FE-1 Constitutional Law 2

Question 1

What is the constitutional significance of the Supreme Court decision in A v Governor of Arbour Hill Prison [2006]?

Accepted Answer

A declaration that a statute is unconstitutional does not automatically invalidate all past convictions under it — the courts can limit the retrospective effect of constitutional invalidity

Answer

In A v Governor of Arbour Hill Prison, the Supreme Court held that a declaration of unconstitutionality does not necessarily lead to immediate release of all those previously convicted under the invalid law. The court balanced constitutional rights against the public interest.

Question 2

What does Article 50 of the Irish Constitution provide regarding pre-1937 laws?

Accepted Answer

Laws in force immediately before the Constitution came into operation continue to apply to the extent they are not inconsistent with the Constitution

Answer

Article 50 ensures continuity by preserving pre-1937 laws (including British statutes applicable to Ireland) subject to their consistency with the Constitution. Inconsistent provisions are deemed to have been repealed.

Question 3

What is the constitutional status of international treaties in Ireland under Article 29.6?

Accepted Answer

International agreements do not form part of domestic law unless the Oireachtas passes legislation to incorporate them

Answer

Article 29.6 provides that no international agreement shall be part of domestic law except as determined by the Oireachtas. This is the 'dualist' approach — international law and domestic law are separate systems requiring a bridge.

Question 4

What does the constitutional guarantee of equality under Article 40.1 actually provide?

Accepted Answer

All citizens as human persons shall be held equal before the law — but the State may have due regard to differences of capacity, physical and moral, and of social function

Answer

Article 40.1 guarantees equality before the law as human persons while allowing distinctions based on capacity and social function. This is a formal equality guarantee that does not prohibit all differential treatment, as affirmed in Quinn's Supermarket v AG [1972].

Question 5

What is the constitutional basis for judicial review of administrative decisions in Ireland?

Accepted Answer

Article 34, which vests judicial power in the courts, and the constitutional obligation of fairness derived from natural justice principles

Answer

Judicial review flows from Article 34's vesting of judicial power in courts and the constitutional requirement for fair procedures. The courts have held that administrative bodies exercising public power must comply with constitutional justice.

FE-1 Practice Test

FE-1 Practice Test

FE-1 Constitutional Law 2