Is the SHSAT really as hard as everyone says it is?

by Jessica L. 4 views3 replies
J
Jessica L.OP
May 27, 2026

My daughter is in 7th grade and we just started looking into the specialized high schools for next fall. Honestly I had no idea how competitive this whole process was until her teacher mentioned it last month. We're kind of late to the game — most kids in her class have apparently been prepping since 5th grade, which, wow.

She took a shsat practice test last week just to get a baseline and scored around 480. From what I can tell with the shsat score calculator on a few different sites, that's not going to get her into Stuyvesant or Bronx Science, but maybe one of the lower-cutoff schools? We've been doing the SHSAT English Practice Test sections together in the evenings and her reading comp is actually pretty solid — it's the scrambled paragraphs that are killing her.

Has anyone been through this recently? How many hours a week did your kid actually study? And is the test nav shsat practice test on the DOE website worth using, or should we be looking at outside prep? Any advice from parents who've done this would be really appreciated.

S
Samantha C.
May 28, 2026
We went through this two years ago with my son. Honestly 480 in October of 7th grade is not bad at all — he was scoring around 460 when we started and ended up with a 528 on test day. The test nav shsat practice test is fine for getting used to the interface but the questions aren't as hard as the real thing. We used a tutor twice a week plus he'd do shsat prep test online sessions on his own maybe 3-4 nights. The scrambled paragraphs just take repetition, there's no shortcut.
C
Chloe W.
May 28, 2026
Quick note — have you looked into which specialized high school that doesn't require shsat might be a fit? LaGuardia takes auditions/portfolios and some of the other specialized schools use different criteria. We ended up pivoting to that route when my son's SHSAT score just missed the cutoffs. It's worth having a backup plan running parallel to the test prep, not as a consolation but as a real option.
S
Sarah M.
May 28, 2026
480 with months still to go is totally workable. My daughter jumped almost 90 points between her first practice test and the real exam — most of that came from mastering the math grid-ins. Check out the SHSAT Math Practice section here, it was genuinely useful for her. Don't panic yet.

Join the Discussion

Sign in or register to reply with your account, or reply as a guest below.