the dentist successfully sue the young woman for the $10,000 after she fails to perform on her new promise?
- No, because there can never be a new contract based on a prior obligation that is no longer owed under the law.
- No, because moral obligation in itself never rises to the level of establishing new consideration to form an enforceable contract.
- Yes, because a promise to pay a debt discharged in bankruptcy can support a new contract based on moral obligation. (Correct answer)
- Yes, because a promise to pay based on a prior debt that is now a moral obligation is always treated as new consideration sufficient to form a binding and enforceable contract.
Correct answer: Yes, because a promise to pay a debt discharged in bankruptcy can support a new contract based on moral obligation.
A promise to pay a debt that has been discharged in bankruptcy is an exception to the general rule that past consideration is not sufficient to support a new contract. The moral obligation to pay the prior debt is considered sufficient consideration to make a new, express promise to pay that debt enforceable, even without new consideration from the creditor. This principle allows the dentist to successfully sue on the new promise.
Question 139: In a civil rights case, a former employee sued her former employer for racial discrimination in terminating her from her job. The employee proved the facts required to raise a presumption of racial discrimination against the employer. At that point, the burden of going forward shifted to the employer, who presented evidence that there was an innocent, non-discriminatory reason for firing her. Which of the following best describes the procedural posture of the case and the plaintiff’s remaining evidentiary burden?
- The plaintiff retains the burden of persuasion of proving discrimination by a clear and convincing weight of the evidence.
- The plaintiff’s case has been defeated by the defendant’s evidence in rebuttal of the presumption – the court will direct a verdict in favor of the defendant.
- The plaintiff still retains the burden of persuasion of proving discrimination by a preponderance of the evidence. (Correct answer)
- The burden of proof and persuasion has shifted to the defendant who must now persuade the jury that there has been no racial discrimination.
Correct answer: The plaintiff still retains the burden of persuasion of proving discrimination by a preponderance of the evidence.
In a discrimination case, once the plaintiff establishes a prima facie case, the burden of *production* shifts to the employer to articulate a legitimate, non-discriminatory reason for its action. If the employer does so, the presumption of discrimination is rebutted, and the burden of *persuasion* always remains with the plaintiff to prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the employer's stated reason was a pretext for discrimination. The burden of proof never shifts to the defendant in this framework.
Question 140: A man was visiting his investment counselor on the 20th floor of an office building. After the meeting, he got on the elevator going down and pressed the button for the lobby. When the elevator got to the second floor it lost its momentum to stop and instead went into a freefall to the basement. The man sustained a broken back and is permanently disabled. Assume that the injured man was unable to uncover any evidence proving what caused the collapse of the elevator. He sues the building owner on a negligence theory. In order to survive a motion for summary judgment, what legal principle can he turn to for assistance?
- Absolute liability.
- The sole perpetrator doctrine.
- Res Ipsa Loquitur. (Correct answer)
- Negligence per se.
Correct answer: Res Ipsa Loquitur.
Res ipsa loquitur ('the thing speaks for itself') is a legal principle that allows an inference of negligence when the specific cause of an accident is unknown, but the event is of a type that ordinarily does not occur in the absence of negligence. An elevator freefalling is not a normal occurrence and suggests a failure in maintenance or operation, which would be under the exclusive control of the building owner. This doctrine helps the plaintiff survive summary judgment by creating a presumption of negligence.
Question 141: A defendant, acting as an accessory before the fact, helps plan a robbery but is not present when it occurs. Under modern law, what is his liability?
- He is liable as a principal to the same extent as those who committed the robbery (Correct answer)
- He is only liable for conspiracy, not robbery
- He cannot be convicted because he was absent
- He is liable only if the robbery was completed
Correct answer: He is liable as a principal to the same extent as those who committed the robbery
Modern law abolishes the distinction between principals and accessories before the fact; all who aid, abet, or counsel are liable as principals.
Question 142: A man purchased a pickup truck from a used car dealer. He made it clear to the salesperson that he needed a vehicle powerful enough to be used in his timber hauling business. The agent represented that the truck would last for hauling timber, because the engine was totally rebuilt and like new. Based on such assurances, the man purchased the truck. The sales contract papers did not mention any warranties nor did it exclude any. After hauling timber for three months with the pickup, it stopped running one day while carrying a full load. The engine had cracked and was rendered useless. The purchaser sued the seller of the truck asking for damages, including what it cost to purchase and install a new engine. The purchaser claimed a breach of implied warranties. The court held a bench trial. Which of the following is the most likely and most applicable decision, considering applicable U.C.C. principles?
- There are no warranties if they are not specifically stated in the sales contract because oral statements are always excluded.
- An implied warranty of merchantability cannot apply to a used vehicle because its intended use cannot be guaranteed.
- In this case, there was an implied warranty of merchantability and an implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose. (Correct answer)
- The seller breached an express warranty of merchantability by not living up to the express promises made.
Correct answer: In this case, there was an implied warranty of merchantability and an implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose.
Under the UCC, two implied warranties apply here. An implied warranty of merchantability arises because the seller is a merchant, guaranteeing the truck is fit for its ordinary purpose. Additionally, an implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose arises because the salesperson knew the buyer's specific purpose (hauling timber) and that the buyer was relying on the salesperson's representation that the engine was 'like new' and suitable for that use. Both warranties were breached when the engine failed.
Question 143: The President signs an executive order directing federal agencies to stop enforcing an immigration statute passed by Congress. A state challenges this order. The order is most likely:
- Valid because the President has plenary power over immigration enforcement
- Valid because prosecutorial discretion is an inherent executive function
- Invalid because the President cannot refuse to enforce a valid act of Congress (Correct answer)
- Invalid only if the Senate disapproves by a two-thirds vote
Correct answer: Invalid because the President cannot refuse to enforce a valid act of Congress
Under the Take Care Clause, the President must faithfully execute the laws; wholesale refusal to enforce a valid statute violates this constitutional duty.
Question 144: A defendant breaks into a house at night intending to commit battery on the occupant. The occupant is not home. Under common law, is the defendant guilty of burglary?
- No, because the occupant must be present for burglary
- Yes, because all elements of burglary are satisfied (Correct answer)
- No, because battery is not a felony at common law
- Yes, only if the defendant actually commits the battery
Correct answer: Yes, because all elements of burglary are satisfied
Common law burglary requires breaking and entering a dwelling of another at nighttime with intent to commit a felony inside — the felony need not be completed.
Question 145: A lessor leased real estate with a gas station business on it to a lessee for two-year terms that were renewable every two years until the tenth year. The property was described as being “located at 1900 Superpower Highway, fronting on the highway 100 feet and extending in depth of equal width 150 feet, as described in Deed Vol. 22, Page 10, with the privilege of using additional adjoining grounds for the general use of the business and the parking of customer's cars.” The lessor granted an option to purchase the “demised premises” at the “current market value at the end of the final term.” The lessee exercised the option (for property at Deed Vol. 22, Page 10) as provided, but the lessor refused to perform. Lessee brought an action for specific performance, to which the lessor responded that the price was indefinite and subject to debate, and that it was unclear if the option included the “additional adjoining grounds,” making specific performance unavailable. Will the court grant the complaint for specific performance and order that the plaintiff’s exercise of the option be enforced?
- Yes, because specific performance applies to a right to enforce the option, and the precise terms of the option can be ironed out by the court through the taking of testimony and hearing evidence.
- No, because it is impossible to determine if the option includes the adjoining lands; furthermore, current market value is an ambiguous term subject to debate by experts.
- Yes, because the land is specifically described at the deed reference, and the “market value” at a specified time is held by courts to be a sufficiently precise description of price. (Correct answer)
- No, because it could not be determined whether “current market value” meant the value at the entering of the lease or the value at the end of the lease.
Correct answer: Yes, because the land is specifically described at the deed reference, and the “market value” at a specified time is held by courts to be a sufficiently precise description of price.
For specific performance, contract terms must be sufficiently definite. Here, the property is clearly identified by a specific deed reference. Courts generally hold that 'current market value' at a specified future time is a sufficiently precise description of price, as it can be objectively determined through appraisal or expert testimony. The 'additional adjoining grounds' are described as for the general use of the business and parking, implying they are appurtenant to the demised premises and thus included in the option.
Question 146: A state statute made it a crime to be addicted to the use of narcotic drugs. A man was arrested and charged with the crime. Two officers testified that they examined “track” marks on the defendant’s arms and wrists, and that the man admitted to using drugs. However, he testified and denied saying that to the officers; instead, he said that he was having an allergic reaction. The trial court instructed the jury that it could find the man guilty of the crime on proof that he was observed to be using drugs and appeared to be addicted to narcotics. The jury found him guilty based on the observed track marks and the man was sentenced to six months of incarceration in a state penitentiary. He appealed on the basis that this was cruel and unusual punishment prohibited by both the state and federal constitutions. Will the conviction likely be reversed?
- Yes, because the statute makes it criminal to use illegal drugs, which constitutes cruel and unusual punishment.
- Yes, because the statute punishes the status of being an addict, which is an illness, and does not require proof of specific acts of drug usage – the punishment is cruel and unusual. (Correct answer)
- No, because the state has the power to forbid the use of narcotics within its borders and that’s in effect what this statute does.
- No, because the arrest is based on the regular use of illegal narcotics and is a proper concern of the criminal law.
Correct answer: Yes, because the statute punishes the status of being an addict, which is an illness, and does not require proof of specific acts of drug usage – the punishment is cruel and unusual.
The statute created a “status” crime because it did not require the specific proof of any antisocial conduct. It instead punished the illness of narcotics addiction. It made it a crime to suffer from an illness. See Robinson v. California, 370 US 660 (1962).
Question 147: A man set fire to his grocery store in order to collect on the insurance. He started a blaze at night when the store was closed and no one would be on the premises. During the blazing fire, a fireman was killed. The authorities arrested the man on charges of arson and felony murder. He was convicted of murder at a jury trial. The man argued that he could not be convicted of murder because he never intended to murder anyone. Will the courts uphold the murder conviction?
- No, felony murder only applies where there are two or more suspects acting jointly to commit a felony.
- No, the death of a fireman was not foreseeable and could not have been anticipated – the man had no intent to kill and he cannot be convicted of murder.
- Yes, once a felony is committed the perpetrator is liable for all events that may be connected to the felony, even if they are unusual outcomes.
- Yes, because the death of a fireman in the blaze was reasonably foreseeable as a consequence of the arson and therefore intent is attributed to the defendant and he is guilty of murder. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Yes, because the death of a fireman in the blaze was reasonably foreseeable as a consequence of the arson and therefore intent is attributed to the defendant and he is guilty of murder.
It is reasonably foreseeable that a fireman could be killed in the blaze. The homicide was thus a natural and probable consequence of the arson. If a thief had been caught in the fire and died, this would not be murder because it was not reasonably foreseeable.
Question 148: A regional planning commission ordered a temporary cessation of all construction in a large planned residential development in order to formulate a comprehensive land-use plan, and to study the environmental impact on a large natural lake adjoining the property. After some 24 months the moratorium still existed, and real estate developers sued, alleging that the moratorium constituted a taking of their property without due compensation in violation of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments. A lower federal court held a hearing, heard evidence, and ruled that the delay under these facts was not unreasonable and no taking occurred. How would the federal court of appeals most likely decide the issue?
- A temporary moratorium denies the developers of all economic use of their land during the cessation, and compensation was payable.
- No compensation is ever due when all that is involved is a regulatory intrusion on the use of one’s property.
- The temporary cessation was not the same as a total restriction on further development and didn’t ultimately deprive the owners of all economic uses of their property. (Correct answer)
- The moratorium was an attempt by the government to appropriate private land for public use during an inordinate period of time, thus requiring compensation.
Correct answer: The temporary cessation was not the same as a total restriction on further development and didn’t ultimately deprive the owners of all economic uses of their property.
A temporary moratorium on development, especially for planning purposes, is generally not considered a compensable taking under the Fifth Amendment if it is reasonable in duration and does not permanently deprive the owner of all economically viable use of their land. The court's finding that the 24-month delay was not unreasonable supports the conclusion that the developers were not ultimately deprived of all economic uses, distinguishing it from a permanent taking.
Question 149: A man conveyed a large parcel of land to a friend. The deed stated that it was to “my friend as long as he uses the property to grow organic vegetables that are not genetically manipulated, and if that proper use is not maintained, the property will immediately revert to the grantor.” 11 years later, the friend was charged with using genetic engineering techniques in violation of the regulations of the state’s agricultural department. What kind of an interest, if any, did the grantor retain by the wording in the deed?
- He retains a life estate.
- He retains an estate for years.
- He retains a fee simple absolute.
- He retains a possibility of reverter. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: He retains a possibility of reverter.
The language 'as long as he uses the property' followed by a condition, and then 'immediately revert to the grantor,' creates a fee simple determinable in the grantee. The grantor retains a future interest called a possibility of reverter. This interest automatically becomes possessory upon the breach of the stated condition, meaning the property automatically returns to the grantor.
Question 150: The owner of real estate neglected to pay his real estate tax bills. The county tax bureau sent a notice by certified mail to him at the property address informing that the property would be sold at a public sale if the taxes were not paid. Nobody was home to sign for the letter and nobody claimed it. It was returned to the county marked “unclaimed.” One year later the property was advertised in the local newspaper and exposed to public sale. Prior to completing the sale, the county sent another notice to the owner that came back “unclaimed.” The buyer at the sale tried to evict the owner. The owner filed a complaint against the county and the buyer claiming a taking of his property without due process. The state courts held that the procedure complied with due process notice. The case came before the U.S. Supreme Court. What was the likely decision of the Supreme Court regarding the method of notice provided here?
- The notice was adequate because it was sent twice and was fairly calculated to get to the right person.
- Certified mail addressed to the owner of the property is always sufficient notice for due process purposes.
- Additional attempts at notice are required if at all possible when the county knows in advance that its methods were returned as unclaimed. (Correct answer)
- The county’s notice was inadequate because it must have the sheriff serve the notice personally on the owner under U.S. Supreme Court precedent.
Correct answer: Additional attempts at notice are required if at all possible when the county knows in advance that its methods were returned as unclaimed.
When a notice of a tax sale is returned as unclaimed, a State must take additional reasonable steps to attempt to provide notice to the owner prior to selling his property, if it is practicable to do so. In this case, a notice could have been posted on the front door, and the notice could have been sent also by regular mail. If the regular mail was not returned, that would indicate notice received. See Jones v. Flowers, 547 U.S. 220 (2006).
Question 151: A defendant kills his terminally ill spouse at her repeated request to end her suffering. Which crime is he most likely guilty of under common law?
- Murder (Correct answer)
- Involuntary manslaughter
- Voluntary manslaughter
- No crime, because consent negates criminal liability for homicide
Correct answer: Murder
At common law, consent is not a defense to homicide; an intentional killing is murder regardless of the victim's request.
Question 152: A husband applied for a life insurance policy for $50,000 on his life, listing his wife as the beneficiary. He paid the insurance company an initial amount of $100 at the time of submitting the application. The agent accepted the down payment, which represented two months of the premium payment. In exchange for this payment, the agent gave the husband a "conditional receipt." A few days later the husband died in an auto accident. The wife as beneficiary demanded payment despite the fact that the insurance company had not officially issued a policy and the husband had not taken a required medical examination required in the wording of the application. The company denied liability, asserting that certain conditions contained in the application and in the conditional receipt (namely the taking of the medical examination) had not been fulfilled by the applicant. The insurer claimed that the condition precedent (the medical examination) was never performed and the contract was not formed. What is the most likely decision of the court?
- The conditional receipt stood as the temporary formation of a contract of insurance until the company made a final decision on whether to issue a policy. (Correct answer)
- There is no such thing as a temporary insurance contract – nothing can exist until the condition precedent is performed.
- A contract existed because public policy forbids the requirement of a medical examination for simple term insurance policies under the face amount of $100,000.
- No contract of insurance exists until the insurer is satisfied as to an applicant's acceptability.
Correct answer: The conditional receipt stood as the temporary formation of a contract of insurance until the company made a final decision on whether to issue a policy.
A conditional receipt, issued upon payment of an initial premium, often creates a temporary contract of insurance, subject to certain conditions. This temporary coverage is intended to protect the applicant while the insurance company processes the application and determines final insurability. If the applicant dies during this period, and the conditions for temporary coverage were met (or could have been met), the insurer is typically liable, even if a formal policy was not yet issued or a medical exam not completed.
Question 153: Defendant was waiting in line for post-Thanksgiving day sales. The door opened at 6 a.m. and hundreds of people rushed the entrance for a chance at a hugely discounted holiday gift. When defendant saw that there was a signed copy of his mother's author's favorite book, he jumped towards it, only to be blocked by a little old lady with a baseball bat. She was using the bat as a blocking tool, but he was determined to get the book, so he deliberately stuck his leg out in front of her and tripped her. She fell hard and in the process ended up with a blood clot in her leg, which traveled to her heart over a period of weeks, and ultimately caused her death. What crime can the defendant likely be convicted of?
- Second degree murder
- voluntary manslaughter
- Involuntary manslaughter (Correct answer)
- First degree murder
Correct answer: Involuntary manslaughter
Involuntary manslaughter occurs when a person causes the death of another through criminal negligence or during the commission of an unlawful act not amounting to a felony (misdemeanor manslaughter). Tripping the old lady was an unlawful act (battery) or at least grossly negligent. While the defendant intended to trip her, he likely did not intend to cause her death or grievous bodily harm, making the resulting death a foreseeable but unintended consequence of his reckless or unlawful act.
Question 154: A roofer offers to completely refurbish a homeowner’s roof for $1,000. The next day the roofer realizes he’s not going to make much, and he sends a revocation of the offer in the mail to customer. On the third day the homeowner puts a letter in the mailbox accepting the offer. On the fourth day the homeowner receives the roofer’s revocation letter. Was a contract formed between the homeowner and the roofer or was the revocation effective?
- No, there was no contract because there was no mutual meeting of the minds at any time.
- The acceptance was effective on posting but the revocation does not become effective until received; thus, a contract was formed when the acceptance was placed in the mailbox. (Correct answer)
- Yes, there was a contract because the revocation letter was invalid due to being based on reasons that violate public policy.
- The revocation letter was posted prior to the acceptance so that no contract was formed.
Correct answer: The acceptance was effective on posting but the revocation does not become effective until received; thus, a contract was formed when the acceptance was placed in the mailbox.
Under the mailbox rule, an acceptance is generally effective when dispatched (e.g., placed in the mailbox), provided the offer was made by mail or a similar non-instantaneous means. Conversely, a revocation of an offer is only effective when it is *received* by the offeree. In this case, the homeowner's acceptance was effective upon mailing on day three, forming a contract, before the roofer's revocation letter was received on day four.
Question 155: A defendant takes a car from a parking lot believing it to be his own car, which looks identical. He is charged with larceny. Which defense applies?
- Mistake of law
- Claim of right is never a defense to larceny
- Necessity
- Mistake of fact negating intent to steal (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Mistake of fact negating intent to steal
A genuine mistake of fact negates the specific intent to steal required for larceny, as the defendant honestly believed the property was his own.
Question 156: A criminal defendant was charged with bank robbery. Prior to trial, he filed a motion in limine, asking the court to exclude from the trial evidence of his prior convictions for assault, forgery and involuntary manslaughter. The defendant wanted to testify on his own behalf but needed an advance ruling to determine whether his prior convictions would be allowed into evidence for purposes of impeaching his credibility. Under Rule 609(a)(2) of the Federal Rules of Evidence, certain kinds of prior convictions are always admissible for impeachment purposes. Under Rule 609(a)(2), the following would be definitely admissible for impeachment purposes if the defendant takes the stand, without further analysis:
- Both the forgery and the assault convictions are admissible for impeachment purposes under Rule 609(a)(2).
- Only the forgery conviction would be per se admissible for impeachment purposes under Rule 609(a)(2). (Correct answer)
- The prior convictions of assault, forgery and involuntary manslaughter would all be admissible for impeachment purposes under 609(a)(2).
- None of the prior convictions are admissible for impeachment purposes under Rule 609(a)(2).
Correct answer: Only the forgery conviction would be per se admissible for impeachment purposes under Rule 609(a)(2).
Federal Rule of Evidence 609(a)(2) states that evidence of a criminal conviction must be admitted for impeachment purposes if the crime required proving a dishonest act or false statement. Forgery inherently involves dishonesty or false statement. Assault and involuntary manslaughter, while serious crimes, do not necessarily involve an element of dishonesty or false statement as defined by this rule, making only the forgery conviction per se admissible under 609(a)(2).
Question 157: A state law requires all public school teachers to lead students in a daily moment of silent meditation 'for prayer or reflection.' A parent challenges this law. How should a court rule?
- Constitutional because teachers retain discretion in how they describe the moment
- Constitutional as it only mandates silence, not prayer
- Unconstitutional because it endorses religion under the Establishment Clause (Correct answer)
- Unconstitutional only if teachers suggest students pray
Correct answer: Unconstitutional because it endorses religion under the Establishment Clause
In Wallace v. Jaffree, the Supreme Court struck down a similar Alabama law because its legislative history revealed a religious purpose, violating the Establishment Clause.
Question 158: The main witness against the defendant in a federal drug prosecution was an individual who was addicted to cocaine, had been hospitalized several times for psychotic experiences, and suffered from several mental illnesses. He arrived in court apparently lucid and ready to testify. The defendant objected to the testimony on the basis that the witness was incompetent to testify due to past mental illnesses. The judge questioned the witness, who stated that he understood the nature of the oath as a witness, that his memory of the events was clear, and he was not under the influence of any chemicals or alcohol. The defense was allowed to cross-examine the witness on his competency. The judge allowed the testimony, which was sufficient to convict the defendant. On appeal, the defendant raised the long mental history of the witness and argued that the judge should have held a detailed fact-finding hearing to determine the competency of the witness. What is the likely decision of the federal appellate court?
- The case is remanded because the court should have appointed independent medical experts to examine the witness and report to the court in a formal hearing to determine competency.
- The appeal is denied because in federal court all witnesses are competent to testify under any circumstances.
- The case should be remanded with instructions for the judge to caution the new jury regarding the several hospitalizations and tendency to psychotic episodes of the witness.
- The appeal is denied because the judge made appropriate inquiries and she did not abuse her discretion in deciding that the man was capable of testifying. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The appeal is denied because the judge made appropriate inquiries and she did not abuse her discretion in deciding that the man was capable of testifying.
Federal Rule of Evidence 601 states that every person is competent to be a witness unless these rules provide otherwise. While mental illness can affect credibility, it does not automatically render a witness incompetent. The judge properly assessed the witness's competency by questioning him about his understanding of the oath and his memory, and allowing cross-examination, which is within the court's discretion.
Question 159: An undergraduate went to a fraternity party. He caught a young woman making sexually provocative eye contact with him. He took her home, raped her without her consent, and then left. After being raped, she ran away and went straight to the police. The rape case was reported by the police. Many guys agreed to testify that the woman was promiscuous, that they had intercourse with her, and that she was quite prolific in her sexual life, according to the student-defendant, who found them willing witnesses. According to the Federal Rules of Evidence, will the trial court likely allow the witnesses to testify about the woman's sexual propensities?
- Yes, because the rules permit evidence of a victim’s sexual predisposition to test credibility.
- Yes, because the evidence will help the jury see that there may be two sides to the story and that the woman was thus the sexual predator instead of the man.
- No, because the rules of evidence prohibit all evidence of a victim’s prior sexual history.
- No, because such "sexual predisposition" evidence is generally prohibited by the rules of evidence except under narrow exceptions. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: No, because such "sexual predisposition" evidence is generally prohibited by the rules of evidence except under narrow exceptions.
Explanation: <br> Fed.R.Evid. 412 forbids showing signs of sexual proclivity or previous sexual behavior. The exception is when information about past behaviors will <br> directly affect the defendant's innocence. Additionally, it can be necessary to demonstrate the victim's permission in specific factual circumstances. <br> However, testimony about the rape victim's general reputation or testimony about specific acts with other people are typically not probative of the <br> victim's overall credibility as a witness or of her consent to having sex with the defendant. Instead, such evidence of a rape victim's chastity relates to <br> her sex life in general. American v. Kasto, 584 F. 8th Cir. 1978), 2d 268, 271–72. Additionally, see Grant v. Demskie, 75 F. Supp. ""The [rape shield] bill] <br> limits the introduction of such evidence and attempts to strike a reasonable balance between protection of a victim's privacy and reputation while not <br> infringing on the defendant's right to a fair trial based on the presumption of innocence... "" Answer 1 is inappropriate because it falls under the <br> category of questions covered by Rule 412, which forbids inquiries concerning the victim's sexual propensity.
Question 160: Several landowners had residential premises in a development called “The Lakes.” One owner’s property contained a small improved beach area that could be used for swimming. That owner gave oral permission to several neighbors to use the beachfront for swimming, as a friendly neighborly gesture. That owner sold her property to a new owner. The new owner erected fences and signs saying, “keep out.” The neighbors sued, claiming that they had an easement by implication through prior usage to use the beachfront. Will the court restore the use of the beachfront to the neighbors?
- Yes, because the granting of a license to use one’s property to perform a certain activity usually ripens into an easement if the use is regular and continual.
- No, because the use granted was merely a license to go on a neighbor’s land to go swimming, and the users of the free license did not expect that they were obtaining an interest in the land. (Correct answer)
- Yes, because the easement was created by the implied assent of the owner and her neighbors, and it became a public easement through prescription.
- No, because land that abuts a lake or other body of water is not subject to the creation of an easement.
Correct answer: No, because the use granted was merely a license to go on a neighbor’s land to go swimming, and the users of the free license did not expect that they were obtaining an interest in the land.
A license is the permission to do an act or series of acts on another’s land without possession of any estate in the land. An oral license without any consideration being paid for the use of the license is revocable at the will of the person granting the license. A license is thus mere permission to perform a certain act. A license in writing for which consideration is paid can be irrevocable, depending on the circumstances. The above example has no indication of being compensated or having any other characteristics of becoming irrevocable.
Question 161: A contractor agreed with a city government to build it a bridge. The contractor was guilty of undue delay in getting the construction finished. The contract specified liquidated damages of a deduction from the contract price for each day of delay based on how much traffic flow was turned away. The city tried to deduct the damages from the contract price. The contractor, however, pointed out that the city had not yet connected a road to the bridge so that there was no traffic flow and hence no damage to the city. Will the court uphold the liquidated damages clause in favor of the city?
- Yes, because the contract provision for liquidated damages has been breached and the city had no obligation to connect a road.
- Yes, because the bridge delays caused the city to delay finishing the bridge, thereby creating the need to enforce the provision for liquidated damages.
- No, because the purpose of the liquidated damages clause has been frustrated by the city’s own failure to perform, making liquidated damages in this case unnecessary. (Correct answer)
- No, because the city breached the contract by not connecting a road to the bridge.
Correct answer: No, because the purpose of the liquidated damages clause has been frustrated by the city’s own failure to perform, making liquidated damages in this case unnecessary.
Liquidated damages clauses are enforceable if they are a reasonable forecast of actual damages and not a penalty. However, if there are no actual damages whatsoever, or if the party seeking to enforce the clause contributed to the lack of damages, the clause may be unenforceable. Here, the city suffered no actual traffic-related damages from the delay because its own failure to connect a road rendered the bridge unusable, frustrating the purpose of the liquidated damages clause.
Question 162: A statement made by an employee to her employer's attorney during an internal investigation is sought in litigation. Under Upjohn Co. v. United States, the attorney-client privilege:
- Does not apply to corporate employees, only to individual clients
- Applies only if the employee was named as a defendant
- Extends to employee communications made to assist counsel in providing legal advice (Correct answer)
- Applies only to communications with top-level corporate officers
Correct answer: Extends to employee communications made to assist counsel in providing legal advice
Upjohn extended the corporate attorney-client privilege to communications with lower-level employees when made to assist counsel in advising the company.
Question 163: Several casinos located in a state where gambling was legal placed advertisements about hotel prices and casino activities in newspapers in neighboring states that did not allow casino gambling. One of those states had a statute that prohibited advertising of casino gambling in any form or manner. A casino sued the state claiming an abridgement of First Amendment rights to free speech. The state responded that the rights of commercial speech were highly restricted and could not be used to advertise something that is illegal in the state. What would be the likely decision of the federal court regarding the statute’s constitutionality?
- It is constitutional because there is no right to free commercial speech.
- It is unconstitutional to regulate any commercial speech as such would deny the business its substantive due process rights.
- It is unconstitutional to bar the advertising of information about an activity that is legal in the originating state. (Correct answer)
- It is constitutional to prohibit advertising of a business’ products in a state where such products are illegal.
Correct answer: It is unconstitutional to bar the advertising of information about an activity that is legal in the originating state.
Commercial advertising enjoys a degree of First Amendment protection. The ads conveyed information of potential interest and value to a diverse audience -- not only to readers interested in the services offered, but also to those with a general curiosity about, or genuine interest in, the subject matter or the law of another State, and to readers seeking change of the law in the state where the ad was published. Bigelow v. Virginia - 421 U.S. 809 (1975).
Question 164: In 1970 a farmer purchased 50 acres of farm land. Several years later he built a house and lived on the property while also farming it. The property was landlocked, but there was a gravel road over the adjoining land directly to the nearest highway. Both the farmer’s land and the adjoining lot came from a larger parcel that was divided by the original owner. The farmer used the gravel road for farming and personal use. In 1991, a new owner purchased the adjoining land. She bulldozed the gravel road shut. The farmer filed an action in equity, asserting his absolute necessity to continue using the road to get to the highway. The new owner disagreed, and claimed that if an easement was granted by the court, it must be restricted to use only for crops at certain times, and that personal use should be disallowed or severely restricted because it was an unauthorized expansion of the original use. Which of the following would be the more likely decision of the equity court based on generally prevailing principles? The court will decree an express easement for the crops but the farmer’s personal use will be limited to twice daily. The court will decree that there is an easement in gross that can be used as long as the farmer pays a monthly charge to be determined by the new owner. The court will decree an implied license to use the adjoining property, which the new owner may terminate at any time. The court will decree an easement of necessity which includes the expanding reasonable use of the easement for any lawful use.
- The court will decree that there is an easement in gross that can be used as long as the farmer pays a monthly charge to be determined by the new owner.
- The court will decree an easement of necessity which includes the expanding reasonable use of the easement for any lawful use. (Correct answer)
- The court will decree an express easement for the crops but the farmer’s personal use will be limited to twice daily.
- The court will decree an implied license to use the adjoining property, which the new owner may terminate at any time.
Correct answer: The court will decree an easement of necessity which includes the expanding reasonable use of the easement for any lawful use.
An easement by necessity arises when a parcel of land is landlocked and requires access over an adjoining parcel that was once part of the same larger tract. The scope of an easement by necessity is generally not limited to the original use but expands to accommodate any reasonable and lawful use of the dominant estate, provided it does not unreasonably burden the servient estate. Therefore, the farmer's personal use, in addition to farming, would likely be permitted as a reasonable expansion of the necessary access.
Question 165: A retail store runs an advertisement in the local newspaper stating: “Only 3 cashmere sweaters remaining; highest quality; real Polo; one grey, one maroon and one beige; on closeout, starting 9 a.m. Saturday, $5.00 each, first-come, first-served.” A store customer was the first to arrive on Saturday morning. He located the three advertised sweaters, picked them up, handed $15.00 to the clerk, and demanded all three sweaters at $5 each. The clerk stated that the store’s price on each sweater was actually $50 each. The customer demanded the advertised price. Who has the superior legal position?
- The store, in that a contract was made at $50 each, which was the store’s actual intended price for the sweaters.
- The customer, because the terms of the advertisement were definite enough to constitute an offer and the offer was duly accepted. (Correct answer)
- The customer, because this was a contract of adhesion favoring one party only, and as such, the store could not enforce it.
- The retail store, because the terms of the advertisement were merely an invitation to make an offer, and the offer made was duly rejected by the store.
Correct answer: The customer, because the terms of the advertisement were definite enough to constitute an offer and the offer was duly accepted.
While advertisements are typically invitations to negotiate, this advertisement was sufficiently definite and explicit to constitute a binding offer. It specified a limited quantity ('Only 3 cashmere sweaters'), a specific price ($5.00 each), and a clear method of acceptance ('first-come, first-served'). The customer's immediate action of being first, picking up the sweaters, and tendering payment constituted a valid acceptance of this unilateral offer.
Question 166: A grower based in one state grew and marketed corn nationwide. The U.S. Congress passed a law attempting to stabilize the price of corn by limiting the volume of corn produced by growers to a specified volume per each cubic acre, on a semi-annual basis. The Department of Agriculture fined the grower for exceeding the production volume. He only intended to use the excess for feeding his livestock and domestic purposes, but he was ordered to destroy it. The grower brought an action claiming that his substantive due process rights had been illegally interfered with. He asked for an injunction and reparations. What would be the most likely decision of the court?
- No relief was granted because the Supreme Court has made it clear in numerous cases that the power of Congress to regulate interstate commerce is unlimited and unrestricted.
- Relief would be granted because the Commerce Clause does not authorize the regulation of indirect influences on interstate commerce, making this action illegal.
- The fact that he used the excess corn and did not ship it resulted in no effect on interstate commerce, and the government’s actions would be enjoined as being beyond the power authorized by the Commerce Clause.
- No relief was granted because Congress has the power to regulate interstate commerce, and even though he used the excess corn internally, it reduced the feed that he had to buy, thus having an effect on interstate commerce. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: No relief was granted because Congress has the power to regulate interstate commerce, and even though he used the excess corn internally, it reduced the feed that he had to buy, thus having an effect on interstate commerce.
This scenario is analogous to *Wickard v. Filburn*, where the Supreme Court held that Congress's Commerce Clause power extends to regulating purely intrastate activities if, in the aggregate, they substantially affect interstate commerce. Even though the grower used the excess corn for personal livestock, this reduced his demand for purchased feed, thereby impacting the overall interstate market for corn and feed, thus falling within Congress's regulatory authority.
Question 167: A defendant is prosecuted for murder under the year-and-a-day rule after the victim dies 14 months after being stabbed. Under the common law, can the defendant be convicted of murder?
- Yes, because the stabbing was the proximate cause of death
- No, because death occurred more than one year and one day after the act (Correct answer)
- Yes, because the defendant caused the victim's death
- No, because the statute of limitations expired
Correct answer: No, because death occurred more than one year and one day after the act
At common law, a defendant could not be convicted of homicide if the victim died more than one year and one day after the defendant's act.
Question 168: A plaintiff in a federal action seeks to conduct more than 10 depositions. Under FRCP 30(a)(2)(A)(i), the plaintiff may exceed the 10-deposition limit only by:
- Serving written notice on all parties at least 30 days in advance
- Obtaining stipulation of the parties or leave of court (Correct answer)
- Filing a motion demonstrating good cause
- Demonstrating that each additional deponent has unique knowledge
Correct answer: Obtaining stipulation of the parties or leave of court
Under FRCP 30(a)(2)(A)(i), a party must obtain leave of court or a stipulation of the parties to take more than 10 depositions in a case.
Question 169: A regular customer left his car at an auto mechanic’s shop with instructions to: check the engine and tune it up; make sure the brakes were all in good working order; examine the tires; and, to otherwise check and repair all major systems because the customer was going on a long driving tour through other states. No discussion of price or words of agreement were spoken between the parties. When the customer picked up the car, there was a bill for $5,000 left on the seat to his attention. All of the services and parts listed pertained to the areas stated in the customer’s instructions. He refused to pay, claiming that there was no agreement and that the mechanic didn’t get advance approval for all of the repairs. Can he be held responsible for contractual service performed?
- Despite the instructions, it was implied-in-fact that the mechanic would have to get permission to make any actual repairs or perform any significant work.
- There was an implied-in-law contract between the parties that required payment by the customer.
- There was an implied-in-fact contract that required the customer’s payment for the services and parts. (Correct answer)
- There was no agreement between the parties due to indefiniteness and absence of detailed terms.
Correct answer: There was an implied-in-fact contract that required the customer’s payment for the services and parts.
An implied-in-fact contract arises from the conduct of the parties, rather than express words. When the customer provided specific instructions to 'check and repair all major systems' for a long trip, and the mechanic performed those services, it created a mutual understanding that the mechanic would be paid for the work. The customer's actions implied a promise to pay for the reasonable value of the services and parts rendered, forming a binding contract.
Question 170: Two parties entered into an agreement of sale for a residential property. The title insurance company called the seller’s attorney to advise that one of the owners in the seller’s prior chain of title over 40 years ago had neglected to get a first mortgage with a private lender satisfied. It was likely that the mortgage was paid but that someone neglected to file a satisfaction notice with the recorder. If the problem had been corrected back then there was no evidence of it on the record. As such, the open mortgage now constituted a cloud on title. The title company required that the seller take action to clear title before final closing could be approved. Which of the following is the most likely way for the seller to clear title so that conveyance can be made.
- A quiet title action against the holder of the open mortgage, along with that party’s heirs and assigns. (Correct answer)
- An action of adverse possession against the bank holding the open mortgage of record. (Correct answer)
- A warranty action against the current seller demanding that the seller take action to clear his title and to convey good title at the final closing.
- A lis pendens action to remove the mortgage from the record and declare title restored in the current owner and seller.
Correct answer: A quiet title action against the holder of the open mortgage, along with that party’s heirs and assigns.
A quiet title action is the appropriate legal proceeding to resolve competing claims to real property and remove a cloud on title, such as an old, unreleased mortgage. By naming the original mortgage holder and their potential heirs or assigns, the court can issue a judgment declaring the mortgage satisfied and clearing the title. This action makes the property marketable for sale.
Question 171: A small business owner was sued for breach of contract. In his answer, he claimed that he acted upon advice of his prior counsel to return the truckload of widgets that were delivered by the plaintiff company. He later repeated that contention in a deposition but refused to elaborate on the details because of the attorney-client privilege. At trial, the plaintiff company called the business owner’s prior attorney to question him on what advice he gave his client regarding the shipment and refusing to perform on the contract. The business owner objected on the basis that the conversations with his former lawyer were privileged. What is the most likely decision of the trial court regarding the objection to the evidence?
- The privilege still stands and the testimony will be precluded because the raising of the defense in the answer is in itself privileged and not subject to further revelation.
- The testimony will be precluded because the privilege with respect to confidential communications to former counsel remained in effect and could not be waived in a pleading.
- The privilege has been waived in the sense that when a party changes counsel, all privileged communications with prior counsel are no longer protected.
- The testimony must be admitted because the business owner’s answer raised the advice of former counsel and thus placed the subject matter of that advice in issue; that is a waiver of the privilege (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The testimony must be admitted because the business owner’s answer raised the advice of former counsel and thus placed the subject matter of that advice in issue; that is a waiver of the privilege
The attorney-client privilege can be waived when a party puts the privileged communication 'at issue' in litigation. By asserting in his answer and deposition that he acted upon the advice of his prior counsel, the business owner made that advice central to his defense. He cannot use the advice as a justification for his actions while simultaneously invoking the privilege to prevent the opposing party from examining the details of that advice. This constitutes an implied waiver of the privilege.
Question 172: A criminal defendant was convicted of robbery and sentenced to ten years in prison, starting on Jan. 1, 2000. Sec. 204 of the state penal code provided for early release for good behavior, and under that provision he would have been granted supervised release as of Jan. 1, 2007. On Feb. 1, 2006, the state legislature repealed Sec. 204 and passed Sec. 205a. It reduced the good time credits for anyone convicted from that date onward, and also for anyone in prison as of the date of the section’s passage. The new release date was calculated to be Jan. 1, 2009. The criminal defendant brought a habeas corpus action arguing that Sec. 205a was an unenforceable ex post facto law as to him. The state courts turned him down saying that good time credit was a privilege and not a vested right. The case ultimately came before the U.S. Supreme Court. Did the Supreme Court invalidate Sec. 205a as an unconstitutional ex post facto law?
- No, the criminal defendant did not have a vested right in the early release date.
- Yes, because the legislature does not have the authority to pass a law that decreases good time credits for prisoners.
- No, because good time credits were an act of grace that could be taken away at any time.
- Yes, because it retrospectively increased the punishment over what was in effect when the offense was committed. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Yes, because it retrospectively increased the punishment over what was in effect when the offense was committed.
The constitutional prohibition against ex post facto laws forbids punishment more severe than what was applicable when the criminal act occurred. Here it was retrospective and it made the criminal defendant’s punishment more onerous. The issue of being “vested” in good time right is irrelevant in an ex post facto analysis. See Weaver v. Graham, 450 US 24 (1981).
Question 173: A city ordinance prohibits all door-to-door solicitation without a prior permit. A religious group challenges it as applied to their proselytizing. The court should find the ordinance:
- Constitutional because the city has a compelling interest in residential privacy
- Constitutional only if the permit process is content-neutral
- Unconstitutional as a prior restraint on speech and religious exercise (Correct answer)
- Unconstitutional only if it was enacted with anti-religious intent
Correct answer: Unconstitutional as a prior restraint on speech and religious exercise
Under Cantwell v. Connecticut and Martin v. City of Struthers, blanket permit requirements for door-to-door religious solicitation are unconstitutional prior restraints on free exercise and speech.
Question 174: An owner of a solar heated residence filed a lawsuit that tried to enjoin her neighbor from building a house that would totally interfere with her access to daily sunlight. The neighbor's plan conformed to all local building ordinances and land use regulations. The owner had been in the house for 10 years and the neighbor recently bought the adjoining lot. The owner showed that a different placement of the house would not interfere with her use and enjoyment of her residence. The trial judge ruled in favor of the defendant on the basis that the defendant had a right to build his house anywhere as long as he followed the building/zoning laws. The owner appealed. Will the appellate court likely reverse the trial court's decision?
- Yes, because blocking a neighbor's sunlight is a constitutional deprivation of substantive due process.
- No, because a comparative evaluation of the benefits and detriments of each position favor the neighbor's position.
- Yes, because the proposed use is a private nuisance that unreasonably interferes with the owner's use and enjoyment of her property. (Correct answer)
- No, because the trial court was correct in ruling that there had to be some violation of building regulations before the construction could be enjoined.
Correct answer: Yes, because the proposed use is a private nuisance that unreasonably interferes with the owner's use and enjoyment of her property.
While there is no absolute right to sunlight, a proposed construction that substantially and unreasonably interferes with a neighbor's long-standing use and enjoyment of their property can constitute a private nuisance. The court would balance the utility of the neighbor's conduct against the gravity of the harm to the owner, especially when an alternative placement exists that would avoid the interference. Conforming to zoning laws is not always a complete defense to a nuisance claim.
Question 175: A plaintiff sues in federal court and voluntarily dismisses the action under FRCP 41(a)(1). The plaintiff had previously dismissed the same claim in state court. What is the effect of this federal dismissal?
- The plaintiff may re-file the claim in any federal court
- The dismissal is without prejudice because it is the plaintiff's first federal dismissal
- The dismissal requires court approval because a prior dismissal exists
- The dismissal operates as an adjudication on the merits under the 'two dismissal rule' (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The dismissal operates as an adjudication on the merits under the 'two dismissal rule'
Under FRCP 41(a)(1)(B)'s two-dismissal rule, if a plaintiff previously dismissed the same claim in any court (state or federal), a subsequent voluntary dismissal operates as an adjudication on the merits.
Question 176: The police were called to a domestic dispute. The wife told police that her husband was abusive and that he was a heavy cocaine user. The husband was present and denied the allegation. Police asked for permission to search the premises for drugs, which was consented to by the wife. The husband, however, refused to consent to the search. The police went ahead anyway and found drugs in the husband’s belongings. After being arrested on drug charges, the husband filed a motion for suppression of the evidence based on lack of consent. What should be the likely decision of the trial court?
- The search was invalid and the evidence must be suppressed because the co-occupant of the premises was present and specifically refused to give consent to the search. (Correct answer)
- The search was invalid because, even though consent was given, the police must first attempt to get a search warrant to enter a home.
- The search was valid because the cases say that one occupant’s consent to the search overrules the other occupant’s refusal to consent.
- The search was valid because the wife’s statement established probable cause that a crime was being committed – this created exigent circumstances for the search.
Correct answer: The search was invalid and the evidence must be suppressed because the co-occupant of the premises was present and specifically refused to give consent to the search.
The Supreme Court has ruled that when both occupants are present and one of them consents but the other refuses consent, the refusal to permit entry prevails, rendering the warrantless search unreasonable and invalid as to him. See Georgia v. Randolph, 547 U.S. 103 (2006).
Question 177: In a personal injury case, plaintiff's counsel asks the defendant on cross-examination, 'Isn't it true you offered to pay the plaintiff's medical bills?' Defendant objects. The court should:
- Overrule the objection because admissions are always admissible
- Overrule the objection as the defendant opened the door
- Sustain the objection under the attorney-client privilege
- Sustain the objection under FRE 409 barring offers to pay medical expenses (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Sustain the objection under FRE 409 barring offers to pay medical expenses
FRE 409 excludes evidence of offers to pay medical or similar expenses as proof of liability for the underlying injury.
Question 178: A severely injured passenger sued the driver of the car (defendant 1) that crashed into the car she was riding in at the time of the accident. She also sued the driver of the car she rode in (defendant 2), claiming that both drivers were negligent in the accident. Defendant 2 wants his attorney to sue defendant 1 for contribution because he is insistent that the other vehicle was totally responsible and liable for all damages. Which of the following would be more appropriate for defendant 2 to file under the circumstances?
- He can file a new complaint and action against defendant 1.
- He can file a counterclaim against defendant 1.
- He can file a crossclaim against the coparty defendant 1. (Correct answer)
- He can file a compulsory counterclaim against defendant 1.
Correct answer: He can file a crossclaim against the coparty defendant 1.
Rule 13(g) is a Crossclaim Against a Coparty. It allows that a pleading may state as a crossclaim any claim by one party against a coparty if the claim arises out of the transaction or occurrence that is the subject matter of the original action or of a counterclaim, or if the claim relates to any property that is the subject matter of the original action. The crossclaim may include a claim that the coparty is or may be liable to the crossclaimant for all or part of a claim asserted in the action against the crossclaimant.
Question 179: A civil case for damages depended on whether the defendant was actually the man driving the identified vehicle at the time of the accident. It was established that others had access to the vehicle so that it was important to identify the person driving at that time. The plaintiff’s attorney asked a witness on direct examination if he saw the driver in the courtroom, and while saying that he pointed, almost instinctively, to the defendant’s table and to the defendant. The witness agreed with the pointing, and said, “Yes, that’s him!” The defendant vehemently objected and called for a mistrial, claiming that this was unfair leading of the witness into answering the ultimate issue of identity. The trial court denied the objections. The defendant appealed. Will the appellate court likely order a new trial?
- Yes, the examination was in violation of the rule that requires establishing a prior foundation before asking a question like that.
- No, the examination was appropriate because the witness was still capable of saying whether he recognized the person or not.
- Yes, the plaintiff’s attorney manipulated the witness’ testimony on the ultimate issue of who was driving the car by impermissibly leading the witness to identify the opposing party. (Correct answer)
- No, cross examination is a far-reaching kind of questioning that cannot be limited in very many instances.
Correct answer: Yes, the plaintiff’s attorney manipulated the witness’ testimony on the ultimate issue of who was driving the car by impermissibly leading the witness to identify the opposing party.
On direct examination, leading questions (questions that suggest the desired answer) are generally prohibited, especially when they concern a material or ultimate issue in the case, such as the identity of the perpetrator. The attorney's act of pointing to the defendant and asking 'Yes, that’s him!' directly suggested the answer and improperly influenced the witness's identification. This constitutes impermissible leading and could warrant a new trial due to the prejudice on a critical issue.
Question 180: A retail salesperson was driving her car at lunch when a man driving an SUV drove through a red light and struck her. The salesperson resided in State A and the accident occurred in State A. The driver of the SUV was employed by a company that was located in State B. The company allowed the employee to take its SUV, which was used most of the time for business purposes, to go home to State A every night and return to work in State B in the morning. The injured retail salesperson sued both the company and the driver in a State A court. The company filed a motion to dismiss claiming that the State A court did not have personal jurisdiction over the company, despite having over its employee. The trial court dismissed the case against the company for lack of personal jurisdiction. Will that decision likely survive on appeal and why or why not?
- No, the mere act of the company's car being in State A was enough to establish personal jurisdiction over the company.
- No, the company benefited from having its employee commute from State A to State B and it is responsible for the acts of its agent. (Correct answer)
- Yes, because the company was not doing busines in State A and therefore it had no contact with the state.
- Yes, because the company did not benefit from giving the employee a car to commute with, thus it had no minimum contacts with the forum state.
Correct answer: No, the company benefited from having its employee commute from State A to State B and it is responsible for the acts of its agent.
Personal jurisdiction over an out-of-state company requires minimum contacts with the forum state. Here, the company benefited from its employee commuting daily from State A to State B in a company vehicle, which constitutes a continuous and systematic presence of its property and operations within State A. The accident occurring in State A, involving the company's vehicle and employee, establishes specific jurisdiction because the company purposefully availed itself of the benefits and protections of State A's laws through this arrangement, making it fair to sue them there.
Question 181: A defendant is charged with assault. The prosecution seeks to admit evidence that the defendant has a prior conviction for battery. Under FRE 404(b), this evidence is:
- Admissible to show intent, knowledge, or common scheme (Correct answer)
- Admissible only if the defendant testifies
- Inadmissible as improper character evidence
- Admissible as substantive evidence of guilt
Correct answer: Admissible to show intent, knowledge, or common scheme
FRE 404(b) prohibits prior bad acts to show propensity but permits them for other purposes such as intent, knowledge, motive, or common scheme.
Question 182: A 16-year-old minor went to a used car dealer with his aunt and grandmother. The minor purchased a used car in “as is” condition. The purchaser was listed as the minor; his relatives were not on the agreements. The boy discovered later that the drive shaft was bent and he returned the car with a demand for a refund of the $2,000 purchase price. The dealer refused to give a refund, citing the assistance and verbal assurances by the aunt and grandmother. They also gave him funds to make the purchase. Is the contract still voidable by the minor so that he can get a refund of the purchase price?
- The aunt and grandmother actually own the vehicle because they were the real parties in interest, and the dealer must return the money to them based on restitution.
- The participation in this case by the adults did not change the rule that a contract entered into by a minor is voidable by that minor – he’s entitled to a refund. (Correct answer)
- There is no refund and the contract was not voidable because the presence of the aunt and grandmother constituted an implied warranty of title.
- He’s entitled to a refund because the dealer committed fraud by not telling him about the defective drive shaft.
Correct answer: The participation in this case by the adults did not change the rule that a contract entered into by a minor is voidable by that minor – he’s entitled to a refund.
Contracts entered into by minors for non-necessities are generally voidable at the minor's election. The fact that the minor's aunt and grandmother were present and provided funds does not change the minor's legal capacity or his right to disaffirm the contract, as they were not parties to the agreement. Therefore, the 16-year-old minor can disaffirm the contract and demand a refund of the purchase price.
Question 183: An amateur golfer was playing in an amateur golf tournament. When she arrived at the ninth tee she found a new car with signs on it that said: "HOLE-IN-ONE Wins this 2014 luxury sedan.” The name of the a dealership appeared on the sign. Much to everyone’s amazement she inexplicably shot a hole-in-one. She attempted to claim her prize. The dealer refused, claiming that the car had been there from a charity tournament that was held two days earlier. The company admitted to neglecting to remove the car and posted no signs prior to the golfer’s hole-in-one. The golfer sued the dealership demanding delivery of the car. What is the likely decision of the court?
- The promoter of a prize-winning contest is not bound to award the prize to an outside individual who was not registered according to the contest rules.
- There was a mistake of fact between the parties and thus no contract could have been formed.
- The contract failed because there was no consideration for the offer to turn over a car and thus no right to expect performance of a gratuity.
- The golfer performed the act needed to win the prize, which in this case constituted an acceptance of the offer and the formation of an enforceable unilateral contract. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: The golfer performed the act needed to win the prize, which in this case constituted an acceptance of the offer and the formation of an enforceable unilateral contract.
The sign 'HOLE-IN-ONE Wins this 2014 luxury sedan' constituted a public offer for a unilateral contract, inviting acceptance by performance (shooting a hole-in-one). The golfer, seeing the sign, performed the requested act. The dealership's internal mistake about the car's purpose is irrelevant because the offer was publicly displayed and reasonably appeared to be a current offer. Upon performance, a binding contract was formed, obligating the dealership to deliver the prize.
Question 184: A forensic expert testifies about DNA evidence in a murder trial. The judge must determine if the expert's methodology is admissible under:
- The plain view doctrine
- The Frye general acceptance test only
- The Daubert standard, requiring reliability and relevance (Correct answer)
- FRE 403 balancing alone
Correct answer: The Daubert standard, requiring reliability and relevance
Under Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals and FRE 702, the judge acts as gatekeeper to ensure expert testimony is based on reliable methodology.
Question 185: Immediately after a shooting incident, the police chased one of the shooters into an apartment where he was apprehended and arrested. While in the apartment, a detective noticed some antique furniture that seemed of collectors’ quality and was out of place in the squalidly furnished quarters. He moved and turned over the pieces to look for markings and insignia. He called headquarters, and was told that items with those markings and descriptions were stolen from a museum six months earlier. He seized the items and arrested another occupant, who claimed he owned the items, on charges of burglary. That suspect filed a motion to suppress based on there being a warrantless search without probable cause. The police relied on the plain view doctrine. Will the court likely suppress the evidence?
- No, the evidence was subject to further search and seizure because it was in plain view and the officer had a reasonable suspicion that it was contraband.
- No, the evidence was properly seized because the officer had a right to investigate it further once he had properly entered the apartment under exigent circumstances.
- Yes, the evidence will be suppressed because the police can never search a personal residence or seize any unrelated items after entering for exigent circumstances dealing with something else.
- Yes, the evidence must be suppressed because the plain view doctrine does not apply where the officer had no probable cause to believe that the observed item was contraband. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Yes, the evidence must be suppressed because the plain view doctrine does not apply where the officer had no probable cause to believe that the observed item was contraband.
The plain view doctrine allows officers to seize evidence without a warrant if they are lawfully in the viewing area, the item is in plain view, and its incriminating character is immediately apparent. Here, while the officer was lawfully in the apartment, the antique furniture's incriminating character was not immediately apparent. He had to move and turn over the pieces and call headquarters to establish probable cause, which exceeded the scope of plain view.
Question 186: A criminal defendant was prosecuted for theft of tons of steel casings piled up on a vacant rural parcel of land. After taking the material, the authorities arrested him and told him that the land and the steel on it were owned by the state government. He defended on the basis that he did not have any criminal intent to steal because he reasonably believed that the steel casings were abandoned and rusting away needlessly. The judge instructed the jury that a man intends the natural consequences of his actions, and that if the defendant took the casings intentionally, then there was a presumption of sufficient mens rea to establish criminal intent. The act of taking in itself established a legal presumption of felonious intent. The defendant was convicted and he appealed on the basis that the judge’s applying of a presumption of criminal intent was erroneous. What is the likely decision on appeal?
- The presumption here invaded the fact-finding province of the jury and in effect applied a legal presumption of guilt simply from the act of taking the property. (Correct answer)
- The presumption of guilty intent was proper because it can never be an innocent act to take property simply because it appears to be abandoned.
- The presumption was improper because the court is not allowed to instruct the jury to make presumptions of any kind.
- The defendant could not have believed that so much steel was abandoned, and it was proper to apply a presumption of criminal intent by the fact of taking it.
Correct answer: The presumption here invaded the fact-finding province of the jury and in effect applied a legal presumption of guilt simply from the act of taking the property.
In criminal cases, a jury instruction that creates a mandatory presumption of an element of the crime, such as criminal intent (*mens rea*), based solely on proof of another element, violates the defendant's due process rights. Such a presumption unconstitutionally shifts the burden of proof to the defendant and invades the jury's exclusive role as fact-finder. The prosecution must prove every element of a crime beyond a reasonable doubt without the aid of such a presumption.
Question 187: A state statute provides that any public official found guilty of misconduct in office by his superiors should be permanently banned from holding any state employment or being appointed to any state office at any time in the future. Would the statute pass constitutional muster and why?
- The statute is a constitutional exercise of the police power.
- The statute is a constitutional statement of public policy.
- The statute is unconstitutional as a bill of attainder. (Correct answer)
- The statute is unconstitutional because it is void-for-vagueness.
Correct answer: The statute is unconstitutional as a bill of attainder.
A bill of attainder is a legislative act that singles out an individual or group for punishment without a judicial trial, which is expressly prohibited by the U.S. Constitution. This statute, by permanently banning 'any public official found guilty of misconduct by his superiors' from all state employment, constitutes a legislative determination of guilt and imposition of punishment without the safeguards of a judicial process. Therefore, it is unconstitutional as a bill of attainder.
Question 188: A paving company contracted with a retail store to pave the parking lot for a new store being built. It was scheduled to open in 60 days, and the paving company agreed to finish by then. Time was stated to be of the essence. However, there were numerous rainy days and, although the store opened on time, the paving was only partially completed. Some customers were inconvenienced and had to walk from nearby parking areas to get to the new store. The retailer sued the paving company for breach of contract, which included a demand for consequential damages for three weeks of partial lost profits. The store proved lower than projected customers, sales and profits but presented no evidence regarding causation. What is the most likely decision of the court after a bench trial on the issues?
- The court will not award lost profits because the store had plenty of time to hire a new paving company when it saw how many days were being missed due to rain.
- The court will not award lost profits because the fact of lower than projected figures is speculative, and it’s unclear that the paving company caused the losses. (Correct answer)
- Damages for lost profits will be awarded because time was of the essence and all foreseeable damages must be paid when a mandatory time provision is breached.
- Damages for lost profits will be awarded because the parties could foresee that profits would be lost if the paving was not finished on time.
Correct answer: The court will not award lost profits because the fact of lower than projected figures is speculative, and it’s unclear that the paving company caused the losses.
To recover consequential damages like lost profits, the plaintiff must prove with reasonable certainty that the damages were caused by the breach and were foreseeable at the time of contracting. Here, the store failed to present evidence of causation, meaning it couldn't definitively link the partial paving to the lower profits. Without clear proof that the paving company's delay directly caused the specific amount of lost profits, the damages are considered speculative and will not be awarded.
Question 189: A former patient sued her surgeon in a federal district court for medical malpractice arising out of an allegedly botched operation. She asked for both compensatory and punitive damages. The law of State A applies, but the State A does not recognize punitive damages in medical malpractice cases. The surgeon moves for summary judgment on the punitive damages count. The surgeon’s motion does not contain any affidavits, discovery or other factual evidence with respect to the punitive damages count. The motion is entitled "Motion for Summary Judgment Regarding Count 2.” It refers to the applicable State A statute, with a request for dismissal. The plaintiff does not respond to the summary judgment motion. Trial is approaching and the defendant surgeon requests a decision. What will the court decide and why?
- Grant the motion and dismiss the lawsuit because the plaintiff did not respond to the motion.
- Reject the motion because it has no supporting affidavits or other evidence.
- Reject the motion and order the jury to decide the issue of punitive damages.
- Grant the motion and dismiss the punitive damages complaint as a matter of law. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Grant the motion and dismiss the punitive damages complaint as a matter of law.
A court orders summary judgment if the pleadings, the discovery and disclosure materials on file, and any affidavits show that there is no genuine issue as to any material fact and that the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.” See F.R.C.P. 56(c). To survive summary judgment, there must be a “genuine issue as to any material fact.” If there is no genuine issue and “the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law,” summary judgment is granted. In this case, the answer is easy because the law precludes punitive damages so that the plaintiff could not allege any facts that would raise an issue of material fact, and most importantly, the defendant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. See, generally for standards required for summary judgment, Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317 (1986).
Question 190: A developer signed a contract to purchase 100 acres of land for construction of single-family dwellings. The land price was $100,000. The contract was contingent on approval of a subdivision plan being accepted by the township for 70 one-acre homes and 30 acres of open space. The subdivision plan was filed with the township but shortly thereafter, the township passed a zoning ordinance that increased the minimum size of building lots in rural areas to five acres per home, in order to preserve the rural nature of the countryside and prevent too much population growth. There was known to be little or no market for five-acre homes. The developer sued the township on the basis that the ordinance was not a reasonable use of the police powers and the property should revert to the original one-acre limitation. The county court denied the developer’s request for injunctive relief against the zoning board. Will the appellate court reverse the county court and issue an order declaring the new 5 acre rule to be an unreasonable and arbitrary use of the police power?
- No, because courts cannot interfere with the rights of local communities to set the minimum size of the lots that they prescribe.
- Yes, the reasonable limit for the size of lots is generally held to be 1 acre and anything above that is automatically prohibited in modern zoning laws.
- No, it is proper for a municipality to regulate the flow of growth and maintain certain areas as strictly rural, and they can usually go up to ten acres without any concern.
- Yes, because the new rule imposes too much of an arbitrary, unreasonable, and exclusionary burden on the use of the land, and is therefore an abuse of the reasonable use of the police power. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Yes, because the new rule imposes too much of an arbitrary, unreasonable, and exclusionary burden on the use of the land, and is therefore an abuse of the reasonable use of the police power.
While municipalities have broad police powers to enact zoning ordinances for public welfare, these ordinances must be reasonable and not arbitrary or unduly burdensome. A five-acre minimum lot size, especially when there's little market for such homes and it effectively prevents reasonable development, can be challenged as exclusionary zoning or an unreasonable exercise of police power. Courts may find such an ordinance to be an abuse of discretion if it serves primarily to exclude certain populations or is not rationally related to a legitimate public purpose.
Question 191: A police detective received an anonymous call that marijuana was being grown in someone’s home, but no other details were given. She went to the home with an investigative team including a drug-sniffing dog. On the front porch of the home the dog began pacing back and forth frantically, which indicated smelling illegal drugs. The team retreated while some of them went to get a warrant. A warrant was issued based on the dog’s behavior. The search inside revealed large quantities of marijuana. The homeowner was arrested. Through counsel, he filed a motion to suppress based on the assertion that the use of the dog was an illegal search without probable cause thus rendering the warrant invalid. Should the court suppress the evidence?
- Yes, because the anonymous call was insufficient cause to allow for a search of the front porch with the dog, which made the warrant invalid – the suppression motion will be granted. (Correct answer)
- No, because the detective had probable cause after receiving the anonymous call, which justified the use of the dog for a valid search -- the warrant was thus valid and the evidence will not be suppressed.
- No, because the detective had a right to take the dog to make a reasonable search, which led to the finding of probable cause and the issuance of a valid warrant.
- Yes, because the dog’s reaction did nothing to tell them that there were drugs inside – a warrant can never be based on a dog’s information.
Correct answer: Yes, because the anonymous call was insufficient cause to allow for a search of the front porch with the dog, which made the warrant invalid – the suppression motion will be granted.
An anonymous call with insufficient detail of the underlying circumstances did not establish probable cause. The taking of the dog to the front porch was an intrusion against the property interests of the owner. The home stands at the core of protection under the Fourth Amendment. The curtilage is part of the home itself. This was an illegal search of the curtilage of the home, making the warrant illegal also. See Florida v. Jardines, 569 U. S. ____ (2013).
Question 192: Several landowners had residential premises in a development called “The Lakes.” One owner’s property contained a small improved beach area that could be used for swimming. That owner gave oral permission to several neighbors to use the beachfront for swimming, as a friendly neighborly gesture. That owner sold her property to a new owner. The new owner erected fences and signs saying, “keep out.” The neighbors sued, claiming that they had an easement by implication through prior usage to use the beachfront. Will the court restore the use of the beachfront to the neighbors?
- Yes, because the granting of a license to use one’s property to perform a certain activity usually ripens into an easement if the use is regular and continual.
- No, because land that abuts a lake or other body of water is not subject to the creation of an easement.
- Yes, because the easement was created by the implied assent of the owner and her neighbors, and it became a public easement through prescription.
- No, because the use granted was merely a license to go on a neighbor’s land to go swimming, and the users of the free license did not expect that they were obtaining an interest in the land. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: No, because the use granted was merely a license to go on a neighbor’s land to go swimming, and the users of the free license did not expect that they were obtaining an interest in the land.
The oral permission granted to the neighbors for swimming was merely a license, which is a revocable privilege to use another's land, not an interest in the land itself. Licenses are typically informal and personal, and they are generally revoked upon the transfer of the servient estate or by the licensor's express act. Since the use was granted as a "friendly neighborly gesture" and was not intended to create a permanent property right, it did not ripen into an easement by implication or prescription, which requires more stringent conditions.
Question 193: A motorist is making a left turn at a traffic light. When the light turns yellow he waits a second and decides to try and rush through the left turn. He is hit broadside by a car traveling through the intersection with the right of way. The investigating police officer points out the sign above the light that informs motorists to make a “left turn on signal only,” meaning that there was a left turn arrow that he was supposed to wait for prior to negotiating the turn. The officer gives him a ticket for “improper left turn.” The motorist pays the ticket. The other driver was severely injured and sues the motorist for negligence. The injured driver asserts in the complaint that the violation of the traffic ordinance is proof of “negligence per se.” Will the court instruct the jury that there was negligence per se?
- Yes, because the ordinance that was violated was intended to avoid the precise harm that occurred. (Correct answer)
- No, because a violation of a traffic ordinance never can be used as proof of negligence.
- No, because the violation of the ordinance under these facts did not support the claim that the motorist caused the accident.
- Yes, because the violation of a traffic ordinance is always proof that the defendant caused the accident.
Correct answer: Yes, because the ordinance that was violated was intended to avoid the precise harm that occurred.
Negligence per se applies when a defendant violates a statute or ordinance, and the plaintiff is a member of the class of persons the statute was designed to protect, and the injury is of the type the statute was designed to prevent. Here, the "left turn on signal only" ordinance is specifically intended to prevent collisions at intersections by regulating turns, which is precisely the harm that occurred when the motorist rushed the turn. Therefore, violating this ordinance is strong evidence of negligence.
Question 194: A group of high school teenagers attended an all-night rave party at a local dance hall. The driver of the group purchased and took several ecstasy pills while there. When she attempted to drive home the next morning, she fell asleep and crashed into a tree, killing one passenger. She tested positive for ecstasy. The owner had rented the facility for the evening to a private group of college students. The owner kept its employees on the premises for security. The owner took numerous steps to prevent drug use, including searching attendees, confiscating drugs, and evicting drug dealers. The estate of the deceased teen sued the owner of the dance hall. The owner filed a motion to dismiss because it asserted no legal duty owed to the decedent. The plaintiff argued that the owner should not be allowed to use its facility for an all-night party, and that it was highly foreseeable that teen drivers and passengers would be put at risk. Will the court likely grant the motion to dismiss?
- Yes, because a property owner is never liable to groups or individuals who rent the property for short periods.
- Yes, because the owner did not actively run the party and did not distribute drugs to the attendees. (Correct answer)
- No, because the owner did owe a duty to protect the users of its facility from danger.
- No, because rave parties are inherently dangerous and the foreseeability factor creates a duty owed by the owner to the attendees.
Correct answer: Yes, because the owner did not actively run the party and did not distribute drugs to the attendees.
A property owner generally owes a duty to keep their premises reasonably safe for invitees. However, when a facility is rented to a private group, the owner's duty may be limited, especially if they are not actively involved in running the event or promoting the dangerous activity. Here, the owner took reasonable steps to prevent drug use and did not actively participate in or promote the party, thus limiting their liability for the actions of the private group's attendees. The owner's efforts to prevent drug use further demonstrate a lack of direct culpability for the specific incident.
Question 195: A defendant timely removes a case from state court to federal court. The plaintiff believes removal was improper. Under 28 U.S.C. § 1447(c), the plaintiff must file a motion to remand based on a defect in removal procedure within:
- 14 days of removal
- 30 days of removal (Correct answer)
- 60 days of removal
- 21 days of removal
Correct answer: 30 days of removal
Under § 1447(c), a motion to remand based on any defect other than lack of subject matter jurisdiction must be made within 30 days after the filing of the notice of removal.
Question 196: A seller of residential property told the buyer that he could use his gravel road to the main highway if he purchased the property, which adjoined the seller’s property. Although the property was not otherwise landlocked, the buyer relied on the seller’s promise in making an offer. The buyer had specific uses in mind for improvements that needed the gravel road. The purchase took place but the seller did not include the easement in the deed or the other papers. The buyer built a garage that accessed the gravel road leading to the highway. The seller later decided to fence off the driveway and divert it from buyer’s use. Will a court compel the seller to open up the road and provide an easement to the buyer?
- No, because the buyer was careless in not putting the agreement in writing at the time of the closing.
- Yes, because this was an easement by estoppel, created by the seller’s promises and relied upon by the buyer. (Correct answer)
- No, because there were other roads to get in and out, and this was not a necessity.
- Yes, because any road that goes over or next to the buyer’s lot is a part of the buyer’s property, and is considered a prescriptive easement.
Correct answer: Yes, because this was an easement by estoppel, created by the seller’s promises and relied upon by the buyer.
An easement by estoppel can arise when a landowner makes a representation concerning the use of their land, another party reasonably and detrimentally relies on that representation, and injustice can only be avoided by enforcing the promise. Here, the seller's promise of road access, coupled with the buyer's reliance in purchasing the property and building a garage, creates an equitable easement that prevents the seller from later denying access.
Question 197: An auto retailer started a marketing promotion on a new hybrid model sedan. It advertised that anyone who purchased the car in 2013 and did not get at least 50 miles per gallon average gas mileage during the first 60 days, would receive a payment of $10,000 cash from the company. Record-keeping and inspection procedures were required to assure accurate reporting by the vehicle owner. The promotion was widely publicized. A female customer purchased a hybrid model during the promotion period, followed all the rules, and recorded only 42 mpg in the first 60 days. She demanded the rebate but the company stalled for months and then stopped responding to her inquiries. Does she have a contractual right to collect the $10,000?
- No, because she did not formally notify the company that she was accepting the offer before she started performing.
- Yes, this was a unilateral contract in which the offeree acted upon the offer by performing the terms of the offer, thus creating a binding contract. (Correct answer)
- No, this was merely puffing, was not an offer to contract with any particular person and was without consideration.
- Yes, because this is a classic bilateral contract, making it necessary that the company live up to its set of promises made to her.
Correct answer: Yes, this was a unilateral contract in which the offeree acted upon the offer by performing the terms of the offer, thus creating a binding contract.
This scenario describes a unilateral contract, where an offer invites acceptance by performance rather than a promise. The auto retailer made a clear offer promising $10,000 for a specific performance: purchasing the car, following the rules, and achieving less than 50 mpg. The customer's actions of purchasing the car, adhering to the rules, and recording the mileage constituted the requested performance, thereby accepting the offer and creating a binding contract.
Question 198: A plaintiff sues a corporation in federal court. The plaintiff's attorney seeks to depose the corporation. Under FRCP 30(b)(6), the corporation must:
- Allow the plaintiff to choose which employee to depose
- Produce written answers to deposition questions in lieu of an oral deposition
- Produce its CEO or highest-ranking officer
- Designate one or more representatives who will testify on the organization's behalf (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Designate one or more representatives who will testify on the organization's behalf
Under FRCP 30(b)(6), a corporation must designate one or more representatives who will testify on its behalf as to matters described in the deposition notice.
Question 199: A group of high school teenagers attended an all-night rave party at a local dance hall. The driver of the group purchased and took several ecstasy pills while there. When she attempted to drive home the next morning, she fell asleep and crashed into a tree, killing one passenger. She tested positive for ecstasy. The owner had rented the facility for the evening to a private group of college students. The owner kept its employees on the premises for security. The owner took numerous steps to prevent drug use, including searching attendees, confiscating drugs, and evicting drug dealers. The estate of the deceased teen sued the owner of the dance hall. The owner filed a motion to dismiss because it asserted no legal duty owed to the decedent. The plaintiff argued that the owner should not be allowed to use its facility for an all-night party, and that it was highly foreseeable that teen drivers and passengers would be put at risk. Will the court likely grant the motion to dismiss?
- No, because rave parties are inherently dangerous and the foreseeability factor creates a duty owed by the owner to the attendees.
- Yes, because a property owner is never liable to groups or individuals who rent the property for short periods.
- No, because the owner did owe a duty to protect the users of its facility from danger.
- Yes, because the owner did not actively run the party and did not distribute drugs to the attendees. (Correct answer)
Correct answer: Yes, because the owner did not actively run the party and did not distribute drugs to the attendees.
Simply providing the venue for a party without actively providing intoxicants or drugs is not enough to raise a legal duty to the attendees. See Sakiyama v. AMF Bowling Centers, Inc., 1 Cal. Rptr. 3d 762, 768, 110 Cal.App.4th 398 (CA Ct. of Appeal, 2d App. Distr. 2003). Foreseeability does not alone establish a legal duty; there are other factors to weigh, including public policy factors. Thus, defendants who simply provide venues for drinking alcohol or raves where ecstasy may be used do not owe a duty of care to plaintiffs killed or injured by guests despite the foreseeability of car accidents. Id. 772-73. Furnishing drugs would make a difference but that did not happen here. Accord, Looby v. Local 13 Productions, 751 A.2d 220 (Pa.Super. 2000).
Question 200: A defendant shoots at A intending to kill him, but misses and kills B. Which doctrine allows the defendant to be charged with murdering B?
- Felony murder rule
- Constructive intent
- Transferred intent (Correct answer)
- Vicarious liability
Correct answer: Transferred intent
Under the transferred intent doctrine, the defendant's intent to kill A transfers to the unintended victim B, making him liable for B's murder.
Multistate Bar Examination (MBE)
The MBE is a 200-question, multiple-choice examination administered over six hours on one day of the bar examination. It covers fundamental legal principles.
Exam Rules
- You can skip questions and return to them later
- Flag questions for review before submitting
- No feedback shown until you submit the entire exam
- Unanswered questions count as wrong — answer everything
- 10 pretest questions are mixed in and don't affect your score
- Timer auto-submits when time runs out
- Your progress is auto-saved every 30 seconds
Practice questions written with AI assistance and published by Nathan Beja, founder of Practice Test Geeks. They are not real exam questions. Exam facts are checked against the official sources linked below. Editorial policy
Sources & references
Exam facts on this page (fees, format, dates, passing scores) are checked against these official sources; the date is our last check. Editorial policy
- ncbex.org — Fees, score validity, eligibility, exam dates, score release, passing score, exam format, test dates · verified Oct 2026